----- Original Message ----- From: "Judith Thamm" <[email protected]> To: <[email protected]> Sent: Monday, October 29, 2001 8:12 PM Subject: CS>1st of 2 articles on Cipro
> If you have had these already - I shall crawl humbly into my corner and > hide - tempoarily... > > Judith. > > CIPRO is Worse Than Anthrax > Serious Side-Effects From CIPRO > Anthrax-like Symptoms from CIPRO > Garlic is Better Than CIPRO > > > Article from > http://www.lewrockwell.com/orig/sardi8.html > > > America Is Losing Its Other Germ War > > America Loses 14,000 Lives A Year In Its Other Germ War; > > Over-Use Of Antibiotics Like Cipro May Induce Plagues; > > Natural Antibiotics May Rescue Mankind > > by Bill Sardi > > Special addendum: side effects of CIPRO-like drugs may be > worse than Anthrax; CIPRO should not be used by rescue, > police or military personnel, nor be approved for nation's > antibiotic stockpile. > > America is losing its other germ war and thousands more > lives are needlessly being lost than from the recent > anthrax threat. > > The public has been gripped by the threat of anthrax in the > past week, and has become familiar with CIPRO > (ciprofloxacin-Bayer), the antibiotic that has been widely > described as the preferred drug to treat inhalation > anthrax. > > At the same time, Americans have been distracted from > America's other germ war -- the over-use of prescription > antibiotics like CIPRO which will only hasten the early > demise of millions of humans worldwide as more germs mutate > and become resistant to these drugs, permitting bugs like > E. coli, Enterococci, Staphylococcus, Helicobacteri pylori, > and yes even anthrax, to escape treatment and increase > morbidity and mortality. The ongoing germ war Americans > face is not administered by a terrorist but is of one their > own doing. > > A news story that has been overshadowed by the American > anthrax scare is that FDA and University of Maryland > researchers found 20% of meat samples obtained from > supermarkets were contaminated with drug-resistant > salmonella, a germ that is responsible for 1.4 million > cases of food poisoning annually. Among the samples of > ground beef, chicken turkey and pork, 84% of the salmonella > was found to be resistant to one drug and 53% to three or > more antibiotics.1 > > Worldwide, many strains of Staph aureus, another pathogenic > bacterium, are resistant to all antibiotics except > Vancomycin, which is considered the antibiotic of last > resort. Strains of germs like Enterococcus faecalis, > Mycobacterium tuberculosis and Pseudomonas aeruginosa > already defy a stockpile of more than 100 antibiotic drugs. > > The FDA is rapidly making plans to reduce the use of > antibiotics in animals, particularly because the drug- > resistance in these animals can be transferred to humans. > Over 40% of the antibiotics produced annually (about 20 > million pounds) are used in animals. > > In an attempt to head off the growing drug-resistance > problem, the American Medical Association has urged its > members not to prescribe CIPRO to patients who are merely > worried about anthrax exposure and has warned physicians to > reduce their rate of prescriptions for antibiotics overall. > Some experts estimate half of the antibiotics taken in the > US are unnecessary. > > Most commercial antibiotics have been molecularly altered > in the laboratory to obtain a patent and to improve > potency. The man-made molecules are what induce germs to > mutate and become resistant to their killing properties.2 > Drug companies have responded to the resistance problem "by > producing newer antibiotics," most which are just > variations or combinations of old drugs.3 The FDA says it > is doing all it can to speed up development and > availability of new antibiotic drugs.4 For example, in > September of 1999 the FDA announced the "approval of a long- > needed new weapon against the growing threat of drug- > resistant bacteria: Synercid, the first alternative in 30 > years to the antibiotic (vancomycin) of last resort." > Synercid (Rhone-Poulenc Rorer) is the first in a new class > of antibiotics called streptogamins, but the FDA admitted > it only has a 52% effectiveness rating in fighting off drug- > resistant strains of enterococcal infections and it was > accompanied by side effects such as rash, vomiting, > diarrhea and joint pain.5 > > But the FDA makes no mention of natural, non-patentable > antibiotics which do not induce resistance, some which > exhibit a 100% kill factor for anthrax and a wide range of > other germs. There are no financial incentives for makers > of antibiotic foods like garlic, or supplements like oil of > oregano, to undergo expensive and time-consuming clinical > trials so they