I have to respectfully disagree with the "Sharing" post, and have to express my amazement at "Trem bashing" on some of the other posts. This is posted on list in support of one of our list members who has contributed, and his contributions are very much appreciated.
First of all, Bob, I very much look forward to your posts, as they usually will have something of substance to say, unlike so many of the posts on this list. When I am blasting away the dozens of post a day which don't look like they have much to do with cs, I am always sure to save those from Tai-Pan. Thanks for all your input. Yes, this list is about input and sharing, not just greedy taking and hiding. I must point out that Trem has shared. (I know your that your post does not state Trem by name, but it appears to be in connection to the other posts in conversations with Trem. If I am in error, please post and state so.) He has told us his basic theory, the amperage he uses, and why he uses that amperage. What more can anyone ask? And compare that with the contributions of Water Oz? Water Oz contributes nothing. They are the knowledge takers (they did not invent colloidal silver), not the contributors. As for the publishing of the original idea, I would have to disagree with the representation that it gives anyone any legal leg to stand on. I, too, have been in R&D, have had to be involved in the patenting of intellectual property, and the decision to publish, or not to publish. Regardless of the law, reality is that your protection is only as good as the size of your bank account for lawyers. This is often why publishing is used instead of patenting. A patent gives all the info about intellectual property, so anyone can copy it and use it to compete against you. Publishing, on the other hand, only gives you one year of rights from the date of publishing. After that, if a patent is not applied for, it is public domain, and the only benefit to publishing is to stop someone else from patenting. For example, a chemical process is often published in Timbuktu, or somewhere out of the way so the competition will not find it. This is because it is nearly impossible to stop a competitor form using your process, as he can keep you out of his plant so you cannot easily prove his stepping on your patent rights. If someone does try to patent the process and stop you from using your own process, the publishing shows that you had it first. But after one year it is public domain, and anyone can use it for profit. As for circuits, many are sold without a schematic, and if you want to know how they work you will need to reverse engineer. Moral of the story: If Trem, or anyone else, publishes anything which may be proprietary, it sets the clock ticking on his rights. Most often there is neither patenting nor publishing. The greatest protection, especially for small companies without the ability to afford high dollar lawsuits, is often in the form of silence. Let us remember, Trem asked Mike before posting about his process. If anyone thinks he has no place on this list, they need to say it to Mike, as I was his decision to allow the post, and a proper decision too. Thanks, Bob, as your posts have been very useful and educational. Your posts on current density got me to begin the making of a current regulating system, or actually a current density regulating system. I was trying to do so with a 10000 volt system with limited success. I did learn a lot in the process, though. I believe it can be properly done, and I will probably continue that line of development at a later date. Thanks Trem, as you have given me the encouragement to go ahead with a current regulating system. It is different than what I was trying to make previously. You have given me enough information to make the dc system I am about to finish. My local electronics shop set me up very nicely with a power supply with the ability to voltage regulate within a current range, or to current regulate within a voltage range. I also bought a small used dc motor drive with current limiting capability. The circuit needs to be reworked to allow more accurate limiting at the low amperage, but for $25 I got a lot of capability to play with (up to 180vdc output!). BTW, I very much respect the fact that you want to keep some things proprietary, and very much appreciate the fact that you are even willing to talk about the rest of your system theory on this list. While keeping your circuit your own business, you have given enough information out that any DIY can make a dc current limiting cs generator. That is a very good and thoughtful contribution, and nobody has the right to ask more. Yes, we are aware of the bashing you are getting on some of the other postings. Don't let their poor attitudes get to you. Some people simply cannot be pleased. Be well, all, Jim Tai-Pan wrote: > Greetings virtuous CSers, > > This is a wonderful list, because we have all given it our input of > ideas and shared the results of those ideas. Each of us has benefited by > receiving and giving of thoughts and ideas, which have formed new ideas > and so forth. > When anyone comes amoung us and joins in the using of our ideas and > then will not share the result it is utterly disgusting. Its an insult > to the listers who work hard and spend much of their time experimenting > and testing new ideas and ways of making CS. Its a slap in the face and > those who take but will not give have no place here. > I have heard the word *proprietary* used many times as an excuse to > not share. Proprietary is only applicable to chemical formulas, > medicines, and processes, not to machines or physical devices. The only > way to keep a machine proprietary is to maintain complete control of it. > Never sell it or let another person use it out of your sight. It must > never leave the control of the proprietor. The proprietor can only sell > the product of the machine. > Patents are given to protect the *right to make a profit* from a > machine or idea. By receiving a patent the machine becomes public > knowledge and may be used by anyone, but not for profit. The public can > see that the patent has been infringed and usually report it to the > patent holder. If its used for profit the patent holder can take you to > court. When a patent is given the contents of the patent are NO longer > proprietary. It has been revealed to the public eye. > If you publish (write about) something such as a better way to do > something and someone comes along and uses it in a patent you can claim > royalties, since your ideas have been used in the patent. (wait until > there is money to claim). The fact that a person has written (published > in view of all) about something gives a legal leg to stand on as the > originator of an idea. Many of the listers have written about things > that were original to them. It is noted that the people who are talking > *proprietary* have never posted (written in public view,published) > anything original on this list. Hummm--why is that. Leting us do their > research for them? The best way to claim an original idea is to write > about it (publish in view of the public) so as to show that you thought > of it first. > Rarely a patent holder will try to hide details so that an originator > will not see that his ideas are being used. The courts will not allow > hiding of details, its been tried. > I have worked in many industries where the way of doing things was > kept secret by the use of *non discloser* forms an employee had to sign, > and in some cases not allowed to even work in a related industry for a > specified number of years. > If anyone is concerned that the listers will see what their ideas are > being used for, shame on them. We are here to combine and share our pool > of knowledge, not take and hide it from the contributors. We appreciate > that a profit is how people live. So show that your way is better, and > its your origninal idea, there will always be those who prefer to buy a > good product (machine or CS) rather than make their own. Maintain good > will by showing how good their ideas are and how you have used it to > make a better product for them (hey- marketing guys,where are you). > Look at WaterOz as an example. They DO NOT sell the proprietary > machine they make their CS with. And won`t even tell how it works or the > process they go through. They do sell standard CS making machines, > details of which are available it you really want to make your own. All > perfectly legal and proper. People buy their products because they are > as advertized. They do their own research and have excellent marketing > skills. Thats what it takes. > > Bless you Bob Lee > -- > oozing on the muggy shore of the gulf coast > [email protected] > > -- > The silver-list is a moderated forum for discussion of colloidal silver. > > To join or quit silver-list or silver-digest send an e-mail message to: > [email protected] -or- [email protected] > with the word subscribe or unsubscribe in the SUBJECT line. > > To post, address your message to: [email protected] > > List maintainer: Mike Devour <[email protected]> -- The silver-list is a moderated forum for discussion of colloidal silver. To join or quit silver-list or silver-digest send an e-mail message to: [email protected] -or- [email protected] with the word subscribe or unsubscribe in the SUBJECT line. To post, address your message to: [email protected] List maintainer: Mike Devour <[email protected]>

