>why don’t we adopt a consistent naming approach like this: > > - kubectl.SlackBuild (compiles from source) > - kubectl-bin.SlackBuild (repacks prebuilt binaries)This question was actually raised a few days ago in a thread about a proposed SlackBuild template for packaging pre-built binaries. It also proposed to name scripts for repackaging software as *-bin, and in the following discussion I felt that the consensus was to use exactly that naming scheme for SlackBuilds, except for cases when repackaging a binary is the only SBo-compatible way (like proprietary software).So you should ask the current maintainer of kubectl to rename the SlackBuild to kubectl-bin or even remove it altogether if building from source doesn't require many dependencies and not resource-intensive.
IMHO, we don't really need a spesific template for pre-built binaries, since it's just a matter of packaging. We can just use the existing templates and adjust it with the project we are trying to package. Template is useful when there's a spesific ways of packaging projects using different build tools, like rust, go, python, perl, etc. I agree with *-bin naming thing. It's consistent with what we have currently in our repo.
as for kubectl, i didn't know the situation when i took over kubectl from Dimitris and pushed the public update. I saw he was trying to remove it, so i took over because i used it. If r1w1s1 wants to provide a script for building it from source, feel free to send PR.
I will submit a new script kubectl-bin for this purpose.During normal cycle like nowadays, renaming is two-way process: Add new script and remove old one. It has to be done manually since it need to be populated in the database.
For mass renames, i would suggest to do it during development for new SBo repo for next Slackware release. Since everything is not yet populated in the database, we can do "wild" things in the repo: adding new scripts, renames, delete broken scripts, etc.
-- Willy Sudiarto Raharjo
OpenPGP_signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
_______________________________________________ SlackBuilds-users mailing list [email protected] https://lists.slackbuilds.org/mailman/listinfo/slackbuilds-users Archives - https://lists.slackbuilds.org/pipermail/slackbuilds-users/ FAQ - https://slackbuilds.org/faq/
