An Analysis of the Transitional Constitution of South Sudan in regard
to Good Practices of Governance by Stephen Pande
 June 22nd, 2012

By: Stephen Pande

Justice Africa

Tuesday, 23 April, 2012



Introduction

This paper will examine the Transitional Constitution of South Sudan
through the lens of some generally acknowledged good practices of
governance.

The paper will begin by outlining its conceptual framework and then
analyze whether or not the forms of governance provided for in the
Transitional Constitution are in line with international norms.
Subsequently, the paper will examine the values of the liberation
struggle and whether these are upheld in the Transitional
Constitution. Finally, the paper will outline recommendations for what
should be discussed in the process of making the permanent
constitution.



Conceptual Framework

A national constitution is the instrument that defines the fundamental
principles and institutions of governance in that country. It does so
by establishing the basic structures and powers of government,
determining their terms of reference, and regulating the relationships
between them. A constitution is therefore a power map that defines the
relationship between different arms of government.

This paper will use a threefold conceptual framework which will
examine the Transitional Constitution through;
 •A political perspective that recognizes some widely accepted best
practices of governance,
 •A historical analysis based on the view that constitutions are often
the result of a break from the past – and consequently the values that
necessitated such a change should be incorporated when re-defining the
emerging new polity.
 •A sociological perspective that focuses on the argument that the
“Will of the People’’ should be the foundation of state formation

The underlying presumption behind this conceptual framework is the
conviction that democracy is the most effective and legitimate means
of governance and therefore, the basic principles of democracy are the
benchmarks of good governance.



Best practices of governance

Elections and the distribution of positions in government

The 2002 African Union Heads of States and Government’s 38th Ordinary
Session in Durban South Africa articulated the following as part of
the AU Principles of Democratic Elections;

1. Democratic elections are the basis of the authority of any
representative government;

2. Regular elections constitute a key element of the democratization
process and therefore are essential ingredients for good governance,
the rule of law, the maintenance and promotion of peace, security,
stability and development;

3. The holding of democratic elections is an important dimension in
conflict prevention, management and resolution;

4. Democratic elections should be conducted;
 •freely and fairly;
 •under democratic constitutions and in compliance with supportive
legal instruments;
 •under a system of separation of powers that ensures in particular,
the independence of the judiciary;
 •at regular intervals, as provided for in National Constitutions;
 •by impartial, all-inclusive, competent and accountable electoral
institutions staffed by well-trained personnel and equipped with
adequate logistical requirements.

The Transitional Constitution does not provide for most of these best
practices regarding elections. For example, it does not have a
provision on how and when elections will be held after the
transitional period.[1] While it is indeed commendable that the
Transitional Constitution provides that South Sudan is a multiparty
democracy and recognizes the significant role of political parties by
listing them as stakeholders in the making of the Permanent
Constitution (although the number of representatives of political
parties and CSOs nominated to the constitutional Review commission has
been considered unfair by these two sectors), it should have provided
a framework for elections. This has led to the peculiar position of
the government drafting legislation on elections that are not guided
by a constitution.

Elections will be a definite provision of the permanent constitution.
The civil society and political parties should therefore discuss and
place submissions on issues relating to elections. In so doing it is
important to examine what most constitutions traditionally define,
which include;
 •How positions in the constitutional and support structures are filled
 •The terms, period and termination of service of constitutional
office holder and other senior public officials
 •Specified term limits of constitutional positions
 •Methodology for removal prior to completion of term

The provision for a bi-cameral house by the Transitional Constitution

In consideration of the significance of elections in democratic
governance it is necessary to briefly discuss the provision for a
bi-cameral house by the Transitional Constitution.

The Transitional Constitution provides for a National Legislature that
is composed of two houses; the National Legislative Assembly and the
Council of States. Members of the National Legislative Assembly are
elected by the people and those of the Council of states are elected
through their respective State Assemblies.

