Some good posts on this thread.
As pointed out by Anker, flying at the air speed that produces the best L/D for a stationary airmass will by definition cover the most ground (horizontal movement) for the altitude lost (vertical movement). We as pilots are often interested in being able to travel as far as possible over the ground when the airmass IS moving, either horizontally (wind) or vertically (sink). Usually if the airmass is rising (lift) we are content to stay in that area of the airmass, and will even circle ;-)
The rule of thumb is to "speed up" in sink, or into the wind, and slow down in lift. But how much? And which airfoil/planform/airframe configurations can still maintain a high L/D a a wider range of(higher and lower) airspeeds? This information would be wonderful to have. If drawn out graphically as a polar it would show for each aircraft design what to expect in the way the plane could be flown. It would also show to all on paper why some airfoils are notorious for being "fussy" about the speed they are flown at (sharply peaked polar) or not fussy (flat polar). If plotted with minimin sink speed and stall speed, and maybe even stall speed in landing configuration we could suddenly be able to know much about a design just by reading the (accurate ;-) performance data. Except for launch...hmmm
The basic desire would be a plane that could achieve it's best L/D even at very high (air) speed, allowing it to effortlessly penetrate even very high winds, at low wing-loadings. This low wing-loading plane with high speed L/D cruise then would still have a low sinkrate at low speed, allowing tight thermal turns in weak lift while still climbing and be able to slow way down to land.
This is pretty much exactly what most designs have been striving for, with compromises being made to optimize for regional or personal preferences. In the USA we have the popular "west coast" planes, i.e. the Addiction, which gives up range in wind for better climb and especially slower landing speeds, as in California we "always make our times anyway" and many contests are decided...literally...by a few inches difference in landing scores over a whole contest.
In Europe they have wind, lots of it, and low clouds and often poor lift. They prefer planes that perhaps don't land as accurately (they measure by the meter not the inch anyway) but can hang in the wind, then get back to the field after taking the one thermal way downwind to make the typically 10 minutes or longer European thermal task time. We fly (relatively) much shorter tasks with much higher precision landings, in different weather conditions.
Understanding and quantifying these performance and stylistic differences would seem to me to make a lot of sellers and purchasers of cool toys happier. There would be less of the suprise and dissapointment that I hear about when a model that is supposed to be "the best" doesn't do what the owner wants it to. Usually through no fault of it's own. This info would also make ballasting less of a "black art," at least some of the time anyways, and allow people to buy a range of planes to suit the conditions they expect to fly in. Plus lots more to debate on RCSE.
I think the technology is just about here now...
JR
John Roe
Laguna Hills, Ca
Do You Yahoo!?
Send FREE video emails in Yahoo! Mail.

