Ode Coyote wrote: > The idea that ionic silver can cause argyria comes from slurring > distinctions between "our" definition of ionic with 'all' definitions of > ionic...substituting 'intent of meaning' within OUR context of conversation > with technicalities from another.
Unfortunately the context of OUR conversation is in contradiction with that of the rest of the chemical world. If one is speaking of ionic silver with respect to EIS, then they are discussing silver hydroxide of less than 20 ppm, mixed with a colloidal component that is I believe is an argyria preventative. Silver hydroxide is an ionic silver, and we are correct in calling it such. However so is any silver compound dissolved in water, and that is the gotcha. When a research indicates that ion forming silver salts CAN cause argyria, he is correct. EIS it probably one of the very few exceptions to this. > > > Silver Citrate etc is technically ionic when dissolved in water and can be > made at thousands of PPM, but that's not what we're talking about when > dealing with 'only' water and silver that fairly reliably turn to 'sludge' > you wouldn't 'use' at more or less 50-100 PPM and it's no longer wholley > "ionic" within our context of meaning. If you do use very high PPM sludge for > a long time, there IS a risk of agyria [Stan Jones]...but no one here does > that. I believe that Stan Jones was taking silver compounds, such as silver chloride and silver fluoride from the fluoridation and chlorination of the water. Also depending on where the water came from (IE a lake or river especially), then a significant amount of silver nitrate could have been in there as well. It definitely was NOT properly made EIS. When using water with chlorine, flourine, nitrates and so forth in them, then you will end up with 100% silver compounds, and asolutely NO colloidal portion until all the reactive impurites are consumed by reacting with silver ions. Thus you can not only end up with a silver ionic content much greater than the 20 or so ppm that is possible with properly made EIS, but absolutely no colloidal portion to act as a prophylatic against argyria. > > > It's a Bait and Switch use of language. I am not sure it is so much a bait and switch as it is that we have formed our own definitions of things in this group which in some cases run counter to the rest of the world (IE chemists and researchers). I still prefer to use EIS, and the ionic and colloidal portions of EIS for conciseness. If someone says ionic silver alone, it is not clear if they mean the ionic portion of EIS, or a silver compound dissolved in water. Although here we would likely assume the former, a chemist would assume the latter. If we want to correct misconceptions given to the public by researches or colloidal silver bashers, we have to understand the terms that chemists use. If we attack the researcher for using the correct term, because it conflicts with our own list useage of that term, then it makes us look like we don't know what we are talking about and certainly does not give us credibility in any discussions. Marshall > > > Ode > > At 02:16 PM 3/25/2005 -0500, you wrote: > > > >Terry Chamberlin wrote: > > > >> All this discussion of what happens when > >> ionic/colloidal silver enters the body, what is > >> happening in the stomach and then in the blood, how > >> such-and-such cannot be happening or in fact must be > >> happening reminds me of the solid, logical scientific > >> proof that the bumblebee CANNOT fly. > >> > >> To read Frank's "scientific", "logical" "proof" that > >> ionic silver is not worth taking is laughable, even > >> pathetic, in the face of its obvious benefit against > >> everything from colds to MS. > > > >I agree that ionic silver works. > > > >> > >> > >> Even Frank's responses here on this list have been > >> disappointing. On his site he warns that ionic silver > >> can cause argyria (a claim I have seen absolutely NO > >> substantiation for whatsoever - cite to me ONE case, > >> Frank), then abmits that it would take an amount none > >> of the standard CS-brewers are even capable of > >> brewing. > >> > > > >Check the archives, several reported cases of argyria caused from WaterOz, > >and Rosemary Jacobs got it from silver nitrate. There are a number of > >documented cases from silver chloride. All are ionic silver, WaterOz is > >silver citrate which is certainly ionic silver when dissolved. There are > >no cases of argyria from properly made EIS, which contains silver > >hydroxide/oxide and colloidal silver particles. > > > >> > >> Why does he then mention it? I am forced to conclude > >> that he makes that point for the fear affect it has on > >> those readers who don't notice his inconsistency, to > >> scare them into buying his product. > > > >He mentions it because it is true. Argyria can be gotten from silver > >compounds that dissolve in water and form silver ions. I cannot I believe > >argyria can be gotten from EIS due to two factors, the maximum ionic > >content of about 20 ppm, and the propholatic effect of the colloid portion. > > > >> > >> > >> He might as well, as we regularly see the medical > >> establishment do, report the possibility of Vitamin A > >> overdose to scare you into buying his "special" kind > >> of Vit A (without mentioning how most Vit A overdoses > >> are from synthetic Vit A). In fact, his scare tactics > >> to persuade you to buy his product and avoid all > >> others sound remarkably similar to the tactics used by > >> the medical establishment. (Eerie music, sculking men > >> in black overcoats, "Is Frank an undercover agent for > >> the Medical Mafia?") > >> > >> Nope, I sincerely doubt it. But using the same > >> logically-dishonest, misdirecting, inuendo-laden > >> approach as those who ARE agents for the bad guys does > >> not create confidence in him or his product. > >> > >> If 10% of what Frank declares about the safety of > >> ionic silver was true, there would be 500 cases per > >> year of argyria, and the FDA would have made the > >> brewing and/or drinking of anything with silver in it > >> a felony. > > > >There are hundreds of cases of argyria from silver compounds which produce > >silver ions when dissolved. There are none, as far as I know from properly > >made EIS or colloid silver. > > > >> > >> > >> The worst part is that Frank's pseudo-scientific, > >> unprovable, unsubstantiated claims make good > >> propaganda for silver opponents to use, howeverever > >> unrealistic they actually are. > > > >Maybe, can you give me an example. For the one you are giving in this > >message, Frank is correct. Silver compounds that dissolve and form ionic > >silver can cause argyria when not mixed with any colloidal silver to > >prevent it. > > > >Marshall > > > >> > >> > >> Frank, clue in to the disservice you are doing to the > >> silver community. Selling your product is not the > >> highest priority in life. Community and caring about > >> others is. > >> > >> > >> __________________________________ > >> Do you Yahoo!? > >> Yahoo! Small Business - Try our new resources site! > >> http://smallbusiness.yahoo.com/resources/ > >> > >> -- > >> The Silver List is a moderated forum for discussing Colloidal Silver. > >> > >> Instructions for unsubscribing are posted at: http://silverlist.org > >> > >> To post, address your message to: [email protected] > >> Silver List archive: http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/index.html > >> > >> Address Off-Topic messages to: [email protected] > >> OT Archive: http://escribe.com/health/silverofftopiclist/index.html > >> > >> List maintainer: Mike Devour <[email protected]> > > > > > > > > > > > >-- > >Internal Virus Database is out-of-date. > >Checked by AVG Anti-Virus. > >Version: 7.0.308 / Virus Database: 266.7.4 - Release Date: 3/18/2005 > > > > > > -- > Internal Virus Database is out-of-date. > Checked by AVG Anti-Virus. > Version: 7.0.308 / Virus Database: 266.7.4 - Release Date: 3/18/2005 > > Internal Virus Database is out-of-date. > Checked by AVG Anti-Virus. > Version: 7.0.308 / Virus Database: 266.7.4 - Release Date: 3/18/2005 > > -- > Internal Virus Database is out-of-date. > Checked by AVG Anti-Virus. > Version: 7.0.308 / Virus Database: 266.7.4 - Release Date: 3/18/2005

