To make a long story short I used CS in my holding tank on my boat, the
other chemicals do not seem to last.
I used 20 ounces in the spring and added a few ounces several times during
season.
Normally I have tank pumped out several times  as it gets full, lack of use
this year it did not get full.
I pulled my boat Nov 1 and had a pump out the day before.
I expected it to be really rank, but to my surprise no smell at all.
It must have killed all the bacteria.

   SICKLEAVE (boat name)