I am assuming since the comment of being uncomfortable due to "fiberglass particles from sanding" the fuselages were made form a male mold. A lot of Kevlar fuse's must be made from a male mold due to joining the seams in a female mold (wet seam) is much more difficult then fiber glass fuse's. I conclude if you have to sand the finish of either test specimen then you are removing any potential strength at an undetermined depth of material, the kevlar fuse may have molded up smoother then the fiber glass fuse requiring less sanding, or visa versa, then the test may have some validity. I have enough knowledge to know that Kevlar is much more tougher then fiber glass, but the test may have had a considerably different results if the fuselage's were made from a female mold with equal amount of epoxy and laid up to equal weights and NO sanding. I am open for any comments -----Original Message----- From: Bill Swingle <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: Walba, Rick <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; [EMAIL PROTECTED] <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Date: Thursday, August 31, 2000 6:14 PM Subject: [RCSE] Original WACO Results Kevlar vs. Glass >Sometimes being a packrat is handy. After searching, I've found the ORIGINAL >posting of the Kevlar vs. Glass tests done by Mr. WACO himself. This post >was originally sent out four years ago. Why a BASH kinda guy like me saved >it, I don't know. > >Bill Swingle >[EMAIL PROTECTED] >Janesville, CA > > >============================================== >From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] >Date: Sat, 25 May 1996 16:53:29 -0400 >Subject: [RCSE] Kevlar vs. Glass Fuselage Test > >The purpose of this test was to determine which material is superior for >construction of open size sailplane fuselages. > >Two WACO BETA fuselages were constructed. These fuselages were as close to >identical as possible except one was constructed of 1.4 oz plain weave >glass, one of 1.7 oz plain weave Kevlar. West System 105 resin and 206 >hardener were used for both fuselages, and similar reinforcements and layup >schedule were used for both fuselages. Both fuselages were tested at a >weight of 3 oz. The length of the BETA fuselage is 49 inches. > >The Torsion Test. A solid wooden plank was mounted to the fuselage at the >normal wing mount position. This plank was then clamped securely to a work >table. To counterbalance the weight of test apparatus at the tail, the nose >of the fuselage was prevented from rotating about the pitch axis, but was >free to rotate about the roll axis. A 15 inch lever arm was mounted at the >normal tail position. Weights were suspended from this arm, and the amount >of twist at the end of the lever was measured for each weight. Each >fuselage was tested twice. > >Results: >Torque in-oz 37.5 75 112.5 150 >avg glass twist 1.75 3.13 4.63 5.75 >Kevlar twist 1.00 2.13 3.13 4 > >Conclusion: The glass fuselage twisted significantly more than the Kevlar > >The Bend Test. Fuselages were suspended as for the torsion test. Weights >were suspended from the tail, and the displacement downward of the tail was >measured. Each fuselage was tested twice. > >Results: >Weight oz 6 12 18 24 30 >avg glass bend 0.25 0.57 0.9 1.13 1.38 >avg Kevlar bend 0.13 0.25 0.5 0.75 0.88 > >Conclusion: The glass fuselage bent significantly more than the Kevlar > >The Crush Test. Each fuselage was clamped firmly on it's side on the top of >a solid work table. Weights were placed on the fuselage in the area of >greatest diameter. The amount the fuselage crushed was measured. > >Weight in oz 64 128 >glass crush 0.16 0.25 >Kevlar crush 0.000 0.016 > >Conclusion: The glass fuselage was easier to crush than the Kevlar > >The Crash Test. This test was conducted in two parts. For both parts, the >fuselages were loaded with lead to simulate flying weight of about 52 oz. 4 >oz was mounted in the V-tail position, 18 oz was mounted internally, and 24 >oz were mounted to a spar which served as a wing. The fuselage CG was in >the normal flying position. > >For the first test, the fulselage was suspended at its CG from a tree limb >about 20 feet high. The fuselage was suspended as a pendulum, and would >strike the ground at an angle of approximately 30 degrees when released. >The fuselage was released at about a 5 degree angle from true. Each >fuselage was released at an arc distance of 1,2,3,4,5,6,7, and 8 feet, and >each distance was tested five times. > >Results: >Neither fuselage suffered any damage. > >Conclusion: Maryland sod is pretty soft this time of year, and it takes a >pretty hard crash to damage a fuselage. > >For the second test, the fuselages were dropped vertically onto a thick >doormat over a concrete floor. Each fuselage was dropped five times from >each height, starting at 6 inches and increasing in 6 inch increments. Each >fuselage was dropped at a 5 degree angle from dead vertical. > >Results: >Neither fuselage suffered any damage until a height of two feet was reached. >At two feet, on the fifth drop the glass fuselage suffered slight damage to >the tail boom just forward of the V-tail. It was still flyable. On the >first drop from 2.5 feet, the glass fuselage failed at the wing mount, and >forward of the V-tail. It was unflyable without repair. On the fifth drop >from 2.5 feet, the Kevlar fuselage was closely examined. The only damage >evident was a little crazing of the Kevlar/epoxy skin in the forward wing >mount area. The test was ended, and the Kevlar fuselage is still flyable. > >Conclusion: A Kevlar fuselage is more crashworthy than a glass one, >particularly when landing vertically on carpeted concrete. > >General Observations: It was obvious from the onset, that the glass >fuselage would be no match for the Kevlar. Just handling the fuselages >would be enough to convince an experienced pilot. The actual cost of the >Kevlar fuselage is about $16 more in terms of time and material. The glass >fuselage was more uncomfortable to construct due to fiberglass particles >from sanding. WACO will continue to offer 100% Kevlar fuselages and carbon >reinforced Kevlar fuselages. If a weight savings of 4 to 8 oz in open size >ships is significant to you, you might want to try a Kevlar fuselage. > > > > >RCSE-List facilities provided by Model Airplane News. Send "subscribe" and "unsubscribe" requests to [EMAIL PROTECTED] > RCSE-List facilities provided by Model Airplane News. Send "subscribe" and "unsubscribe" requests to [EMAIL PROTECTED]

