I disagree.

All of our systems are compromised in terms of RF performance.
We have no defined ground plane or counterpoise to the antenna and no
consistent manner of installation.

Carbon fiber just adds to the mess, it doesn't create a mess that
wasn't already there.

So what you are saying is that there is no way to do a useful ground
range check with a plane that has carbon fiber. There are so many
factors that are not in the control of the modeler that no test can be
valid.
If this is really true then carbon fiber is a major safety hazard and
should be banned right away. After all it makes it impossible to test
for proper operation of the radio gear before flight.
A proper ground range check before flight is required by the AMA
safety code, so an AMA modeler cannot fly without doing a ground range
check. If it is not valid then what to do?

The problems of reflections are always there even when there is NO
carbon in the plane. Somehow we have managed to get at least a working
idea of what is going on even with imperfect testing.
Should we require all planes be chamber tested before first flight and
at regular intervals?
Carbon or not it is the only way to get really solid tests, but the
question is, do we really need tests that good?

Probably not.

After all, we see far more flights where everything works than ones
where the pilot loses control due to a link failure.
Even the majority of crashes are easily traced to pilot imput. I can
think of several cases where it probably would have been better if the
radio had not sent my command through.

Carbon fiber is not magic and it is not really anything new. Radios
have have trouble with metal pushrods next to antennas and other thing
for years before any CF was in our planes at all.

How can you do an airborn range check of a plane that you expect to
fly away out of control at any moment?

michael
RCSE-List facilities provided by Model Airplane News.  Send "subscribe" and 
"unsubscribe" requests to [EMAIL PROTECTED]  Please note that subscribe and 
unsubscribe messages must be sent in text only format with MIME turned off.  
Email sent from web based email such as Hotmail and AOL are generally NOT in 
text format

Reply via email to