Interestingly, the two houses conduct their business in joint sittings
chaired by the same speaker. How the two-tier house conducts its
business is complicated. For example, if a bill falls within the
competences of both Houses, the National Legislative Assembly first
discusses the issue and the Council of States is only allowed to
decide on it if an “Inter-House Committee” (whose composition is not
determined by the Transitional Constitution) forwards it to the
Council of States. The administration of proceedings is also very
complicated. For example, quorum is to be applied to each house
separately and their vote count is also separate.

While it is clear that the Transitional Constitution establishes a
two-tier legislature, it is unclear why key roles, particularly the
role of authorising resource allocation are the sole preserve of the
National Legislative Assembly and not the established “joint” National
Legislature.

If a bicameral house is to be retained, which may be appropriate, it
may be necessary that the permanent constitution provides for separate
sittings under different speakers. This is the usual practice in
systems with a bicameral system. The constitution should clarify the
issues that each house would discuss and as such distinguish their
respective powers.

After leaders are elected or nominated through processes provided in
the constitution, their powers must be balanced. The need to check and
balance the powers of leaders in modern times has culminated in some
widely acknowledged principles such as; separation of powers,
limitations of the power of the government, decentralization of powers
and what some political analysts  call diffusion of powers

Limitation of Powers

The principle of limitation of powers is central to
“constitutionalism.” Constitutionalism is achieved when government
institutions and political processes are effectively constrained by
constitutional rules. It is often expressed in the form of support for
constitutional provisions that achieve the goal of limiting
government.

The government should be legally limited in its powers – and its
authority depends on it observing those limitations. These limitations
are, for example, in the form of individual or group rights vs.
government powers such as the rights to free expression, association,
equality; and the due process of law. The rules imposing limits upon
government power must be entrenched in the constitution and the
government must not have the capacity to change those limits as they
please. An example of instances where the executive manipulates the
constitution, as is the tendency in some African countries, is when
the sitting president can alter the terms of presidency.

Separation of Powers

The principle of separation of powers requires that power is
distributed to the three arms the government (Legislature, Executive
and Judiciary). This principle implies that;
•There should be no overlap in the powers and functions of the
different arms of government;
 •There should be no overlap of personnel in the different arms of government;
 •None of the arms of the government should in any way interfere with
the functions and work of the other.

Traditionally the roles of the three arms are as follows;
 •The executive’s role is to implement laws and policies, provide
services, manage public resources, maintains public order and security
and manages relations with other governments.
 •The Legislature is composed of elected politicians, whose roles
include making laws, representing the interest of their constituents,
and checking the excesses of the Executive and the Judiciary.
•The Judiciary is the arm of the government that administrates
justice. It interprets and applies the law thus checking the excesses
of the Executive and the Legislature. It also carries out legal
reforms and reviews.

The interdependence of these three organs of governance can be
illustrated by the analogy of the fire place in an African set up
which has three stones with a pot on top. The pot symbolizes the
nation and the three stones symbolize the three arms of government.
The stones need to be balanced to provide support for the pot; this
balance symbolizes the balance of powers.

In the Transitional Constitution of South Sudan, the President has the
role of supervising constitutional and executive institutions. This
may mean that the Office of the President will have an administrative
oversight not only over executive institutions and the bureaucracy but
all the constitutional institutions, including the Judiciary and the
Legislature. What constitutional institutions means is not clear.

Furthermore, the principle of separation of powers requires that only
institutions of the Executive (not the Judiciary and the Legislature)
are under the direct supervision of the President.

Contrary to the principle of separation of powers, the Transitional
Constitution has various provisions in which presidential powers
interfere with legislative power. For example, it provides that the
president shall “convene, summon, adjourn or prorogue the National
Legislature in consultation with the Speaker”. This provision can be
subject to misuse. First, “in consultation with the Speaker” does not
seem to require a formal agreement of the Speaker. It is not the same
as saying “after consultation with.” So, the President may decide if
and when the National Legislature meets (or does not meet). This may
threaten the independence of the Legislature and the practice of
legislative power.

