The test of time
To the outside observer, the challenge in making sense of any such
long-running scientific controversy is to establish whether the skeptics
are simply on the wrong side of the new paradigm, or whether their
skepticism is well founded. In other words, is the science at issue
based on sound scientific thinking and unambiguous data, or is it what
Sir Francis Bacon, for instance, would have called "wishful science,"
based on fancies, opinions, and the exclusion of contrary evidence?
Bacon offered one viable suggestion for differentiating the two: the
test of time. Good science is rooted in reality, so it grows and
develops and the evidence gets increasingly more compelling, whereas
wishful science flourishes most under its first authors before "going
downhill."

Such is the case, for instance, with the proposition that dietary fat
causes cancer, which was an integral part of dietary fat anxiety in the
late 1970s. By 1982, the evidence supporting this idea was thought to be
so undeniable that a landmark NAS report on nutrition and cancer equated
those researchers who remained skeptical with "certain interested
parties [who] formerly argued that the association between lung cancer
and smoking was not causational." Fifteen years and hundreds of millions
of research dollars later, a similarly massive expert report by the
World Cancer Research Fund and the American Institute for Cancer
Research could find neither "convincing" nor even "probable" reason to
believe that dietary fat caused cancer.

The hypothesis that low-fat diets are the requisite route to weight loss
has taken a similar downward path. This was the ultimate fallback
position in all low-fat recommendations: Fat has nine calories per gram
compared to four calories for carbohydrates and protein, and so cutting
fat from the diet surely would cut pounds. "This is held almost to be a
religious truth," says Harvard's Willett. Considerable data, however,
now suggest otherwise. The results of well-controlled clinical trials
are consistent: People on low-fat diets initially lose a couple of
kilograms, as they would on any diet, and then the weight tends to
return. After 1 to 2 years, little has been achieved. Consider, for
instance, the 50,000 women enrolled in the ongoing $100 million Women's
Health Initiative (WHI). Half of these women have been extensively
counseled to consume only 20% of their calories from fat. After 3 years
on this near-draconian regime, say WHI sources, the women had lost, on
average, a kilogram each.

The link between dietary fat and heart disease is more complicated,
because the hypothesis has diverged into two distinct propositions:
first, that lowering cholesterol prevents heart disease; second, that
eating less fat not only lowers cholesterol and prevents heart disease
but prolongs life. Since 1984, the evidence that cholesterol-lowering
drugs are beneficial--proposition number one--has indeed blossomed, at
least for those at high risk of heart attack. These drugs reduce serum
cholesterol levels dramatically, and they prevent heart attacks, perhaps
by other means as well. Their market has now reached $4 billion a year
in the United States alone, and every new trial seems to confirm their
benefits.

The evidence supporting the second proposition, that eating less fat
makes for a healthier and longer life, however, has remained stubbornly
ambiguous. If anything, it has only become less compelling over time.
Indeed, since Ancel Keys started advocating low-fat diets almost 50
years ago, the science of fat and cholesterol has evolved from a simple
story into a very complicated one. The catch has been that few involved
in this business were prepared to deal with a complicated story.
Researchers initially preferred to believe it was simple--that a single
unwholesome nutrient, in effect, could be isolated from the diverse
richness of human diets; public health administrators required a simple
story to give to Congress and the public; and the press needed a simple
story--at least on any particular day--to give to editors and readers in
30 column inches. But as contrarian data continued to accumulate, the
complications became increasingly more difficult to ignore or exclude,
and the press began waffling or adding caveats. The scientists then got
the blame for not sticking to the original simple story, which had,
regrettably, never existed.

More fats, fewer answers
The original simple story in the 1950s was that high cholesterol levels
increase heart disease risk. The seminal Framingham Heart Study, for
instance, which revealed the association between cholesterol and heart
disease, originally measured only total serum cholesterol. But
cholesterol shuttles through the blood in an array of packages.
Low-density lipoprotein particles (LDL, the "bad" cholesterol) deliver
fat and cholesterol from the liver to tissues that need it, including
the arterial cells, where it can lead to atherosclerotic plaques.
High-density lipoproteins (HDLs, the "good" cholesterol) return
cholesterol to the liver. The higher the HDL, the lower the heart
disease risk. Then there are triglycerides, which contain fatty acids,
and very low density lipoproteins (VLDLs), which transport
triglycerides.