can make a label claim as an antibiotic. > This gives drug manufacturers complete reign over the > prescription antibiotic drug market. Most Americans are so > ill informed on this issue that they just can't believe > natural antibiotics are more potent than the drugs their > doctor prescribes. > > Physicians could direct their patients to natural > antibiotics that don't induce resistance, but they have > largely been trained to use prescription medications and to > look askance at natural remedies as if they are snake oil. > This problem is already costing many patients with their > lives as the antibiotic drugs fail to cure pneumonia or > other hospital-acquired infections. An estimated 14,000 > hospitalized patients are believed to die from drug- > resistant bacteria annually. That's far more than the > current anthrax exposure.6 > > In order to maintain profits of the pharmaceutical > companies and physicians, the FDA requires the public to > play a risky game, to wait for infection to occur, then run > to the doctor, risk death or chronic health problems, > receive a broad-spectrum antibiotic while the doctor sends > a swab sample to the laboratory for culture to see if the > prescribed antibiotic will defeat that particular kind of > germ. There are over 76 million cases of foodborne > infection annually in the US which produces diarrhea and > 5000 deaths annually.7 These deaths could be prevented if > the manufacturers of natural antibiotics like garlic and > oil of oregano were permitted to inform the public of their > well-documented germ-killing properties. The public could > take garlic or oil of oregano as prevention without risk of > germ-resistance. In a country that prides itself in free > speech, even the truth is being barred from public > dissemination in regards to herbal antibiotics. > > NATURAL ANTIBIOTICS TO THE RESCUE > > Virtually every prescription antibiotic that is consumed is > hastening the day when all the bug-killers will be rendered > useless. Why we continue to solely rely upon patentable > molecules to kill germs and ignore more potent, economical > and safe natural antibiotics, which do not induce > resistance, goes unexplained except for financial greed. > > A growing body of scientific evidence confirms that natural > herbs and spices exhibit antibiotic properties that are > equivalent if not superior to drugs. > > For example, researchers in the Netherlands report that > garlic is capable to eradicating vancomycin-resistant > enterococci bacteria, a germ that is a growing cause of > mortality in hospitals.8 A broth of 2% garlic juice has > been shown to completely eradicate ampicillin-resistant E. > coli.9 E. coli infections are widespread, originating from > fecal material, and a resistant strain of E. coli (clonal > group A) is accounting for more than half of all the female > urinary tract infections. In some parts of the country > about 20% of these infections now only respond to a > combination of powerful drugs, drugs that encourage even > more drug resistant strains.10 > > A 1% solution of garlic from fresh cloves has been shown to > have antibacterial activity against E. coli and antibiotic- > resistant (methicillin) Staph aureus, Salmonella, a common > cause of food poisoning, and Candida albicans, the most > common yeast infection.11 Researchers at Georgetown > University report that oil of oregano (not the kitchen > cupboard variety of oregano) was recently tested against > drug-resistant Staphylococcus bacteria and was found to be > equally effective as streptomycin, penicillin and > vancomycin.12 > > These herbal antibiotics do not induce germ resistance. The > complete lack of antibiotic resistance with garlic has been > repeatedly shown.13 Garlic exhibits strong activity against > bacteria, even multi-drug resistant strains, as well as > against fungi (yeast) and viruses.14 In one report, > infectious disease specialists concede that garlic may be > effective in the treatment of middle ear infection given > that antibiotic drugs are failing.15 > > An estimated 50% of the US adult population is believed to > be infected with Helicobacter pylori, the gastric bug that > causes ulcers and has recently been confirmed as the germ > that causes stomach cancer.16 Antibiotics could virtually > eliminate the risk of stomach cancer, the 8th leading cause > of cancer-related death in the US, but their use among non- > ulcer infected patients would induce more drug-resistant > strains of H. pylori. Yet garlic is able to kill H. > pylori.17 It is unlikely that physicians will begin to > advise their patients to consume more garlic or garlic > capsules to prevent stomach cancer. So the public remains > at risk for a form of cancer