Aaron,

We really ought to get Mark Drela in on this one!  I am over my head,
technically speaking.

But that doesn't stop me from speculating!

I assume by shear center that you mean the effective center of the wing beam
- the location that is effectively resisting the wing deflection.  This is
typically behind the quarter chord, especially on sheeted wings, for several
reasons.  I believe that there is an attempt, even when locating a discrete
spar, to balance wing torsion due to lift offset from the spar on the one
hand with wing torsion due to the section moment on the other.  The lift one
is typically leading edge up (LEU) during high loads whereas the moment one
is leading edge down (LED) at high speeds.

An upward gust tends to twist the wing LEU for two reasons.  First, the lift
is in front of the spar, so to speak.  Second, the mass CG of the wing is
behind the lift also, so any upward acceleration tends to twist the wing
LEU.

I think that it is primarily this second phenomenon that drives flutter at
high speed where the wing loads are low, but accelerations are high.  At
high speed the upward twist further accelerates the wing upward, leading to
more twist and so on until the load is balanced by the wing structure.  But
there is a phase lag going on so now when the wing reaches the top
(accelerating down now) the wing twists down and the cycle repeats.  I
believe that the phase lag and the relative twist/deflection ratio are
sensitive to speed and this is why you see this at high speed.

By moving the local CG forward you can decouple the acceleration from the
twist and make the problem occur at higher speed or disappear.

The spar location is more likely to control the bend/twist interaction in
the steady-state case.  A wing that is flexible in torsion with an aft
(effective) spar location will be at risk for divergence.  The more it
deflects up (say), the more it pitches up, so the more load and so on.  At
some critical speed this cycle pumps itself up and the wing clicks off.
Mass balancing will not help this problem much.  It might help to some
extent because near to this divergence speed you can get the wing going with
a little bit of flutter.  I have done this twice with a Mirage - you get
about three cycles of increasing amplitude and then the wing clicks of at
the center...

Anyway, to answer your question directly, I think that the wing CG wants to
be near the local quarter chord, not a the spar location.  The idea is to
reduce or eliminate the couple between the lift and the mass.

I hope that this has added something to the discussion.

Regards,

Blaine Beron-Rawdon
Envision Design
San Pedro, Calfiornia, USA

----------
>From: Aaron Valdes <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
>To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
>Subject: mass balancing
>Date: Wed, Aug 16, 2000, 1:15 PM
>

>
> Blaine,
>  Would you try to match the CG of the local wing section to the quarter
> chord (approx lift center), or to the shear center? We have an inherent
> problem in that the shear center of our wings is not generally located at
> the point where the load is applied. So we have a shear coupling effect. I
> agree that moving the cg forward is a good thing, especially if the
> structure is displaying instability. This is a very interesting area for
> me. I wish I got to spend more time working on aero-elasticity problems.
> Any thoughts?
>
> Aaron Valdes
> Aerospace Engineer
> TRW Unmanned Aerial Vehicles
> (858) 592-4201 direct
> (858) 592-4228 fax
>
>
> 
RCSE-List facilities provided by Model Airplane News.  Send "subscribe" and 
"unsubscribe" requests to [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to