All of these particles have some effect on heart disease risk, while the
fats, carbohydrates, and protein in the diet have varying effects on all
these particles. The 1950s story was that saturated fats increase total
cholesterol, polyunsaturated fats decrease it, and monounsaturated fats
are neutral. By the late 1970s--when researchers accepted the benefits
of HDL--they realized that monounsaturated fats are not neutral. Rather,
they raise HDL, at least compared to carbohydrates, and lower LDL. This
makes them an ideal nutrient as far as cholesterol goes. Furthermore,
saturated fats cannot be quite so evil because, while they elevate LDL,
which is bad, they also elevate HDL, which is good. And some saturated
fats--stearic acid, in particular, the fat in chocolate--are at worst
neutral. Stearic acid raises HDL levels but does little or nothing to
LDL. And then there are trans fatty acids, which raise LDL, just like
saturated fat, but also lower HDL. Today, none of this is controversial,
although it has yet to be reflected in any Food Guide Pyramid.

To understand where this complexity can lead in a simple example,
consider a steak--to be precise, a porterhouse, select cut, with a
half-centimeter layer of fat, the nutritional constituents of which can
be found in the Nutrient Database for Standard Reference at the USDA Web
site. After broiling, this porterhouse reduces to a serving of almost
equal parts fat and protein. Fifty-one percent of the fat is
monounsaturated, of which virtually all (90%) is oleic acid, the same
healthy fat that's in olive oil. Saturated fat constitutes 45% of the
total fat, but a third of that is stearic acid, which is, at the very
least, harmless. The remaining 4% of the fat is polyunsaturated, which
also improves cholesterol levels. In sum, well over half--and perhaps as
much as 70%--of the fat content of a porterhouse will improve
cholesterol levels compared to what they would be if bread, potatoes, or
pasta were consumed instead. The remaining 30% will raise LDL but will
also raise HDL. All of this suggests that eating a porterhouse steak
rather than carbohydrates might actually improve heart disease risk,
although no nutritional authority who hasn't written a high-fat diet
book will say this publicly.

As for the scientific studies, in the years since the 1984 consensus
conference, the one thing they have not done is pile up evidence in
support of the low-fat-for-all approach to the public good. If anything,
they have added weight to Ahrens's fears that there may be a downside to
populationwide low-fat recommendations. In 1986, for instance, just 1
year after NIH launched the National Cholesterol Education Program, also
advising low-fat diets for everyone over 2 years old, epidemiologist
David Jacobs of the University of Minnesota, Twin Cities, visited Japan.
There he learned that Japanese physicians were advising patients to
raise their cholesterol levels, because low cholesterol levels were
linked to hemorrhagic stroke. At the time, Japanese men were dying from
stroke almost as frequently as American men were succumbing to heart
disease. Back in Minnesota, Jacobs looked for this
low-cholesterol-stroke relationship in the MRFIT data and found it
there, too. And the relationship transcended stroke: Men with very low
cholesterol levels seemed prone to premature death; below 160 milligrams
per deciliter (mg/dl), the lower the cholesterol level, the shorter the
life.

Jacobs reported his results to NHLBI, which in 1990 hosted a conference
to discuss the issue, bringing together researchers from 19 studies
around the world. The data were consistent: When investigators tracked
all deaths, instead of just heart disease deaths, the cholesterol curves
were U-shaped for men and flat for women. In other words, men with
cholesterol levels above 240 mg/dl tended to die prematurely from heart
disease. But below 160 mg/dl, the men tended to die prematurely from
cancer, respiratory and digestive diseases, and trauma. As for women, if
anything, the higher their cholesterol, the longer they lived (see graph
on p. 2540).