that could be virtually > eliminated. > > Furthermore, it is apparent that the simultaneous use of > antioxidants and herbs such as green tea with antibiotic > drugs may actually help to prevent genetic mutations and > suppress the emergence of resistant bacteria in the first > place.18 > > Animals could be given natural antibiotics like garlic and > oil of oregano and these germ-killers can also be placed in > foods to kill off any pathogens and to reduce spoilage. Oil > of oregano has been shown to exhibit the greatest > inhibition of bacteria among food spices in a recent test > against pathogens such as E. Coli, Staph aureus, > Pseudomonas and others germs.19 > > A study conducted at Cornell University found that spices > such as garlic, oil of oregano, onion, and allspice kill > every bacterium tested, even anthrax.20 A 1977 conducted in > India reveals that crude garlic extract exhibited greater > antibiotic action against Bacillus anthracis (anthrax) than > tetracycline, penicillin, streptomycin, ampicillin, > erythromycin and other antibiotics.21 > > In a remarkable study, the Garlic Centre in Essex, England, > reports that a daily garlic capsule reduced the incidence > of the common cold by 50 percent during winter months. The > common cold affects more people than any other type of > infection.22 There are nearly 61 million cases of the > common cold annually in the US says the National Center for > Health Statistics. Garlic has been shown to kill Herpes > simplex, Parainfluenza, and rhinovirus in a laboratory > dish.23 Researchers at the Weitzmann Institute of Science > in Israel report that allicin, a component of garlic, > effectively kills off multi-drug resistant strains of E. > coli, fungi such as Candida albicans, protozoan parasites > such as Giardia lamblia and viruses.24 > > SPECIAL ADDENDUM: > OTHER ANTIBIOTICS WORK EQUALLY WELL AS CIPRO > > While only a few hundred Americans were potentially exposed > to anthrax and given precautionary courses of CIPRO and > other antibiotics, the demand for CIPRO was reported to > rise from less than 10,000 to over 18,000 pills dispensed > daily in the week of October 14-20, 2001. > > The FDA approved CIPRO for inhalational anthrax on July 28, > 2000. However, it is not the only drug that works against > anthrax. For ethical reasons human studies on anthrax > cannot be conducted. But animal studies with anthrax were > performed in 1993. Groups of 10 animals were exposed to > inhalational anthrax. Each antibiotic tested completely > protected the animals while on the drug, but upon > discontinuance, here was the survival rate: penicillin, 7 > of 10 survived; ciprofloxacin (CIPRO)*, 8 of 9 survived; > doxycycline, 8 of 9 survived. (*An additional animal was > not counted because it succumbed to pneumonia during the > trial.)25 > > The director of the National Institute of Allergy and > Infectious Diseases, Dr. Anthony S. Fauci, says there is a > false impression that CIPRO is the only drug that would > work against anthrax. CIPRO is in a class of drugs called > fluoroquinolones would work equally well, he says.26 Brand > names of other fluoroquinolone drugs are Avelox, Floxin, > Levaquin, Maxaquin, Noroxin, Penetrex, Tequin and Zagam. > > In 1994 Russian scientists found the protective effects of > three fluoroquinolone drugs, ciprofloxacin (CIPRO), > pefloxacin and lomefloxacin, were practically the same > against anthrax.27 Five other fluoroquinolones have been > shown to be pharmaceutically superior to ciprofloxacin.28 > Levofloxacin is better absorbed into lung tissue than > ciprofloxacin, which is where anthrax spores reside.29 > > CIPRO WORSE THAN ANTHRAX > > According to a Washington Post report, the use of CIPRO is > likely to threaten the health of far more people than any > anthrax attack. The report says 7.3 percent of CIPRO users > can expect to experience side effects, which includes death > following the ingestion of just one tablet, seizures, > hallucinations, and rash, the latter symptom mimicking a > sign of anthrax which would unnecessarily frighten a CIPRO > user.30 > > Though CIPRO has been around since 1987 and over 250 > million people have taken it, it is fraught with serious > side effects, enough to make a person wonder why it was > approved for use in a biological warfare environment. > > First, Fluoroquinolone drugs like CIPRO are not recommended > for children under the age of 18, nor pregnant females. > > Second, Fluoroquinolones may adversely interact with many > other drugs. Caffeine, warfarin blood thinners (Coumadin), > magnesium antacids, and theophylline asthma drugs should > not be taken with this class of drugs.31 > > Third, Ciprofloxacin and all fluoroquinolones are > photosensitive medications and they can cause skin > reactions upon exposure to solar ultraviolet radiation and > even from low-dose fluorescent lighting.32 Phototoxicity is > reported with all fluoroquinolones but lomefloxacin's > molecular structure minimizes this problem.33 Rescue > workers, police or military personnel who receive CIPRO- > like drugs and who must work outdoors may experience light- > induced reactions. > > Fourth, CIPRO is reported to interfere with collagen > formation and induce rupture of the Achilles tendon. > Tendonitis and tendon ruptures have been reported several > months following antibiotic treatment even with minimal > mechanical stress.34 Even rather low doses of CIPRO-like > drugs, or a magnesium-deficient diet, may induce Achilles > tendon inflammation or rupture.35 Apparently CIPRO either > blocks the absorption or the action of magnesium, an > essential mineral, which then results in weakened joints. > The provision of supplemental magnesium should be advised > to users of CIPRO since this may prevent the occurrence of > joint ruptures.36 But nothing is said about the connection > between magnesium shortage and joint problems in product > literature. Since magnesium impairs the absorption of > fluoroquinolones, it should be taken in between courses of > this class of antibiotics.37 CIPRO-like drugs are > apparently inappropriate for use in a biological warfare > environment where rescue, police and military personnel > require antibiotic treatment and yet may suffer joint > injuries that would impair their performance. > > Fifth, Bayer AG, the German-based parent company that > produces CIPRO, is accused of fraud and unethical behavior > for not disclosing to surgical patients in a clinical study > of the potential hazards posed by the use of CIPRO when it > is taken with preoperative sedatives or tranquilizers. > Apparently sedatives impair the absorption of CIPRO and > then increase the risk of infection. Some British surgical > patients experienced infections and one died in a clinical > study that Bayer refuses to disclose data on.38 It is > reported that many people in New York City began taking > tranquilizers following the attack on the World Trade > Center. This would be a contraindication for CIPRO-like > drugs in a metropolitan biological warfare arena where some > people may require surgery due to trauma, etc. > > Sixth, in fact the FDA is proposing to withdraw one of the > fluoroquinolone drugs used in poultry because is causes the > rapid development of resistant Campylobacter bacteria that > can be transferred to humans.39 > > Bayer sells CIPRO for $1.83 per table to the US government, > less than the $4.40 normal price. But the recommended two > 500 mg tablets per day for 60 days to treat inhalational > anthrax exposure would cost about $220, compared to around > $20 for tetracycline or doxycycline. > > Tommy Thompson, secretary of Health & Human Services, is > petitioning Congress for $643 million to add CIPRO and > other drugs to the nation's antibiotic stockpile. This may > be ill advised. > > REFERENCES > > 1. White DG, et al, The isolation of antibiotic-resistant > salmonella from retail ground meats, New England Journal > Medicine 345: 1147-54, 2001 and Associated Press, October > 18, 2001. > 2. Levy SB, The challenge of antibiotics resistance, > Scientific American, March 1998. > 3. Lavin BS, Antibiotic cycling and marketing into the 21st > century: a perspective from the pharmaceutical industry, > Infection Control Hospital Epidemiology 21: 32-35S, 2000. > 4. Lewis R, The rise of antibiotic-resistant infections, FDA > Consumer Magazine, Sept. 1995. > 5. FDA approves long-needed new antibiotic, Associated Press, > Sept. 21, 1999. > 6. Ostrom CM, Antibiotics dangerously overused, group warns, > Seattle Times, October 17, 2001. > 7. Acheson DWK, Foodborne diseases update: current trends in > foodborne diseases, Medscape Infectious Diseases, 2001] > 8. Jonkers D, Sluimer J, Stobberingh E, Antibacterial effect > of garlic and omeprazole on Helicobacter pylori, > Antimicrobial Agents & Chemotherapy 43: 3045-54, 1999. > 9. Unal R, et al, Novel quantitative assays for estimating the > antimicrobial activity of fresh garlic juice, Journal Food > Protection 64: 189-94, 2001. > 10. Gewolb J, New E. coli strain causes trouble, Science Now, > October 4, 2001. > 11. Sasaki J, et al, Antibacterial activity of garlic powder > against Escherichia coli O-157, Journal Nutrition Science > Vitaminology 45: 785-90, 1999. > 12. Preuss HG, Oregano oil may protect against drug-resistant > bacteria, Georgetown Researcher Finds, Science Daily, > October 11, 2001. > 13. Sivam GP, Protection against Helicobacter pylori and other > bacterial