Sudan Tribune, Lies, deceptions and the downfall of journalistic
integrity in South Sudan

by Nancy Mer Adongjok, RSS

"The idea that media is there to educate us, or to inform us is
ridiculous", Abbie Hoffman

AUG. 20/2012, SSN; Throughout my career as a journalist and my
involvement with a wide range of international newspaper tabloids, I
have learnt that journalists are expected to do more than just
reporting events and positively analyzing current affairs for public
consumption.

Journalists do not have to create public outcry and sense of
one-sighted reporting that can cause backlash through diatribe
reporting nor plagiarize the views of others so that the same factual
errors are perpetuated. A breach of such journalism practices can
result in one's license being suspended or the media house fined or
both.

But in a place like South Sudan, there are no credible media laws to
hold journalists accountable or allow to report fairly without
deliberately publishing factual errors.

And that caused Sudan Tribune (the topic of this writing) to enjoy
immunity that allowed them to intentionally breach the code of ethics
without their motives questioned by either authorities of the
countries (North and South Sudans) they operate in.

Since its inception in 2003, this online media based in Paris (France)
had a fair share of blame for publishing tribal oriented ideas without
editing, to which no named source is attributed, fabricating matters
and being blatantly dishonest, being totally unbalanced and unfair
when they have been given the true facts from their subject, but fail
to publish these as an answer to the journalist's point of view.

Because their business is headquartered in France, they also enjoy
more pluses than minuses compared to other media sources currently
operating in the two Sudans: their offices have never been shutdown,
their editor-in-chief had never been interrogated or detained just
like others currently operating through iron fists. Though one of
their journalists was recently arrested, Sudan Tribune enjoy a far
better immunity than you would imagine.

For a news website that claims to promote plural news and views on
Sudan (two Sudans perhaps?), that unintentional exemption cannot be
used as a ground for ethics misconduct and deliberate deception or
poor journalistic showing which the Sudan's best online news site
(averaging 6 million viewers a year, according to Wikipedia) currently
promote.

You would expect a news source of Sudan Tribune caliber to rightfully
credit their source of information without yearning for plagiarism to
falsify or over-verifying their side of story without too much
"showing of copycatting", but this hasn't entirely been the case.

Over a year ago, the news website was caught red-handed by a prominent
South Sudanese news website called The New Sudan Vision (NSV) for
using their story without even mentioning NSV as the original source.
The NSV managed by Mading Ngor (currently working for Reuters)
demanded an apology from Sudan Tribune (ST) or indicate that the NSV
is the original source of that particular story. Sudan Tribune not
only neglected NSV's requests, they continued having the news story
appear on their site.

This is plagiarism at best and a practice of enjoying immunity without
concern for rectifying errors and reporting imbalance.

Another example of a deceptive reporting by ST was on the death of two
Ugandan UPDF soldiers in July at Kidepo National Game Park, in which
South Sudan poachers reportedly shot dead the two UPDF soldiers named
Pte. Ahimbisibwe and Mathias Odongo.

Sudan Tribune in their yesterday's (August 16) reporting on a similar
killing of two UPDF soldiers (a report also factually written by New
Vision in Uganda and The Upper Nile Times in South Sudan) went as far
as saying that the two officers killed in July "sparked tension
between Uganda and South Sudan nations" when even the military
leadership of each country didn't exchange views on the issue.

This is another failure to tell the readers/public what they urgently
need to read, and an example of twisting facts to continue threatening
peaceful existence.

Without appearing neutral in controversial and unsubstantiated
journalistic reporting, Sudan Tribune recently founded itself in the
middle of a tussle between a major United States newspaper called
McClatchy and the Minister of Information in the government of South
Sudan, Hon. Barnaba Marial Benjamin. McClatchy were outraged by
Marial's labeling of their journalist, Alan Boswell as a paid agent of
Khartoum. ST popularized the issue as if it was between them and
Marial.

Worst of all, instead of clearly feeding the readers on the issue,
they neglected most of Marial's version of the story and instead
continued to publish McClatchy's side of the same issue to make the
Minister appear arrogant and reckless. Such reporting did not only
show a sign of intentional blackmailing, it also made Sudan Tribune
appear as an agent for Khartoum's deceitful propaganda.

I can continue at length giving factual evidences on the lack of
quality of reporting by ST and its "continuous mixing of lies,
politics and journalism to try to be conspicuously accurate in
everything", to operate in South Sudan remotely and under no laws to
quest their business conduct.

At the end, it's one question that really matters: does Sudan Tribune
employ its journalists as pariahs to international journalism's ethics
and standards? The question is answerable to the news website itself.

*  Sudan Tribune, Lies, deceptions and the downfall of journalistic
integrity in South Sudan first appeared as a national editorial of
The Upper Nile Times.

COMMENTS, PLEASE CLICK HERE

Disclaimer: The views expressed above are solely those of the
author(s) and do not represent those of the website.

-- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected].
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/groups/opt_out.


Reply via email to