These mortality data can be interpreted in two ways. One, preferred by
low-fat advocates, is that they cannot be meaningful. Rifkind, for
instance, told Science that the excess deaths at low cholesterol levels
must be due to preexisting conditions. In other words, chronic illness
leads to low cholesterol levels, not vice versa. He pointed to the 1990
conference report as the definitive document on the issue and as support
for his argument, although the report states unequivocally that this
interpretation is not supported by the data.

The other interpretation is that what a low-fat diet does to serum
cholesterol levels, and what that in turn does to arteries, may be only
one component of the diet's effect on health. In other words, while
low-fat diets might help prevent heart disease, they might also raise
susceptibility to other conditions. This is what always worried Ahrens.
It's also one reason why the American College of Physicians, for
instance, now suggests that cholesterol reduction is certainly
worthwhile for those at high, short-term risk of dying of coronary heart
disease but of "much smaller or ... uncertain" benefit for everyone
else.

This interpretation--that the connection between diet and health far
transcends cholesterol--is also supported by the single most dramatic
diet-heart trial ever conducted: the Lyon Diet Heart Study, led by
Michel de Lorgeril of the French National Institute of Health and
Medical Research (INSERM) and published in Circulation in February 1999.
The investigators randomized 605 heart attack survivors, all on
cholesterol-lowering drugs, into two groups. They counseled one to eat
an AHA "prudent diet," very similar to that recommended for all
Americans. They counseled the other to eat a Mediterranean-type diet,
with more bread, cereals, legumes, beans, vegetables, fruits, and fish
and less meat. Total fat and types of fat differed markedly in the two
diets, but the HDL, LDL, and total cholesterol levels in the two groups
remained virtually identical. Nonetheless, over 4 years of follow-up,
the Mediterranean-diet group had only 14 cardiac deaths and nonfatal
heart attacks compared to 44 for the "Western-type" diet group. The
likely explanation, wrote de Lorgeril and his colleagues, is that the
"protective effects [of the Mediterranean diet] were not related to
serum concentrations of total, LDL or HDL cholesterol."

Many researchers find the Lyon data so perplexing that they're left
questioning the methodology of the trial. Nonetheless, says NIH's
Harlan, the data "are very provocative. They do bring up the issue of
whether if we look only at cholesterol levels we aren't going to miss
something very important." De Lorgeril believes the diet's protective
effect comes primarily from omega-3 fatty acids, found in seed oils,
meat, cereals, green leafy vegetables, and fish, and from antioxidant
compounds, including vitamins, trace elements, and flavonoids. He told
Science that most researchers and journalists in the field are prisoners
of the "cholesterol paradigm." Although dietary fat and serum
cholesterol "are obviously connected," he says, "the connection is not a
robust one" when it comes to heart disease.

Dietary trade-offs
One inescapable reality is that death is a trade-off, and so is diet.
"You have to eat something," says epidemiologist Hugh Tunstall Pedoe of
the University of Dundee, U.K., spokesperson for the 21-nation
Monitoring Cardiovascular Disease Project run by the World Health
Organization. "If you eat more of one thing, you eat a lot less of
something else. So for every theory saying this disease is caused by an
excess in x, you can produce an alternative theory saying it's a
deficiency in y." It would be simple if, say, saturated fats could be
cut from the diet and the calories with it, but that's not the case.
Despite all expectations to the contrary, people tend to consume the
same number of calories despite whatever diet they try. If they eat less
total fat, for instance, they will eat more carbohydrates and probably
less protein, because most protein comes in foods like meat that also
have considerable amounts of fat.

This plus-minus problem suggests a different interpretation for
virtually every diet study ever done, including, for instance, the kind
of metabolic-ward studies that originally demonstrated the ability of
saturated fats to raise cholesterol. If researchers reduce the amount of
saturated fat in the test diet, they have to make up the calories
elsewhere. Do they add polyunsaturated fats, for instance, or add
carbohydrates? A single carbohydrate or mixed carbohydrates? Do they add
green leafy vegetables, or do they add pasta? And so it goes. "The sky's
the limit," says nutritionist Alice Lichtenstein of Tufts University in
Boston. "There are a million perturbations."

