The crux of Mading’s case against the Assembly
Article
Comments (10)
email Email
print Print
pdfSave
separation
increase
decrease
separation
separation
By Zechariah Manyok Biar
February 9, 2012 — If integrity matters, then it should be practiced
impartially. If order of issues is what governs a democratic nation,
then it should be applied to all regardless of their status. The saga
of Mading Ngor of Bakhita Radio and the Legislative Assembly is
becoming interesting—interesting because it is showing the
contradictions that are common in South Sudan. Our laws seem to be
based on our feelings, not what they really are.
It was on Monday that Mading Ngor was mishandled by the security
guards at the Legislative Assembly. The media took the issue
seriously, forcing the Assembly to discuss the incident. The Assembly
appeared at first to convince many people in public about its
seriousness to deal with the issue impartially. The Speaker promised
on Tuesday that the matter would be investigated. It was indeed
investigated. But impartiality was killed before the investigations
were completed. The impartial investigation would have meant the
investigation of both sides: the guards and Mading in order to prove
the claims of each side against the other. But that was not the case.
On Wednesday the findings of the investigation were read out. The
findings were based on the statements given by the guards and people
that had nothing to do with the incident. Those people might have been
information volunteers during the investigation. But nobody even
bothered to establish their relationships with Mading in his
journalistic work.
Despite the partiality of the investigation, the reactions of the
Assembly were interesting. The members capitalized on the findings
without questioning the procedural justice that the Assembly should
care about. The media was blamed on how it reported the incident.
First, the Assembly could not believe that the Editor-in-Chief of
Citizen, Nhial Bol, wrote that the Assembly celebrated the beating of
Mading Ngor. Hon. Aleu Ayieny who brought this allegation to light
denied the allegation and suggested that the Paper (The Citizen) be
taken to court by the Assembly.
I agree with Hon. Aleu Ayieny that the Assembly never celebrated the
beating of Mading Ngor. First, Mading did not say he was beaten. He
said he was violently carried to the point his trousers were torn.
Second, the Assembly applauded when one of their members suggested on
Tuesday that the incident be investigated and that the guards
responsible be held accountable. When Hon. Aleu accused Mading of
trouble-making that day, the Chairperson of Information Committee in
the Assembly disputed Aleu’s allegations. All this showed that the
Assembly never celebrated the mishandling of Mading Ngor.
If Mr. Nhial Bol should be taken to court for misinforming the public,
then he should indeed be taken to court. But the Assembly would win
the case in court if it is free from such a practice. My fear is that
the Assembly is not free from misinforming the public. In its findings
during the investigation, one of the findings read out to the Assembly
on Wednesday by the Chairperson of Information Committee was that
Mading Ngor was found to be just a freelance Journalist not the
Journalist of Bakhita Radio as he claims. I waited for more
clarification on that point, but that was it. No any other evidence
was given about the finding.
This, to me, falls under the category of the misinformation to public
in an attempt to tarnish the name of the Journalist in the same way
that Nhial Bol misinformed the public in order to tarnish the name of
the Assembly. If the Assembly was the master of correct information,
it would have gone to Bakhita Radio to find out whether Mading is a
Journalist of Bakhita Radio or not. In its News at 8:00am on Thursday,
Bakhita Radio announced that the Assembly banned its Journalist Mading
Ngor from attending the session of the Assembly. If Mading was not a
Journalist of Bakhita, then why would Bakhita call him its Journalist?
Is the Assembly’s finding correct? If this finding failed the test,
why would the public believe other points in the investigation
findings?
The other interesting part was when Hon. Kom Kom said that during the
investigation, they were told that Mading was causing trouble
throughout in the Assembly. Mark the word “throughout.” If throughout
really means what it says, then ten times that Mading was accused of
causing trouble would be a drop in the ocean. Throughout would mean
counting the sessions that Mading attended in the Assembly and adding
them up to find how much. According to Mading, he had been attending
the secessions of the Assembly for five months and we know that the
Assembly has three sessions per a week. So, five months times sessions
of the Assembly each week would be more than ten times and that
contradicts the statement by the Chairperson of the Information
Committee that the investigation findings was that Mading caused
trouble ten times. If, on the other hand, the statement by Hon. Kom
Kom was an exaggeration, then why blame Nhial Bol for the same
behavior?
Coming to the point of the order of issues, a country where order of
activities is valued should always have laws in place to regulate the
order of issues. Here in South Sudan, we seem to act on emergencies
often even when we have time to do things on time. Take for example
the Wednesday call from the Assembly for the Executive to present the
Media Bill quickly for deliberations and passage simply because of the
case of Mading Ngor despite the fact that the Media Bill has been
sitting in the Council of Ministers for years. What guarantee will the
media have that the bill is not going to be based on the anger of the
Assembly, making it a law against the media than a law meant to
regulate the activities of the media?
The fear of media often presents suspicion on Government’s
accountability and transparency. If our Government is a Government who
fought for freedom as we know, then why would it fear the media? The
media is the only tool that the Government should use to let the
public know how things are done. Sitting on the Media Bill means that
transparency is imprisoned. Now that things are getting out of hand,
the bill is going to be discussed in a way that the fear would clearly
be spelled out, tarnishing the image of the country internationally.
The suing of Nhial Bol would be baseless without the Media Act in
place. Forcing it on different Articles would mean injustice. You
convict somebody for knowingly breaking the existing law. But now,
where is the law that regulates Nhial’s writing? The regulations that
regulate the relationships of the Assembly with the media are not even
in existence. What a system!
Zechariah Manyok Biar lives in Juba, the Republic of South Sudan. He
can be reached at [email protected]
The views expressed in the 'Comment and Analysis' section are solely
the opinions of the writers. The veracity of any claims made are the
responsibility of the author not Sudan Tribune.
If you want to submit an opinion piece or an analysis please email it
to [email protected]
Sudan Tribune reserves the right to edit articles before publication.
Please include your full name, relevant personal information and
political affiliations.
--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
[email protected].
For more options, visit this group at
http://groups.google.com/group/SouthSudanKob?hl=en.