In a message dated 4/1/01 6:00:26 PM EST, [email protected] writes:

<< Subj:     Re: CS>Model to Explain Charge Buildup for LVDC CS 
Electrochemical Reactions
 Date:  4/1/01 6:00:26 PM EST
 From:  [email protected] (Ivan Anderson)
 Reply-to:  [email protected]
 To:    [email protected]
 
 Roger,
 
 I did detail reaction (2) in my last post:
 reaction (2) is 2H2O ---> [2H+] + O2(g) + 4e    -0.42 + -0.60 = -1.42

Ivan: How is the over voltage of reaction (2) related to the reaction below?

4OH- ------> 2H2O + O2(g) + 4e   E(o) = -0.40

 The over-voltage required by H and O is due to the extra energy required
 to rip these elements from the water (or so it has been explained to
 me).
 
 I think that the pH does rise somewhat, but is possible that the OH-
 reacts with Ag+ arriving at the cathode to form AgOH or is adsorbed to
 the elemental silver particles attached to the cathode, and is
 essentially pulled out of solution.
 
 >>>I believe this phenomenon is duplicated in reverse when, an EMF is
 IMPRESSED on two silver wire electrodes. Silver "ions" are produced at
 one electrode and hydrogen gas (at least initially) is produced at the
 other. Just as zinc ions are produced in one beaker WITH NO BALANCING
 NEGATIVE ION, silver "ions" are produced at the anode WITH NO BALANCING
 NEGATIVE ION because hydrogen is also released as a gas just as it
 occurs in the zinc/hydrogen battery example. This charge imbalance is
 transferred to the silver "ions", and since Frank has demonstrated that
 practically all electrolytic LVDC CS processes generated a mixture of
 ions and particles, it is likely that particulate silver combines with
 ionic silver and the combination of the two holds the charger in
 question.<<<
 
 I agree that there is no requirement for the charge of the solution to
 be neutral, only that the electrical laws be followed ie. that for every
 electron supplied at one end of the circuit one must be withdrawn at the
 other.

Ivan: No argument there. However, if you consider the "no salt bridge" 
experiment I outlined with a zinc and a hydrogen electrode, charge balance is 
maintained as long as you add up the charges in each beaker. However, the 
electrochemical reactions will be unable to progress beyond the point where 
the EMF driving each half cell reactions equals the EMF produced by the 
(algebraic sum of the) charge imbalance within each beaker.
 
I am not sure that I agree that, as in your connecting a salt bridge
 analogy, the charge imbalance is redressed by adding a salt. In this
 case the charge remains exactly the same, as you have added an
 essentially neutral substance, which just happens to divide into 2 equal
 but oppositely charged ions. 

Ivan: To keep things as simple as possible, the following discussion pertains 
to the initial few minutes of CS electrolysis. It seems to me that if salt is 
added to water, the ionic species responsible for carry the charge changes 
from silver ions (in the case when no salt is present) to Na+ and Cl- which 
then carry all of the charge between the two silver electrodes. If NaCl is 
carrying ~100% of the charge, how can a charge buildup occur for Ag+ ions 
when they no longer play a significant charge carrying role?

In the former case (no salt is present), Ag+ cations are just beginning to be 
produced at the anode so there is very little Ag+ available to transfer 
charge to the cathode, AND other than OH- (at ~10^-7 moles/liter), there are 
no significant amounts of other anionic species available to carry the charge 
from the cathode to the anode. Consequently, a charge buildup occurs similar 
to what happens in a with the "no salt bridge" Zn/H2 battery. When salt is 
added to the water, a charge buildup cannot occur because Na+ and Cl- are 
available to carry charge between the cathode and anode respectively.

By placing a salt bridge in your example you simply provide a connection 
which allows the charge imbalance to distribute evenly between the 2 
solutions. There is
no way to keep this cell running without replenishing the lost H+ ions by 
adding further HCl.

Ivan: My point was that without the salt bridge this cell would stop running 
despite the available HCl & Zn, leaving an equal, but opposite, charge 
buildup in the two beakers. WITH a salt bridge, no charge buildup would 
occur, and the cells would continue to run until one (or both) of the 
reactants (Zn or H+) was depleted.

Roger


--
The silver-list is a moderated forum for discussion of colloidal silver.

To join or quit silver-list or silver-digest send an e-mail message to: 
[email protected]  -or-  [email protected]
with the word subscribe or unsubscribe in the SUBJECT line.

To post, address your message to: [email protected]
Silver-list archive: http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/index.html
List maintainer: Mike Devour <[email protected]>