These trade-offs also confound the kind of epidemiological studies that
demonized saturated fat from the 1950s onward. In particular,
individuals who eat copious amounts of meat and dairy products, and
plenty of saturated fats in the process, tend not to eat copious amounts
of vegetables and fruits. The same holds for entire populations. The
eastern Finns, for instance, whose lofty heart disease rates convinced
Ancel Keys and a generation of researchers of the evils of fat, live
within 500 kilometers of the Arctic Circle and rarely see fresh produce
or a green vegetable. The Scots, infamous for eating perhaps the least
wholesome diet in the developed world, are in a similar fix. Basil
Rifkind recalls being laughed at once on this point when he lectured to
Scottish physicians on healthy diets: "One said, 'You talk about
increasing fruits and vegetable consumption, but in the area I work in
there's not a single grocery store.' " In both cases, researchers joke
that the only green leafy vegetable these populations consume regularly
is tobacco. As for the purported benefits of the widely hailed
Mediterranean diet, is it the fish, the olive oil, or the fresh
vegetables? After all, says Harvard epidemiologist Dimitrios
Trichopoulos, a native of Greece, the olive oil is used either to cook
vegetables or as dressing over salads. "The quantity of vegetables
consumed is almost a pound [half a kilogram] a day," he says, "and you
cannot eat it without olive oil. And we eat a lot of legumes, and we
cannot eat legumes without olive oil."

Indeed, recent data on heart disease trends in Europe suggest that a
likely explanation for the differences between countries and over time
is the availability of fresh produce year-round rather than differences
in fat intake. While the press often plays up the French paradox--the
French have little heart disease despite seemingly high saturated fat
consumption--the real paradox is throughout Southern Europe, where heart
disease death rates have steadily dropped while animal fat consumption
has steadily risen, says University of Cambridge epidemiologist John
Powles, who studies national disease trends. The same trend appears in
Japan. "We have this idea that it's the Arcadian past, the life in the
village, the utopia that we've lost," Powles says; "that the really
protective Mediterranean diet is what people ate in the 1950s." But that
notion isn't supported by the data: As these Mediterranean nations
became more affluent, says Powles, they began to eat proportionally more
meat and with it more animal fat. Their heart disease rates, however,
continued to improve compared to populations that consumed as much
animal fat but had less access to fresh vegetables throughout the year.
To Powles, the antifat movement was founded on the Puritan notion that
"something bad had to have an evil cause, and you got a heart attack
because you did something wrong, which was eating too much of a bad
thing, rather than not having enough of a good thing."

The other salient trade-off in the plus-minus problem of human diets is
carbohydrates. When the federal government began pushing low-fat diets,
the scientists and administrators, and virtually everyone else involved,
hoped that Americans would replace fat calories with fruits and
vegetables and legumes, but it didn't happen. If nothing else, economics
worked against it. The food industry has little incentive to advertise
nonproprietary items: broccoli, for instance. Instead, says NYU's
Nestle, the great bulk of the $30-billion-plus spent yearly on food
advertising goes to selling carbohydrates in the guise of fast food,
sodas, snacks, and candy bars. And carbohydrates are all too often what
Americans eat.

Carbohydrates are what Harvard's Willett calls the flip side of the
calorie trade-off problem. Because it is exceedingly difficult to add
pure protein to a diet in any quantity, a low-fat diet is, by
definition, a high-carbohydrate diet--just as a low-fat cookie or
low-fat yogurt are, by definition, high in carbohydrates. Numerous
studies now suggest that high-carbohydrate diets can raise triglyceride
levels, create small, dense LDL particles, and reduce HDL--a
combination, along with a condition known as "insulin resistance," that
Stanford endocrinologist Gerald Reaven has labeled "syndrome X." Thirty
percent of adult males and 10% to 15% of postmenopausal women have this
particular syndrome X profile, which is associated with a several-fold
increase in heart disease risk, says Reaven, even among those patients
whose LDL levels appear otherwise normal. Reaven and Ron Krauss, who
studies fats and lipids at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory in
California, have shown that when men eat high-carbohydrate diets their
cholesterol profiles may shift from normal to syndrome X. In other
words, the more carbohydrates replace saturated fats, the more likely
the end result will be syndrome X and an increased heart disease risk.
"The problem is so clear right now it's almost a joke," says Reaven. How
this balances out is the unknown. "It's a bitch of a question," says
Marc Hellerstein, a nutritional biochemist at the University of
California, Berkeley, "maybe the great public health nutrition question
of our era."