The transitional constitution of South Sudan also has several
provisions which may undermine the independence of the Judiciary. For
example, The President has powers to appoint all Justices and Judges
Courts (Courts of Appeal, High Courts, County Courts), subject only to
recommendation of the Judicial Service Commission whose members the
President appoints. In best governance practice, appointment of judges
and justices are often subjected to the scrutiny of the legislative
branch and high court justices have security of tenure. This is
because of the significant role of the Judiciary and the fact that it
is expected to be independent.

It may also be necessary to ensure that the functions of the
Independent Commissions do not interfere with the principle of
separation of powers. This can be done by ensuring that;
 •The relationships between these commissions and the relevant
ministries are well defined.
 •The central powers conferred to commission do not contradict
legislative powers
•The president does not have a predominant position in the appointment
process i.e.  the appointments and dismissal  can be subjected to  the
scrutiny of the legislature  or committees of the legislature
 •The commissions are accountable either to  parliament or committees
of parliament ( at least they should be accountable to a institution)



Decentralization

Decentralization means devolving powers from the central government.
In South Sudan powers are devolved to the state and local government
and the Traditional Authority.

The Transitional Constitution of South Sudan has a strong emphasis on
decentralisation.  This is evident in the fact that the Preamble
recognizes a decentralised system. However, the national government is
dominant over the state governments. The states do not have exclusive
powers as is the practice in federal political structures. The powers
of the states are mandated by the national government who can withdraw
state powers. While the Transitional Constitution expressly states
that the states have exclusive powers the schedules of powers gives
the central government the right to decide on what powers are given to
the states. Coupled with this, the President has the right to remove a
governor of a state and can disband the state legislatures, which
distorts the exclusive powers of the state.

The states also have no control over their own natural resources.
According to the Transitional  Constitution, the “Rights over all
subterranean and other natural resources throughout South Sudan,
including petroleum and gas resources and solid minerals, shall belong
to the National Government”. This means that it does not provide for a
specific quarter for the producing state.



Adherence to International Law and International Arbitration Processes

By joining the United Nations, South Sudan made a commitment to abide
by international law. Its constitution should thus recognise
commitments under international law, some of which include the
following;
 •All states are judicially equal
 •Each State enjoys the rights inherent in full sovereignty
 •Each State has the duty to respect the personality of other States.
 •The territorial integrity and political independence of each State
are inviolable.
 •Each State has the right freely to choose and develop its political,
social, economic and cultural systems;
 •Each state has the duty to comply fully (and in good faith) with its
international obligations and to live in peace with other states.
 •Every state shall refrain from any action aimed at the partial or
total disruption of the national unity and territorial integrity of
any other State or country.

One of the organs of the UN that the constitution must commit to abide
by, especially in consideration of the ongoing skirmishes between
North and South Sudan is the International Court of Arbitration. This
court, whose head quarters are at The Hague, is the judicial body of
the UN responsible for settling disputes among nations. It settles
disputes through – arbitration and judicial settlements. The
international court of arbitration was responsible for arbitrating
over the Abyei border. The many contested Sudan / South Sudan boarder
regions may have to be decided by the International court of
arbitration.



Diffusion of Powers

Diffusion of powers is a common practice in many young nations. It
requires that power must not be concentrated in any specific sector
(community, class gender etc) of the population. It requires that that
more and more power be distributed to the population or institutions
formed by the population.

a)    Traditional Authority

An excellent provision that encourages diffusion of powers is the
institution of Traditional Authority. “The institution, status and
role of Traditional Authority, according to customary law are clearly
recognized”.  This provision also enhances decentralisation.

While this is an important provision as it accepts the important role
that the Traditional Authority has historically played, the
Transitional Constitution has failed to clearly distinguish the roles
of the Traditional Authority and local government.

