In a message dated 11/7/00 5:58:19 PM Eastern Standard Time, 
[EMAIL PROTECTED] writes:

> If you find someone to make these for you for 10.00 or 20.00 a template then
>  GO FOR IT. 

Very nice post Tom.

Just a few things to add.
I've seen a misconception about the .DXF outputs for airfoil templates.  If 
you look closely at the standard Compufoil DXF output, you will see that the 
actual profile is made from tiny individual line segments.  If you truly are 
anal about your profile, you can go in and edit these segments and "smooth" 
them with arc segments, but it really isn't necessary.  For all the templates 
I've laser cut, I leave the straight segments in place.  Why?  Because from 
the time you actually cut the template, polish the edges w/ 400+ grit and 
then run a hot wire thru foam, you will never see these "sharp" edged 
intersections.  With the laser cut the kerf of the cut zone usually is not 
refined enough to see these intersections, looking at the top LE surface 
(area of greatest profile curvature), the angle between the segments is 
~173^.  This 7^ deviation between two segments ~0.200" in length (SD7037, 10" 
chord) isn't enough to actually show up as a 'corner'.  If using a hard tool 
method, i.e. CNC Mill, these corners may show up, but with a laser and 
probably water jets, these corners are more or less blended.  When cutting 
metal the corners would definitely appear, but with "combustible" mat'l 
(formica, plastics, wood.....), it is very difficult to achieve such a fine 
definition.  Not impossible or indicative of inaccuracies, just very 
difficult and time consuming from a machine set up/production standpoint.
Now, a bit of advice:
If you or anyone else is interested in purchasing CNC cut parts of any type, 
by any method, do yourself a financial favor and draw <exactly> what you want 
cut, save it as a DXF and take it to the shop that will be making your parts. 
Why?  Because you will be charged for any engineering time that needs to be 
done to "clean up" your drawings, plus the programming time, plus the actual 
machine time.  For a typical quad taper planform, 5 sets of templates, I will 
usually spend ~4 hours on the computer cleaning up the DXF output from 
Compufoil and making the programs for the laser.  Then I'll spend roughly 
another hour in the shop setting up the machine and actually cutting the 
templates.  Rough numbers: the shop I work at bills ~$45-$50 for my time and 
the lasers are billed at ~$150/hour.  So, to walk in off the street w/ a 
Compufoil output DXF, you could easily spend $300 for a set of 5 templates.  
If you do most of the grunt work yourself, giving the shop a DXF of <exactly> 
what you want, then you've got ~1 hour plus of programming time plus the hour 
of shop time.  
Now, before all the laser cut kit producers jump in and say these prices are 
toooooo high, realize that these numbers are for a metal fab job shop.  I cut 
my templates on one of two Bystronic 2800W industrial lasers w/ 5' x 10' 
cutting beds capable of cutting 3/4" thk steel.  They are not small output 
machines and operating costs are a bit higher than a smaller sized, low 
wattage laser.  Also, if you go to somebody, LaserArts maybe, that cuts 
templates commercially, chances are that they might have your airfoil in your 
chord length already in the program library.  Then you're looking at some 
'administrative' cost to process the order, plus the mat'l and shop/machine 
time.
Sorry if this got long-winded, but it all seemed relevant when I typed it.  
:-)

Tom Miller
Carlisle, PA

RCSE-List facilities provided by Model Airplane News.  Send "subscribe" and 
"unsubscribe" requests to [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to