Hi Mike, I'm in up to my ankles in my unfinished projects, head first. So it will be a while before I get back to this topic, but it's fascinating. I suspect the neutralization of hydronium or hydroxyl by the electrode current alters the concentration, hence the dynamic equilibrium; thus leading to rapid formation of more . I further imagine this effect propagates to the neighboring water molecules. Analogous perhaps to the speed of travel of an electron in a metal conductor vs. the speed of charge propagation. I'll have to think a bit about the effect of the silver ions or the hydroxide on them.
Cabbage is good!  Anthocyanin, though, hmmm . . .
How about a series of neutral sensors across the active area . . . can you really pick up a Hall effect on such a diffuse and tiny signal? Wow!! How about a mini-fish tank, flat sides, less visual distortion, close together, less volumetric spread, anyone who will put cabbage juice in their CS should be willing to chance a few molecules of acetic from mostly cured silicone rubber, . . . maybe, . . . . sorta, <g> Or line the innards with polybag. Dunno about sensor electrodes, kinda tricky but may be able to cancel out their electrolytic effects. I could send you a few of the pH dipsticks I get, they don't bleed;
"pH indicator strips, non-bleeding   Cat. #9590
colorpHast  pH  0-14
EM Reagents"

Made in Germany US Pat. 4,029,598 EM Science, 480 Democrat Road, Gibbstown, NJ 08027

I see it all now:
Four thin glass droppers, capped and spaced along the area of interest, a strip in each. Quickly he pulls all four stoppers simultaneously - the tubes fill, the strips color, the voltmeters record, the stoppers go back in as the sleepless experimenter tremblingly removes the . . . . Oh, Shit! one of the stoppers is missing! The sensor slipped out the bottom! The microvoltmeter is shorting out against the positive pole . . . Blue Smoke!

Hmmm, I think I need to get a little more rest; sleep dep. is usually counter-productive.
Take care,  Malcolm
P.S. more below

At 08:20 PM 10/12/03 -0400, you wrote:

url: http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/m63427.html
Re: CS>Re: Measuring ppms
From: Malcolm Stebbins
Date: Sun, 12 Oct 2003 03:21:54

  Hi Malcolm,

  I posted  this early this morning but it seems to  have disappeared.
  Sympatico has  been  unreliable  all week so I  assume  it  is lost.
  Please forgive  if it shows up later, but I wanted to thank  you for
  your excellent  comments and help on my question. I think  I figured
  it out - see if it makes sense to you.

  [... snip nice discussion on Bronsted Lowry Proton Transfer theory]

  >> Electrons cannot  propagate  in an electrolyte.  Current  flow is
  >> through the movement of ions only.

  > BTW, Mike, this is not strictly true, but it may be so for aqueous
  > electrolytes - dunno.

  I think it's true for any liquid electrolyte, but I'm not sure about
  solid polymers  such as film batteries. Do you know of  any examples
  of electron conduction in a liquid electrolyte?

Yes, Birch Reduction utilises a solution of electrons, not ions, in dry cold (I think alcohols, I'll have to look it up.) Very pretty blue color.




  > Hey, if water swaps protons around in the form of  hydronium ions,
  > does that mean it's a semiconductor and 'holes' propagate??

  This is  amusing. The same thought occurred to me. I found  some web
  sites that  discussed the movement of protons  via  water molecules.
  This apparently  occurs  very  quickly  -  on  the  order  of  a few
  femtoseconds. So  movement  of   the   hydroxyl  ion  could  also be
  explained by proton transfer in the opposite direction.

And There Ya Go!!  Much more clearly than I said it!


  Ivan's data indicated the hydroxyl ion moves 6 times faster than the
  silver ion  under an applied field. This should  mean  the diffusion
  velocities whould  also be different by the same ratio. So I  set up
  an experiment  to  visualize the ions using  red  cabbage  juice and
  managed to get just the right amount to see both species.