 Twenty-five Percent Affirmative Action for Women

The 25% quota for women in legislative and executive organs provided
in the Transitional constitution is yet another excellent aspect of
diffusion of powers. This is meant to ensure that control of power and
authority is not monopolised by men who have a definite advantage over
women because of history, customs and general practice. However, to
fully implement this provision, women will have to be considered in
practically all sectors including commissions and committees of the
executive and the legislative and constitutional positions in the
civil service, army, police and prisons etc.



The Values of the Liberation (Historical Perspectives)

Constitution making processes are often considerate of historical
dynamics and indeed the making of the permanent constitution provides
an opportunity for the people of South Sudan to ensure that the values
for which they fought are enshrined in the constitution.

Some of the values for which Southern Sudanese fought that should be
reflected in the constitution include;
 •Multiparty democracy as opposed to dictatorship
 •Equal opportunity for development for all citizens and regions.
 •Freedom and liberty
 •Free and independent media
 •A secular state that recognizes diversity in culture and religion

In its Preamble, the Transitional Constitution emphasises the values
of the liberation struggle and freedom by reflecting on the sacrifices
that led to attainment of freedom and remembering the martyrs who lost
their lives during the struggle for freedom.

As expressed in the preamble, the Transitional Constitution
acknowledges that the liberation resulted in wounds that need to be
healed and thus puts forth reconciliation as a value and aspiration of
the people of South Sudan. The others values put forth in the preamble
are poverty eradication and a decentralized multiparty democratic
system of government.  In all these, the preamble emphasises a
commitment to nurturing the values and principles of democracy and
good governance.

One of the major issues that the Transitional Constitution has left
open and which was central to the liberation struggle is identity.
Identity is usually expressed in provisions that define citizenship.
To have all rights as a South Sudanese citizen one has to be “born to
South Sudanese mother or father.” This definition is provided in the
Interim Constitution, specifically the section that refers to the
right to participate in the referendum. According to this provision,
which could also be included in the Permanent Constitution, a Southern
Sudanese is: Any person whose either parent or grandparent is or was a
member of any of the indigenous communities existing in Southern Sudan
before or on January 1, 1956; or whose ancestry can be traced to any
one of the ethnic communities of Southern Sudan; or any person who has
been permanently residing or whose mother and/or father or any
grandparent have been permanently residing in Southern Sudan as of
January 1, 1956.

Language and culture are important manifestations of the identity of a
people. The liberation struggle in South Sudan was a struggle to
defend the identity of South Sudanese. It is in this context that,
although Arabic is the most widely used language, it is not recognized
as the official language.

Instead the Transitional Constitution stipulates that “all indigenous
languages of South Sudan are national languages and shall be
respected, developed and promoted”.  It goes ahead and establishes
English as “the official working language” and states that that
English is “the language of instruction at all levels of education”.

Most of the values of the liberation listed at the beginning of this
sub-topic are captured by the Bill of Rights provided in the
Transitional Constitution. The Bill of Rights is a commitment on the
part of the government to ensure that the value and worth of mankind
is respected and promoted.

It provides for freedom from slavery, freedom from torture, right to
personal liberty, equality before the law, equality of women,
affirmative action for women ( 25% of the positions in legislature and
executive must be given to women), extensive rights for children,
right to a fair trial, 24 hour detention, right to a counsel for
serious offenses, right to practice your religion, right to freedom of
expression and the press, right to freedom of assembly and
association, right to political participation and voting, right to
freedom of movement and residence, right to education, right to public
health care, rights of  People with Special needs and the elderly, and
right to housing among others.

However, the Bill of Rights has several weaknesses.

Group rights activists argue that the language used in reference to
people with disabilities is more of a welfare language than a rights
based language and want the term “people with special needs” clearly
distinguished from “people with disabilities”.

Right to own property is granted but taken away with the provision
that states that it can be taken away if there is “consideration for
prompt and fair payment.” Prompt and fair payment is not strong
enough. For example if the state acquires your land, there must be not
only prompt and fair payment but prompt fair and equitable and
compensation.

Although it provides for some basic human rights such as the right to
housing it omits other fundamental human rights such as the right to
food. Food insecurity is a widespread problem which particularly
affects marginalised groups and it may be necessary that the right to
food should be incorporated.

