Abyei: A test of good relations between the two Sudans


By Luka Biong Deng

August 18, 2012— The African Union Roadmap for normalizing relations
between the South and Sudan is now approaching its final phase. The
negotiation between the two countries will resume towards the end of
next week on the pending issues.

 By 2nd September, the UN Secretary General will present the report
about the status of negotiation on the pending issues to the UN
Security Council. By 22nd September, the African Union Panel will
present a comprehensive report on the status of negotiations,
including detailed proposals on all outstanding issues, to be endorsed
by African Union Peace and Security Council as final and binding
solution to the post-secession relations.

Within two weeks following the submission of the report by the Panel,
the AU Peace and Security Council will hold a meeting at ministerial
level to endorse the report of the Panel and to transmit its
communiqué, for consideration and endorsement, by the UN Security
Council acting under Chapter VII of the UN Charter. The two countries
are expected to reach amicable solutions for all the pending issues
before 22nd September. If the negotiations failed to reach amicable
solutions on all or some of the pending issues, then the Panel will
call for another summit between Salva and Bashir before 22nd September
to resolve all the pending issues or to pen a comprehensive agreement
on all pending issues if negotiations reached amicable solutions.

With oil and other payments deal being concluded, the Roadmap has
unlocked one of the most difficult hurdles between the two countries.
This deal will undoubtedly provide a solid basis for resolving the
other pending issues. The oil deal has sent positive economic and
political signals with great sense of optimism. The economies of two
countries received well the news of the oil deal, particularly the
economy of Sudan that was almost in the status of coma and blackout.
The Sudanese pound gained strength after the announcement of the oil
deal.

A journalist from Khartoum told me that the people of Sudan have now
come to realize the South that was projected as a liability is now
seen as detrimental to the economic survival of Sudan. The feeling in
the South is rather mixed about the oil deal. Many people did not see
rational for assisting the regime in Khartoum with $3 billion with no
return as well as pumping their oil again through the hostile
neighbor.

Despite such concerns, the South is desperate for oil revenue to meet
the high expectations of its people. With the oil shutdown in the
South, the development activities have been stalled, provision of
basic services has been constrained and hyperinflation is negatively
affecting the living conditions of every citizen. In fact the oil and
other payments deal is the cost of being a land-locked country with a
bad neighbour. The only return to the South from this deal is to
normalize relations with Sudan and to build confidence to resolve all
the pending issues including the final status of Abyei.

As the negotiation of the two countries will resume soon in Addis
Ababa, the people of the two countries and international community
attach high hopes of reaching amicable resolutions of all the pending
issues in the same spirit with which they concluded the oil deal.
Resolving the final status of Abyei area will be one of critical
issues to be discussed by the two countries. During the last round of
talks on Abyei, Sudan delegation argued bitterly that its experience
with the secession of the South brought only misery and any attempt to
temper again with any part of the territory of Sudan will not be
accepted and may cause further conflict. Their position on the final
status of Abyei is that it either remains in Sudan or to be
partitioned between the two countries as a win-win solution.
The delegation of Sudan argued in such a way as if the issue of Abyei
is anew and to be negotiated afresh with no reference to Abyei
Protocol, the ruling of the Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA) and
June 2011 Agreement on Abyei. It was clear that the delegation of
Sudan intended to sell the idea of partitioning Abyei as such option
was among the options initially entertained by the US and the Panel.
It is worth mentioning that the referendum for the people of Abyei is
one of the unfinished businesses of the CPA that was not only signed
by Sudan and the SPLM but also witnessed by international community
including African Union and United Nations. Also the ruling of PCA
that defined the area of Ngok Dinka transferred in 1905 from the South
to the North is an international binding award.

In fact the June 2011 Agreement on Temporary Arrangements for the
Administration and Security of Abyei Area confirms not only the
validity of Abyei Protocol after expiry of the CPA Interim Period but
it also reaffirms the borders of Abyei as per the ruling of PCA. Any
aberration from these commitments will not only trigger the root
causes of Abyei conflict that were addressed by the CPA but it will
also show absolute dishonouring of international obligations towards
peaceful resolution of Abyei conflict.