  The ions met in the middle between the electrodes! This was amazing.
  It contradicted  everything I had learned up to that point.  This is
  described in experiment #2 at

    http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/m61491.html

  I was  too  astonished to take accurate notes of the  time,  and the
  hydroxyl ion  turned  the  solution   a   deep  color  that  made it
  impossible to see anything past the halfway point. So I repeated the
  experiment using  salt,  which did not show the  hydroxyl  ion. This
  gave the  approximate velocity of the silver ion, and  showed  it is
  much slower than even very gentle convection currents:

    http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/m61527.html

  [...]

  >> The ones further away may know an electric field is  present, but
  >> their drift velocity due to the electric field is  perhaps orders
  >> of magnitude less than their thermal velocity, and much less than
  >> the diffusion velocity.

  > Diffusion velocity?? If I'm going 100 mph back and forth randomly,
  > and at the same time I'm propagating steadily toward San Francisco
  > at 10 mph, I'm gonna get there; the traffic opposing me  cannot be
  > any thicker than the traffic going my way.

  Yes, it  is  very  similar to the  Fermi  velocity  of  electrons in
  metals, typically one-tenth the speed of light. Even though they are
  moving very  fast, the drift velocity is about the same as  a person
  walking.

  But that's not the problem.

  Current is  the  movement of charge carriers. This  is  electrons in
  metals, electrons  and  holes in  semiconductors,  and  positive and
  negative ions in electrolytes.

Water is its own electrolyte;  paradigm shift.


  Consider a long tube with silver electrodes at each end, filled with
  dw. Apply a constant current.

  From the above experiments, there will be no silver or hydroxyl ions
  in the middle of the tube at the beginning when current is applied.

  Yet as more ions enter the solution, the conductivity  increases. So
  my question  is how do the ions know there are more of  them  in the
  solution so the conductivity can increase?

Here is my guess on it; the "ions" to consider are the dissociated water, and the effect travels quickly because it is a question of dynamic equilibrium as the water 'splits' and reforms very rapidly. Thus the effect of an electrode reforming a non-ion is the almost immediate establishment (remember how strong the H(+) and OH(-) are) of a replacement pair, to restore the dissociative equilibrium. And although I can't comment on the interaction of the imposed electric field in all this, it's my WAG that the initial, rapid (and possibly strongest overall?) effect is due to communication of dissociation anomalies like a row of dominoes, triggering highly localised alterations in the water's pH. Or Something like that . . . gotta go.


  Take a Hall current probe that can measure DC current.

  Measure the  current  in  the wires. It  will  give  the  same value
  anywhere along the wires.

  Now measure  the current anywhere along the tube. It  will  give the
  same value  anywhere  along the tube. It has to.  The  current  in a
  series circuit is the same everywhere.

Quibble, Quibble; space effects; dunno, too tired.


  But there  are no silver or hydroxyl ions in the middle of  the tube
  yet. So where are the charge carriers coming from that  generate the
  magnetic field detected by the Hall probe?

  My conclusion  is they must be the ions from the  trace contaminants
  in the dw. But they have a much lower concentration than the ions we
  are now making at the electrodes.

  The second conclusion is they must move faster to keep  the magnetic
  field the same value. Therefore there will be a  non-uniform voltage
  distribution along the tube. This should be easy to measure.

  But these  ions must exist. There must be a continuous  path through
  the water from one electrode to the other, containing ions  that can
  move. That's why my freezing experiment was doomed to failure.

  Hmm.. This was posted on Saturday, Sept. 27. But it doesn't  show up
  in the  archives,  so I can't give you a link. I'll try  to  post it
  later when I have some time. The experiment failed, but there  was a
  very interesting foonote.

  Thanks for  your  interesting analysis, Malcolm. It's  refreshing to
  find someone who knows the theory of chemistry.

You overestimate my knowledge, more the intellectual pack-rat than the student, but Thanks, anyway!!


Best Regards,

Mike Monett

Best Regards,

Mike Monett


--
The silver-list is a moderated forum for discussion of colloidal silver.

Instructions for unsubscribing may be found at: http://silverlist.org

To post, address your message to: [email protected]

Silver-list archive: http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/index.html

List maintainer: Mike Devour <[email protected]>




---
Incoming mail is certified Virus Free.
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.516 / Virus Database: 313 - Release Date: 9/1/03

---
Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free.
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.516 / Virus Database: 313 - Release Date: 9/1/03