The other worrisome aspect of the carbohydrate trade-off is the
possibility that, for some individuals, at least, it might actually be
easier to gain weight on low-fat/high-carbohydrate regimens than on
higher fat diets. One of the many factors that influence hunger is the
glycemic index, which measures how fast carbohydrates are broken down
into simple sugars and moved into the bloodstream. Foods with the
highest glycemic index are simple sugars and processed grain products
like pasta and white rice, which cause a rapid rise in blood sugar after
a meal. Fruits, vegetables, legumes, and even unprocessed
starches--pasta al dente, for instance--cause a much slower rise in
blood sugar. Researchers have hypothesized that eating high-glycemic
index foods increases hunger later because insulin overreacts to the
spike in blood sugar. "The high insulin levels cause the nutrients from
the meal to get absorbed and very avidly stored away, and once they are,
the body can't access them," says David Ludwig, director of the obesity
clinic at Children's Hospital Boston. "The body appears to run out of
fuel." A few hours after eating, hunger returns.

If the theory is correct, calories from the kind of processed
carbohydrates that have become the staple of the American diet are not
the same as calories from fat, protein, or complex carbohydrates when it
comes to controlling weight. "They may cause a hormonal change that
stimulates hunger and leads to overeating," says Ludwig, "especially in
environments where food is abundant. ..."

In 1979, 2 years after McGovern's committee released its Dietary Goals,
Ahrens wrote to The Lancet describing what he had learned over 30 years
of studying fat and cholesterol metabolism: "It is absolutely certain
that no one can reliably predict whether a change in dietary regimens
will have any effect whatsoever on the incidence of new events of
[coronary heart disease], nor in whom." Today, many nutrition
researchers, acknowledging the complexity of the situation, find
themselves siding with Ahrens. Krauss, for instance, who chairs the AHA
Dietary Guidelines Committee, now calls it "scientifically naпve" to
expect that a single dietary regime can be beneficial for everybody:
"The 'goodness' or 'badness' of anything as complex as dietary fat and
its subtypes will ultimately depend on the context of the individual."

Given the proven success and low cost of cholesterol-lowering drugs,
most physicians now prescribe drug treatment for patients at high risk
of heart disease. The drugs reduce LDL cholesterol levels by as much as
30%. Diet rarely drops LDL by more than 10%, which is effectively
trivial for healthy individuals, although it may be worth the effort for
those at high risk of heart disease whose cholesterol levels respond
well to it.

The logic underlying populationwide recommendations such as the latest
USDA Dietary Guidelines is that limiting saturated fat intake--even if
it does little or nothing to extend the lives of healthy individuals and
even if not all saturated fats are equally bad--might still delay tens
of thousands of deaths each year throughout the entire country. Limiting
total fat consumption is considered reasonable advice because it's
simple and easy to understand, and it may limit calorie intake. Whether
it's scientifically justifiable may simply not be relevant. "When you
don't have any real good answers in this business," says Krauss, "you
have to accept a few not so good ones as the next best thing."


----------------------------------------------------
Sign Up for NetZero Platinum Today
Only $9.95 per month!
http://my.netzero.net/s/signup?r=platinum&refcd=PT97


--
The silver-list is a moderated forum for discussion of colloidal silver.

To join or quit silver-list or silver-digest send an e-mail message to: 
[email protected]  -or-  [email protected]
with the word subscribe or unsubscribe in the SUBJECT line.

To post, address your message to: [email protected]
Silver-list archive: http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/index.html
List maintainer: Mike Devour <[email protected]>