During my meeting in Addis with the US Special Envoy, Ambassador Lyman
was very clear about the position of US against any attempt to
partition Abyei and that such position was communicated to Sudan and
the Panel. Also the European Union Special Envoy also reaffirmed
during my meeting with her in Addis the commitment of the European
Union to the conduct of Abyei referendum and rejects any suggestion to
partition Abyei. The Deputy Prime Ministe of Ethiopia and Chair of
IGAD reiterates, during my meeting with him, the unequivocal
commitment of Ethiopia and IGAD to the conduct of Abyei referendum
within a territory of the Ngok Dinka as defined by the ruling of the
PCA. Also the UN Special Envoy stressed in my meeting with him in
Addis the unambiguous position of the UN to the conduct of Abyei
referendum and its adherence to the ruling of the PCA.

Generally, the international community seems to have a common position
of how to resolve the final status of Abyei. The conduct of referendum
for the people of Abyei in the area of Dinka Ngok as defined by PCA is
the basis upon which the final status of Abyei area would be resolved.
The issues that stalled the conduct of Abyei referendum on 9th January
2011 were lack of agreement on the definition of other residents who
will be eligible to vote and the chairmanship of the referendum
commission.

 If these two issues are resolved in the next round of talks, then the
Parties would have resolved one of the biggest problems hindering the
normalization of relations between the two countries. There is a
general agreement among the international observers that the criteria
for eligibility of other residents to vote in Abyei referendum should
be in such a way not to overshadow the views of the indigenous people
of the area, the Ngok Dinka.

In fact the ruling of PCA that reduced the area of Abyei from 18,559
km2 as per recommendation of Abyei Boundaries Commission to only
10,460 km2 was to ensure the majority of the Ngok Dinka who are the
targets of the referendum to exercise such right without being diluted
by others.

In fact and as it is well argued by the South that any attempt to
allow nomads to vote in Abyei referendum, then Dinka Malual, Dinka
Twic, Dinka Awan, Dinka Panarou, Dinka Alor, Bul Nuer and Misseyia
Ajaira Arabs who seasonally trespass Abyei area will all be eligible
to vote in Abyei referendum. This idea of allowing nomads to vote in
Abyei referendum will not only dilute the views of the target
indigenous communities of Dinka Ngok and other residents but it will
make the conduct of the referendum cumbersome. The valid argument
would be that if some members of these nomads become residents of
Abyei area then they will not only participate in the referendum as
residents but they will also be treated equally and enjoy the same
rights with the indigenous Ngok Dinka community.

The South has extending to the Sudan the hand of friendship and
cooperation not only through injecting a life to the economy of Sudan
by allowing its oil to flow through Sudan but also by availing more
than $3 billion as unconditional assistance to Khartoum. As President
Bashir committed himself in the last summit to take two steps for
every step taken by President Salva towards normalization of relations
between the two countries, President Salva has taken more than one
steps in the oil and other payments deal. President Bashir should show
his commitment in the next around and to walk the talks by accepting
the conduct of Abyei referendum for the Ngok Dinka and other residents
but not for nomads.

The recent agreement between the Ngok Dinka and Misseriyia Ajaira on
the core principles for peaceful co-existence sends a clear message to
the two countries and international community the commitment of the
Ngok Dinka, despite the devastation of their area by the regime in
Khartoum and some elements of Misseriyia, to ensure to all nomads the
right to pasture and water in their area as well as peaceful
co-existence with them. President Bashir must show to the South his
commitment to good relations by amicably resolving the final status of
Abyei area otherwise he may run the risk of his demise and that of his
regime.

Luka biong is a senior member of the South Sudan’s governing Sudan
People’s Liberation Movement (SPLM). He is currently the Co- Chair of
Abyei Joint Oversight Committee Representing South Sudan. This article
was first published by New Nation Newspaper.


The views expressed in the 'Comment and Analysis' section are solely
the opinions of the writers. The veracity of any claims made are the
responsibility of the author not Sudan Tribune.

If you want to submit an opinion piece or an analysis please email it
to [email protected]

Sudan Tribune reserves the right to edit articles before publication.
Please include your full name, relevant personal information and
political affiliations.

-- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected].
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/groups/opt_out.


Reply via email to