This range/glitch question seems to be one where it is very difficult to get
real world observations to match with theory. There must be some very subtle
real world variables that have a big impact on radio reception. Or there are
some elements of theory that are not well understood yet. I tend to get that
warm cozy feeling about a new area of knowledge once the theory and the real
world observations agree with one another. I'm not getting that feeling yet.

As part of my quest for that warm cozy feeling, I have some questions for
the theorists:.

Does antenna configuration matter? The Samba site shows some T shaped RX
antennas where the wire coming from the RX goes to the middle of another
wire. Should that work for 72MHZ also?

What happens when you coil a bunch of the RX antenna inside the fuse? Does
that have the same effect as shortening the antenna? What about doubling the
antenna back against itself (assuming the antenna wire is insulated). Does
the reciever still see a long antenna, or would that have the same effect as
cutting off half of the antenna?

Is there a difference between a 72MHZ Futaba transmitter and a 35MHZ Futaba
transmitter other than the RF module that plugs into the back of it?  When
the spacemodeling team went to the World Champs last year, Futaba lent us
some 35MHZ modules. It was our understanding that we could use these in our
existing (originally 72MHZ) transmitters. When we had problems oversees and
made some phone calls, we were told by  (a Futaba technical person I think)
that you can't just use a 35MHZ module in a 72MHZ transmitter. We did some
fast research and bought a new Futaba transmitter in Prague. That
(originally sold as 35MHZ) transmitter showed much greater ground range but
still glitched badly in the air. Perhaps that was just due to the carbon
issues, we may have had two problems originally. Our problems weren't solved
until we switched to what we called "stealth 72". That is to say we just
flew on 72MHZ and didn't say so (A sort of don't ask, don't tell policy).
Now back at home I have been flying some contests using my lovely new Futaba
9CAP "35MHZ" transmitter with 72MHZ modules. It works just fine. A friend of
mine who knows some RF theory says that you might expect a 35MHZ transmitter
to work on 72MHZ but not the other way around. Something about energy output
and the amount of energy in a 35MHZ vs. a 72MHZ signal. Have I perhaps been
blasting the airwaves with double the FCC allowable transmitter output by
transmitting on 72MHZ with a 35 MHZ transmitter? Did we have half the usual
power output when we tried transmitting on 35MHZ with a 72MHZ transmitter?
Does any of this make any sense at all?

I would be interested to know if anyone else has tried lengthening 72MHZ RX
antennas and what was the result. I put such an antenna in a HL model and
saw no adverse effects on ground range. I flew another  model with an
antenna that must have been about double length. It was a HL model so much
of the extra length was just coiled up inside the fuse. That model flew just
fine.

Eventually, if we get enough anecdotal evidence and we get enough theory, we
can compare the two and find a way to make the two agree. The biggest
disagreement I see so far is the "sacred 72MHZ RX antenna length" question.
We need better theory or better/more real world testing to settle that one.

Phil "In search of that cozy feeling" Barnes






RCSE-List facilities provided by Model Airplane News.  Send "subscribe" and 
"unsubscribe" requests to [EMAIL PROTECTED]  Please note that subscribe and 
unsubscribe messages must be sent in text only format with MIME turned off.

Reply via email to