Hi All,
 
I was reading section 17.1.1.2 of RFC 3261 and I had some basic questions, so I 
thought I will ask the experts.
 
1. What is the UAC supposed to do when it is in the Proceeding state and it 
does not receive any final response? The text in section 17.1.1.2 does talk 
about this case. Also when I look at the flow in Firgure 5, there seems to be 
no timer attached to get out of the 'Proceeding' state. There is one attached 
to 'Calling' (Timer B) and 'Completed' (Timer D) states, but none to 
'Proceeding' state. So are we saying that once you get into Proceeding state 
and the other end fails for some reason, the UAC is stuck.
 
Or is the figure inaccurate and it should really show a Timer B associated with 
one of the arrows coming out of that state? In which case my questions would be 
does a provisional response reset this timer? Otherwise an INVITE transaction 
would be constrained to 32secs assuming a T1 of 500ms (i.e. a call should go 
from 'Calling' to 'Completed' in 32secs!
 
Appreciate your responses.
 
Thank you.
- Ajay  
_______________________________________________
Sip-implementors mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.cs.columbia.edu/mailman/listinfo/sip-implementors

Reply via email to