UNAMID Evacuates Wounded SAF Soldiers in Darfur: Larger Implications

Eric Reeves, November 18, 2012

On November 13, 2012 the UN/African Union Mission in Darfur (UNAMID)
made the decision to provide "medevac" (medical evacuation) to
approximately twelve Sudan Armed Forces (SAF) soldiers following heavy
fighting with rebel forces in North Darfur. One report puts the number
of evacuated wounded soldiers at two dozen.  The injured were taken to
the city of el-Fasher, location of the primary SAF military base in
Darfur.  Such military clashes between the SAF and rebel forces have
been escalating for many months, as has violence against civilians,
especially by Khartoum's proxy forces in Darfur; all this occurs even
as UNAMID has resolutely insisted that fighting and violence have
diminished, thus justifying a draw-down in forces.  But the grim truth
is that UNAMID can't sustain an adequate security presence for the
vast majority of locations in Darfur facing threats of violence by
Khartoum-allied militia forces.  We might well wonder, then, why
UNAMID would choose to deploy its conspicuously inadequate resources
to evacuating Khartoum's combatants, especially since such medevac
forms no part of UNAMID's mandate—indeed, "evacuating combatants" is
neither mentioned nor suggested anywhere in the UN delineation of that
mandate (running to over 1,300 words, included below as Appendix A).
Nor is the task of evacuation, by aircraft or ground vehicles,
anywhere mentioned in the very lengthy and highly detailed Status of
Forces Agreement (SOFA), signed by Khartoum and the UN/AU force in
February 2008.

To be sure, UNAMID spokesman Chris Cycmanick is narrowly accurate in
declaring that this medevac is justified by International Humanitarian
Law (the medevac was "completely in line with International
Humanitarian Law"), and several of the Geneva Conventions are explicit
on the question of the legality of such medical evacuation.  But
Cycmanick seriously misrepresents the situation by declaring that
medical evacuation of SAF soldiers is in any way part of the "core
requirement of international humanitarian law, which falls under the
Mission’s mandate" (UNAMID press release, November 13, 2012).
International Humanitarian Law certainly governs the UNAMID mandate
and the actions of UNAMID; but again, there is not one word about
medical evacuation of combatants.  On the contrary, the meaningful
language of the mandate is given overly entirely to specifying the
obligations of the peacekeeping force to protect civilians and
humanitarians—this is the "core" task, and to suggest otherwise is
simply disingenuous.  The mandate does also speak vaguely about
UNAMID's assisting in the implementation of the Darfur Peace Agreement
(May 2006); but the DPA had long been irrelevant when the language of
the mandate was drafted, and it was simply convenient for a UN
peacekeeping force to have at least a nominal "peace agreement" to be
presiding over (the absurdly negotiated and widely rejected "Doha
Document for Peace in Darfur" now serves as an equivalent
placeholder).

Moreover, the real question here is not a legal one—it concerns the
implications of UNAMID's consequential decision to use scarce
transport resources for a military medevac on behalf of a regime that
has an abysmal record of itself defying International Humanitarian Law
and International Human Rights Law in any number of situations.  Here
it should first be pointed out that UNAMID has in the past been highly
selective in its use of transport resources for medevac purposes.
Cycmanick claims that UNAMID has in the past provided such services to
rebel wounded and civilians; however, this is a highly questionable
assertion, one borne out by pitifully little in the way of reporting
from the region, including from UNAMID itself.  It is hardly
surprising that one of the main rebel groups vehemently protested the
medevac, since they are quite aware that their own wounded would never
be accorded such assistance.  Nor would such wounded rebel combatants
enjoy the protection of IHL, even in hospitals supposedly enjoying
UNAMID protection.

This only highlights the perversity of invoking International
Humanitarian Law (IHL) as a defense for the recent action by UNAMID.
For such defense opens UNAMID itself to any number of awkward
questions:

• Why have the UN and African Union leadership done so painfully
little to condemn confirmed instances of Khartoum's violations of IHL
as well as International Human Rights Law (IHRL)?  These include
painting military aircraft "UN white," aircraft departing directly
from the air base at el-Fasher, location of UNAMID headquarters.  The
previous UN Panel of Experts on Darfur—before Ban Ki-moon's
Secretariat expediently sabotaged the mission—repeatedly confirmed
this gross violation of IHL.  Now neither the completely inept current
Panel nor UNAMID reports anything of this ongoing crime, one that
endangers all humanitarian aircraft and, because unrebuked, has spread
to the North/South border regions.

