DEFENSE DEPARTMENT FACES HUGE PROBLEM OVER ANTHRAX VACCINATIONS ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Edited by Bill Rogers Email: [email protected]
The controversy over the safety of anthrax vaccinations ordered by the Defense Department for all service members is heating up as more and more people either refuse to take their shots or quit the service. Anthrax is considered a major biological warfare threat. So far about 330,000 of the 2,500,000 people in uniform have received at least the first of six shots. But anthrax shots are becoming a serious morale and readiness problem, to say nothing of a health problem. CBS News interviewed more than 100 Air Force Reserve and Air National Guard pilots and reported on July 26 so many pilots are quitting over this issue that there are "huge holes in some military air units." Key units stand to lose up to half their pilots, and at just five bases more than 100 reserve pilots quit this year, CBS said. "The squadron is unable to do its peacetime and wartime mission, and this directly impacts the nation's readiness," Maj. Ramona Savoie declared. She is one who quit. The recent campaign in the Balkans demonstrates the need for Reserve and Guard forces whenever the Air Force makes any substantial effort, so the loss of many experienced pilots will have a serious impact on readiness of U.S. forces. The Defense Department insists that the vaccine is safe and effective and that the program is going smoothly, but memos obtained by CBS tell a different story. One squadron commander wrote, "Due to the controversy regarding the shots, compliance has been very low." Another commander acknowledged that "We are losing a lot of experience." Many Guard and Reserve pilots also fly for the airlines, and some have quit for fear that side effects of the shots would put their civilian flying career at risk -- or their passengers. "Would you want your pilot to have any problem with remembering, and tremors, seizures? This is all stuff that's attributed to the vaccine," Mike Angerole said. He flies for Southwest Airlines and is among those quitting the Air Guard. Two bills have just been introduced in Congress that would address concerns about the anthrax vaccinations. On July 19, Rep. Benjamin Gilman, New York Republican, introduced H.R. 2548, which would suspend the vaccination program until the vaccine is determined to be safe and effective and to provide for a study by the National Institutes of Health. The other, H.R. 2543, introduced by Rep. Walter Jones, a North Carolina Republican, would make the shots voluntary. Gilman's bill directs the National Institutes of Health to see that an independent study is done to determine the types and severity of adverse reactions and long-term health implications. The study would also determine the effectiveness of the vaccine in protecting humans against all strains of anthrax pathogens that U.S. military personnel are likely to encounter. The Defense Department opposes requests to make the shots voluntary, is not granting exceptions to the requirement to take shots, and, as it finds itself getting deeper into this controversy, seems to be hardening its position. Defense Secretary William Cohen recently wrote in a letter to Army Times, "Just as soldiers must wear helmets, commanders must know all their troops are vaccinated against anthrax." And the Pentagon says the shots will continue no matter how many pilots quit. It launched a campaign to convince the troops that the vaccine is safe, but Mark Zaid, a Washington attorney who has represented at least two dozen service members who have refused the shots, said the education effort was handled poorly and backfired on DOD. He believes DOD is so embarrassed about the matter that it won't back away and thereby admit to mistakes. "They'll go kicking and screaming until the last possible second" when they are forced to change the vaccination policy, he said. Zaid, who had been working on Gulf War Syndrome issues, started getting calls right after the shots started in March 1998. He said at first people were usually just given a general discharge, then occasionally an other-than-honorable discharge, and now more frequently a court martial. The Marine Corps has been giving courts martial more than the other services. In the active duty forces, it is mostly lower ranking enlisted people who refuse, while in the reserve forces, captains, majors and colonels are refusing and quitting. He noted that emergency-essential civilians in DOD must also take the shots, and half a dozen senior civilians in the Military Sealift Command have been fired. What should service members do? "Tough decision. I don't know," Zaid answered. "I have never given anybody advice about what they should do. I always tell them they need to talk it over with family and friends. If you decide to refuse it, come back to me and I will do what I can to help. "The only thing I have given as far as advice was that if you are going to refuse the vaccine, and that is your final decision, then don't accept an Article 15 nonjudicial punishment. That makes no sense. Just ask to be administratively separated or request a court martial. You are going to end up at one or the other anyway, so why drag the process out? Why drag the process out, why get demoted, why get fined, why get ostracized in the meantime?" "We identified so many errors in the [DOD] public statements, in their literature where they are trying to convince people how safe it is." Zaid told SFTT he has internal documentation from the Defense Department that contradicts much of what was being said publicly. He accused public affairs officers of being deliberately deceptive in discussing the facts about the vaccine. Secretary of the Army Louis Caldera acknowledged the risks in a memo obtained and published by the San Diego Union-Tribune on June 29. The vaccine, according to a memo signed by Caldera, "involves unusually hazardous risks associated with the potential for adverse reactions in some recipients and the possibility that the desired immunological effect will not be obtained by all recipients." In September 1998 he agreed to accept the burden of potential liability claims made against the vaccine manufacturer by service members. At the same time DOD was conducting a campaign to convince the troops that the vaccine is safe. Rep. Gilman and five other members of Congress -- Christopher Shays, Sue Kelly, Mark Souder, Doug Ose and James Talent -- sent Secretary Cohen a letter on July 20 asking him to answer a series of pointed questions and noting that they were receiving "an increasing number of contacts from concerned constituents..." They wrote that Cohen had pledged that four specific conditions would be met before vaccinations would start, and charged that testimony in Congressional hearings has shown that "none of these conditions was satisfactorily addressed before the vaccine program was implemented." The conditions were: 1) supplemental testing to assure sterility, safety, potency and purity of the vaccine stockpile; 2) implementation of a system for fully tracking anthrax immunizations; 3) approval of operational plans to administer the vaccine and communications plans to inform military