The right to found a family is dictated by customary law which in a
deeply patriarchal society such as South Sudan impinge upon the rights
of women. Furthermore, under customary law it is very difficult for
women to gain a divorce which necessitate the inclusion of the right
to divorce. It may be necessary that the article on the right to found
a family be replaced with a more encompassing article such as the one
stipulated in the African Charter on the Rights of Women which  states
 “….Equal rights at marriage, during marriage and at its dissolution”.
There is also no marriageable age stated in the transitional
constitution which leaves young adults, especially the girl child in a
vulnerable position. It has been argued that an article clearly
stipulating that the marriageable age should be 18 years and above in
line with the UN Convention on the rights of the child.

The right of women to inherit from their husband is also weak because
it involves them sharing the inheritance with their children and this
places them in an unequal position to their husband.

The Transitional constitution is completely silent on gender based
violence. It is particularly important that the code of conduct for
the armed forces enshrines the army’s obligation to refrain from acts
of sexual and gender based violence.



“The Will of the People” (A sociological Framework)

In best governance practices, the people delegate power and
responsibility to the government to govern on their behalf. Such
delegation which is popularly known as “the will of the people” is the
last component of our conceptual framework.

The principle of the “Will of the People” is based on the conviction
that citizens need to be consulted on how they want the society to be
administered. This means that there should be a mechanism to enable
various groups to communicate their requests and needs. Such a
mechanism should ensure that all citizens have an equal opportunity to
engage in the process.

This paper will examine the Transitional Constitution of South Sudan
to evaluate whether it promotes “The Will of The People” by asking the
following questions;
 •Does the Transitional constitution provide space for interaction
amongst the various interest groups so that all of them feel
responsible and identify with the outcomes of governmental decisions?
 •Does the Transitional Constitution provide for mechanisms to resolve
violent conflicts within South Sudan?
 •How has the Transitional Constitution opened up channels of
communication between the government and the citizens?

The Transitional Constitution recognizes the supremacy of the “Will of
the People” by acknowledging that matters approved by a referendum
shall have authority above any legislation. This means that the object
of a referendum is a “law” that can be directly applied or a general
principle which would have to be “translated” into a legal provision.
However, the Transitional Constitution does not provide for the
ratification of the final document by a referendum.

South Sudan owes its independence and its internationally recognized
existence as a sovereign state to the people who voted in favor of
secession in the historic 2011 referendum. Without the “Will of the
People” there would be no independent South Sudan. This raises certain
questions;
 •Considering that Southern Sudanese created the state of South Sudan
through their referendum vote, is it necessary that they ratify its
new framework of governance in another referendum?
 •What will be the sovereign capacity of the Permanent Constitution of
South Sudan?

In the provisions on the road map to the Permanent Constitution, the
Transitional Constitution recognises the supremacy of the will of the
people. It provides for a Commission that will review the Transitional
Constitution by collecting views and suggestions from all the
stakeholders. The Commission will conduct a nation-wide public
information programme and civic education on constitutional issues and
draft a constitution that is to be presented to the President along
with a report on the decisions made one year after the creation of the
Commission.

This will be followed by a Constitutional Conference. The
Constitutional Conference is very considerate of the “Will of the
People” because it will include a variety of stakeholders including
political parties, civil society organizations, women organizations,
youth organizations, faith-based organizations, people with special
needs, traditional leaders, war widows, veterans and war wounded
business leaders, trade unions, professional associations, the
academia and other categories to be determined. However, it is unclear
what proportion of delegates will be from each category and how they
will be selected.

Even as we ask ourselves how the various sectors of civil society
listed above will organize themselves to participate in the conference
and how they will nominate their delegates, it is important to note
that the total number of the delegates and the proportion of delegates
from each stakeholder group are provided for. Who then will determine
all these?

