Eirck, I meant having a replication factor of 1 in SolrCloud would not be scalable, I ended up using a replication factor of 1 , because of the disjoint replicas issue for replication factor greater than 1 , that I mentioned previously in the other email thread.
Are you saying that a SolrCloud cluster with a replication factor of 1 would be performant as well ? I had read in SolrCloud documentation that the required number of replicas is directly proportional to the number of queries(concurrent). Thanks On Sun, Nov 2, 2014 at 11:59 PM, Erick Erickson <erickerick...@gmail.com> wrote: > I _strongly_ urge you to try it before assuming it won't work. > > bq: It obviously seems will not be scalable due to the fact that the same core > will be indexed and queried at the same time as this is a long running > indexing task. > > What evidence do you have for this? SolrCloud is designed for this scenario. > You have to have a huge ingestion rate for this to be a problem, essentially > you > need to be pushing Solr's CPU utilization through the roof. > > I don't know of configurations where you can essentially have each of > your shards > act as a master in the old-style master/slave situation. But a lot of > people with > very high indexing and query rates seem to make SolrCloud work in > their situations, > before recommending anything I'd like to see some evidence that the stock > solution won't work. > > Best, > Erick > > On Sun, Nov 2, 2014 at 7:06 PM, S.L <simpleliving...@gmail.com> wrote: >> Resending this as I might have not been clear in my earlier query. >> >> I want to use SolrCloud for everything except the replication , is it >> possible to set up the master-slave configuration using different Solr >> instances and still be able to use the sharding feature provided by >> SolrCloud ? >> >> On Thu, Oct 30, 2014 at 6:18 PM, S.L <simpleliving...@gmail.com> wrote: >>> Hi All, >>> >>> As I previously reported due to no overlap in terms of the documets in the >>> SolrCloud replicas of the index shards , I have turned off the replication >>> and basically have there shards with a replication factor of 1. >>> >>> It obviously seems will not be scalable due to the fact that the same core >>> will be indexed and queried at the same time as this is a long running >>> indexing task. >>> >>> My questions is what options do I have to set up the replicas of the single >>> per shard core outside of the SolrCloud replication factor mechanism because >>> that does not seem to work for me ? >>> >>> >>> Thanks. >>>