personnel; and 4) review of medical aspects of the program by an independent expert. They noted that the Defense Department had cited Food and Drug Administration approval of anthrax vaccine, but pointed out that FDA had approved a vaccine for workers in the woolen industry. A weaponized version of anthrax, meant to be inhaled by victims, is different and there has been little or no testing of the vaccine's effectiveness in humans against this form of anthrax for obvious reasons. Testing on animals had mixed results. The members of Congress said they have yet to see any evidence that this vaccine would be effective against altered or multiple strains of anthrax, which the Russians are known to have experimented with, and further noted "extremely poor performance of the vaccine against even individual multiple strains in the Ft. Detrick guinea pig studies..." Safety of the vaccine is another of their concerns. They argue that not enough is known yet to safely administer it to 2.5 million people. If only 2 percent of the people experience adverse reactions, that would be 50,000 people -- an unacceptably high number. And, in addition, it's "completely unknown what will be the effect of cumulative annual boosters, let alone the combined effects from 15 or so other biological warfare vaccines under development." They are also concerned about the plant that produces the vaccine, which has been repeatedly cited by the FDA for quality control problems and other violations dating to 1990. The facility closed "voluntarily" in March 1998 to make $1.8 million in renovations and a $15 million expansion funded by DOD. The letter to Cohen notes that at a briefing following an April 29 subcommittee hearing, it was stated that the vaccine "is dangerous enough the manufacturer demanded, and received, indemnification from the Army against the possibility that persons vaccinated may develop anaphylaxis or some unforseen reaction of serious consequences, including death." Why was DOD so quick to say the vaccine is safe? the writers asked. A point is also raised about several reports of troops receiving shots (during the Gulf War) from expired lots of vaccine, "to the significant detriment of their health as recorded in testimony and the media." Cohen was asked what is being done to prevent this from happening again. He was also asked about reports that persons giving the shots have failed to make sure they were not giving shots to people who shouldn't get them for such reasons as illness, pregnancy or previous adverse reactions. "Likewise, we are also concerned that the reporting of adverse reactions among troops who have received the vaccine, is being discouraged, so as not to cause undue alarm in those units which have not received their first round of shots." Cohen is asked about reports that when reserve component personnel express an interest in leaving the service they meet "with delays, instructions to not list the vaccine as a reason, and even threats of poor evaluation reports." He is asked to provide assurances that these repressions will not occur in the future. The writers conclude by expressing concern about the impact of all of this on morale and the need to ensure that the vaccine "is not itself a more real threat to our citizens in uniform." Another in a series of hearings in Congress about anthrax was held on July 21. Several military people who have suffered serious reactions to the shots testified before sympathetic members of the Subcommittee on National security, Veterans Affairs and International Relations, chaired by Rep. Christopher Shays. Their tales are disturbing. Captain Michelle Piel is an Air Force Academy graduate and C-5 pilot at Dover AFB, Delaware. She was healthy and actively flying last October when she received her first shot. Shortly afterwards while flying back from an overseas mission, "the right side of my head filled up with fluid," she said. When she landed, a flight surgeon grounded her. In about three weeks she had recovered and took the second shot and immediately felt ill again. She experienced fatigue, dizziness, nausea, and blurred vision, joint pain and colds. She missed weeks of duty and was examined by a dozen doctors who could not explain what the problem was. She is better now, but still suffering from something and has periods of regression. Doctors wanted her to take further anthrax shots to see what would happen, but she refused. Though she was too sick to fly, the Air Force did not want to file a report of an adverse reaction to the vaccination. After many months her wing commander got her to specialists at Walter Reed Army Medical Center who were able to help her. The wing commander suspended the program at Dover, and that stirred tremendous repercussions, she said. "Everyone I spoke to at Dover AFB recognized that our wing commander sacrificed his career for us." The captain told the committee she was testifying because she firmly believes "that our military's health is critical to our nation's warfighting readiness." Another pilot, a reservist at Dover, Jon Richter, testified to severe health problems that started right after his shot. He said his hip joints cause great discomfort now and he never had any problems before. He told the committee he would rather walk away from the military rather than take another shot. "I have defended my country and I have obeyed the orders of the officers over me, but taking another anthrax shot is not an order I can carry out," he declared. A side issue involves freedom of speech for those who see a need to express their concerns. An Air Force nurse on Okinawa, Captain Debra Egan, wrote in Stars and Stripes of her concern as a health professional over the vaccinations, and now says there have been retributions against her for speaking out. The military paper has come to her defense. Other service members are claiming there is pressure not to go public with this issue. It is clear that refusal to take the shots is career-ending, no matter what else happens. Shays called taking the vaccine "a profoundly personal choice, whether or not to put something in their bodies they fear may do more harm than good. After military service, the uniform comes off, but the anthrax vaccine stays with you for life. It's just not the commitment many dedicated men and women made to their country when they volunteered for military service." He pledged to stick with this issue and other toxic battlefield concerns. "We will follow it until we are sure medical force protection means assuring the long term health of U.S. forces, not just short-term mission capability." "DoD needs to revise its policy and stop force-wide immunization," Zaid said. Whether the shots become voluntary or just for select, high-risk groups, he thinks they are unjustified for all service personnel. He said a lot of the 2.5 million people are permanently stationed stateside in areas that are not high risk, and don't need the shots. But then he offered an unsettling thought to the interviewer: " You and I should be inoculated before a lot of the military people for being here in the D.C. area." ************************************************************************ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