The critical issue with regard to the last organ of the constitution
making process is that parliament may make radical changes to the
document that will have been agreed by the last two pro-people
processes, which is a contradiction of the “Will of the People”

It is important to analyze the provisions that guarantee the
recognition of the will of the people alongside the significant role
played by the president throughout the process of making the Permanent
Constitution. For example, the President appoints the members of the
Commission (the number of sitting members is his decision); he
presents the draft to the Constitutional Conference; he  appoints the
delegates to this Conference (he decides how many they are); he is
presented with the draft and the explanatory report by the
Constitutional Conference; he tables the draft from the Constitutional
Conference before the National Legislature; and he receives the draft
the National Legislature will have adopted for signing.



CONCLUSION

This paper discussed many aspects of democracy and good governance
that should be incorporated in the permanent constitution. It
presupposes that democracy, which a constitution should guarantee,
provides the strongest theoretical framework for good governance and
consequent social economic development;
 •It provides people with the right to participate. This means that
people have a right to decide what type of development they would like
to have in their country, and the best way of achieving it.
•It provides the citizens with the right to distribute and use social
power. This means that people as citizens decide who should hold
power, for how long and how they should use the power. This enables
people to create a positive political environment which is necessary
for development.
 •It ensures justice (or fairness) and rule of law. Real development
can hardly take place in an environment where these factors do not
exist.

The relationship between democracy and development has implication on
the state. Where the government dominates society, it does not leave
adequate room for the citizens to determine their development
priorities. The constitution is the only instrument that can guarantee
political openness.



RECOMMENDATIONS

Elections, which are the initial steps of democratisation, will be a
definite provision of the Permanent Constitution. The civil society
and political parties should therefore discuss and place submissions
on issues relating to elections. In so doing, it is important to think
along what most constitutions define, which include;
 •How positions in the constitutional and support structures are filled
 •The terms, period and termination of service of constitutional
office holder and other senior public officials
 •Specified turn-over cycle of constitutional positions
 •Methodology for removal prior to completion of term
 •Defined supportive legal instruments, e.g. an electoral act

It should also be discussed how the constitution can provide for the
conduct of elections under a system of separation of powers.

It is also important to discuss whether the bicameral house should be
retained or not and whether or not there should be one or separate
sittings. The constitution should certainly clarify the issues that
each house would discuss and as well as outline the respective powers
of the two houses.

How the government can be legally limited in its powers and how rules
imposing limits upon government power can be entrenched so that the
government has no room to change those limits as they please is also
an important issue of discussion.

It is also necessary to discuss how the constitution can ensure that
there is no overlap in the powers and functions among the different
arms of government.  This can be discussed alongside the need to
ensure that there is no overlap of personnel in the different arms of
government and that none of the arms of the government interferes with
the functions and work of the other in any way.

It is necessary to discuss whether or not there should be an
instrument that enables the collective responsibility of the Council
of Ministers to be checked by the Assembly or vetted by the judiciary.

This forum may also discuss whether or not it is necessary to ensure
that the functions of the independent commissions do not interfere
with the principle of separation of powers.

Other important areas of discussion are;
 •Issues on citizenship and nationality
 •The official working language ,
 •The role of the traditional authority
 •The actualization of women’s rights
 •How to fully implement the 25% affirmative action quarter for women
 •The issues of compensation and
 •how the local government should function
 •Mechanisms of controlling of conflict of interests, (e.g. nepotism
and ethnicity)
 •Issues on  financial management
 •Domesticating  international law and conventions



REFERENCES


 1.Laws of the Republic of South Sudan: The Transitional Constitution
of South Sudan 2011
 2.The Interim Constitution of South Sudan
 3.Andrew Heywood (2007) Politics, 3rd edition, Palgrave Foundations
 4.Swiss Examination of the Transitional Constitution
 5.Making Informed Decision, A Hand book for Civic Education (CRECO) 2007
 6.Draft Civic Education Trainers Guide On the Constitution and the
Constitution making process in South Sudan

-- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected].
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/groups/opt_out.


Reply via email to