infections by garlic, Journal Nutrition 131: 1106- > 08S, 2001. > 14. Ankri S, Mirelman D, Antimicrobial properties of allicin > from garlic, Microbes Infection 1: 125-29, 1999. > 15. Klein JO, Management of acute otitis media in an era of > increasing antibiotic resistance, International Journal > Pediatric Otorhinology 5: 15-17S, 1999. > 16. Uemura N, et al, Helicobacteri pylori infection and the > development of gastric cancer, New England Journal Medicine > 345: 829-32, 2001. > 17. Sivam GP, Protection against Helicobacter pylori and other > bacterial infections by garlic, Journal Nutrition 131: 1106- > 08S, 2001; Sivan GP, et al, Helicobacter pylori- in vitro > susceptibility to garlic (Allium sativum) extract, > Nutrition & Cancer 27: 118-21, 1997. > 18. Pillai SP, et al, The ability of certain antimutagenic > agents to prevent development of antibiotic resistance, > Mutation Research 496: 61-75, 2001. > 19. Elgayyar M, et al, Antimicrobial activity of essential oils > from plants against selected pathogenic and saprophytic > microorganisms, Journal Food Protection, 64: 1019-24, 2001. > 20. Billing J, Sherman PW, Antimicrobial functions of spices, > Quarterly Review Biology 73: March, 1998. > 21. Sharma VD, et al, Antibacterial property of Allium sativum: > in vivo and in vitro studies, Indian Journal Experimental > Biology 15: 466-68, 1977. > 22. BBC News, October 3, 2001; Josling P, Preventing the common > cold with a garlic-supplement: a double-blind, placebo- > controlled survey, Advances in Therapy 18: 189-93, 2001. > 23. Weber ND, et al, In vitro virucidal effects of Allium > sativum (garlic) extract and compounds, Planta Medica 58: > 417-23, 1992. > 24. Ankri S, Mirelman D, Antimicrobial properties of allicin > from garlic, Microbes Infection 1: 125-29, 1999. > 25. Friedlander AM, et al, Postexposure prophylaxis against > experimental inhalation anthrax, Journal Infectious > Diseases, 167: 1239-43, 1993. > 26. Kolata G, Cipro isn't the only drug that can be prescribed, > anthrax experts say, New York Times, October 17, 2001. > 27. D'aikov SI, et al, Comparative evaluation of the > effectiveness of fluoroquinolones in experimental anthrax > infection, Antibiotic Khimioterapy, 39: 15-19, 1994. > 28. Lubasch A, et al, Comparative pharmacokinetics of > ciprofloxacin, gatifloxacin, grepafloxacin, levoflaxacin, > trolafloxacin and mixifloxacin after single oral > administration in healthy volunteers, Antimicrobial Agents > Chemotherapy 44: 2600-03, 2000. > 29. Gotfried MH, et al, Steady-state plasma and intrapulmonary > concentrations of levofloxacin and ciprofloxacin in healthy > adult subjects, Chest 119: 1114-22, 2001. > 30. Gillis J, Connolly C, Emphasis on Cipro worries officials, > Washington Post, Oct. 19, 2001, Page A17. > 31. Medline Plus, Micromedex, Inc., 12/18/2000, US National > Library of Medicine; Ball P, Safety of the new > fluoroquinolones compared with ciprofloxacin, Journal > Chemotherapy 12: 8-11, 2000. > 32. Jaffe A, Bush A, If you can't stand the rash, get out of > the kitchen: an unusual advers reaction to ciprofloxacin, > Pediatric Polmonology 28: 449-50, 1999. > 33. Stablmann R, Lode H, Toxicity of quinolones, Drugs 58: 37- > 42, 1999 supplement. > 34. Casparian JM, Luchi M, et al, Quinolones and tendon > ruptures, Southern Medical Journal 93: 488-91, 2000. > 35. Shakibaei M, et al, Biochemical changes in Achilles tendon > from juvenile dogs after treatment with ciprofloxacin or > feeding a magnesium-deficient diet, Archives Toxicology 75: > 369-74, 2001. > 36. Egerbacher M, et al, In vitro evidence for effects of > magnesium supplementation on quinolone-treated horse and > dog chondrocytes, Veterinary Pathology 38: 143-48, 2001. > 37. Fish DN, Chow AT, The clinical pharmacokinetics of > levofloxacin, Clinical Pharmacokinetics 32: 101-19, 1997. > Drug firm put patients at risk in hospital trials, London > Times, May 14, 2000. > 38. FDA/CVM Proposed to withdraw poultry fluoroquinolones > approval, Food & Drug Administration, October 26, 2000. > October 24, 2001 > > Bill Sardi is a health journalist at > www.askbillsardi.com. > > Copyright 2001 by the Bill Sardi Word of Knowledge > Agency, San Dimas, California. Not for commercial > reproduction without permission of the author. > > > > > -- > The silver-list is a moderated forum for discussion of colloidal silver. > > To join or quit silver-list or silver-digest send an e-mail message to: > [email protected] -or- [email protected] > with the word subscribe or unsubscribe in the SUBJECT line. > > To post, address your message to: [email protected] > Silver-list archive: http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/index.html > List maintainer: Mike Devour <[email protected]> >