• Why has the UN and African Union leadership done so little to
overcome Khartoum's relentless obstruction of shipments of food and
medicine from Port Sudan to Darfur, another egregious violation of
IHL?  Why do humanitarian organizations continue to face denial of
visas and travel permits for their workers?  Why do these workers
continue to face intimidation, harassment, severe limitations in
movement, and explicit threats of violence or actual violence?  These
are all serious violations of IHL that continue unabated, and the
current Yellow Fever epidemic in West Darfur is again demonstrating
the deadly consequences of humanitarian obstruction and denial of
access.  This frequently fatal disease is likely to spread quickly in
areas to which Khartoum continues to deny access, especially parts of
Jebel Marra adjacent to the main outbreak.

• Why have UN and AU condemnations of aerial bombardment of civilians
been so very occasional and so completely ineffectual?  Why has
Khartoum paid no price for aerial attacks on civilian targets that
continue to be a standard part of its military campaign in Darfur?
The most recent bombing attack, yet again on eastern Jebel Marra,
killed two (Radio Dabanga, November 15, 2012), but there have been
many hundreds since UNAMID took up its mandate on January 1, 2008 (see
www.sudanbombing.org).  Why has there been no pressure to halt a
practice that has been continuous on the part of the present regime
for well over a decade?

• Why have the UN and AU not been more forceful in their condemnation
of the humanitarian blockade of the populous Jebel Marra region, which
has had no remotely adequate relief access for three years?  Again,
this is an extraordinary violation of IHL.

• Why does complete impunity continue to obtain for even the most
brutal violators of both IHL and IHRL in Darfur?  Why is the
continuing epidemic of rape in Darfur never mentioned by UNAMID?  or
even by the UN Secretary General?  This silent acquiescence gives
every sign of being a decision made to appease Khartoum.

• Why do so many camps for displaced persons report chronic violence,
threatening civilians in a variety of ways?   Present levels of
insecurity in the camps represent a fundamental failing on the part of
UNAMID in taking responsibility for its mandate.  Radio Dabanga
reported on November 16, 2012 an all too typical account:

"Displaced persons from Saraf Omra camps in North Darfur have
complained about the high level of insecurity in the area due to the
continuous attacks executed by pro-government militias, they told
Radio Dabanga on Friday, 16 November.   Residents from the Naseem,
Dankoj and Jebel camps affirmed that pro-government militias carry out
armed robberies and fire random shots targeting the camps.  A camps
activist told Radio Dabanga that security is lacking in the area,
stressing that the lives and properties of local residents are
constantly under threat."

•  Why have there been no comparably urgent efforts to evacuate
wounded civilians during countless violent assaults in which a UNAMID
base was nearby—assaults often entailing violations of both IHL and
IHRL?  The massacre of civilians in Tabarat was perhaps the most
egregious failure.  The attack on Tabarat, very near Tawila in North
Darfur, occurred on September 2, 2010 and was conducted by an Arab
militia force allied with Khartoum and the SAF.  More than 50 African
men and boys were executed, many by gunshot at point-blank range.
Scores of others were wounded, and desperate survivors made their way
to nearby Tabarat to plead for assistance.  The assistance never came.
 Six days after the attack, on September 8, 2010, UNAMID issued a
terse statement confirming that Khartoum's forces were blocking all
access to Tabarat, including assisting the many wounded and dying: "On
7 September, a UNAMID [mission] on its way from El Fasher to Tarabat
[sic] was stopped by an SAF convoy and were informed by the commanding
officer not to return before two days due to ongoing SAF operations in
the area" (UNAMID press release [el-Fasher], September 8, 2010).

Again, many scores of African villagers had been slaughtered or
wounded in this notorious event; help for these civilians was
desperately needed.  And yet there was no evacuation, only silence and
a shameful failure even to report on events at Tabarat.  This stands
in stark contrast with the extraordinarily detailed account by Reuters
in the immediate aftermath of the Tabarat massacre (see Appendix B
below); the dispatch contains a number of interviews with survivors
who recounted the horror of what they had seen and the desperation
with which they pleaded with UNAMID personnel for medical help and
evacuation of the wounded (UNAMID has a significant base in nearby
Tawila).  This is the most telling context in which to understand
UNAMID's decision to medevac SAF troops, and the ensuring
justification for such a mission simply because it did not conflict
with IHL.  What do Mr. Cycmanick and the UNAMID political leadership
think about the relationship of IHL to the various events at Tabarat?

But there are many other such examples.  Much more recently UNAMID has
been blocked from investigating reports of atrocities committed
against civilians in the Hashaba area of North Darfur (October 2012).
The same was true in early August, when Arab militia forces overran
the major town of Kutum, looting and destroying humanitarian supplies
and resources, as well as newly displacing the entire population of
nearby Kassab camp for IDPs (
http://www.sudanreeves.org/2012/08/13/3376/).

In Hashaba, Radio Dabanga reports eyewitness accounts suggesting that
several hundred civilians were killed or injured in the period from
September 26 through October 2. The attacking forces were repeatedly
described by these eyewitnesses as Arab militia forces backed by SAF
aerial military assets.  The reports continued to describe the
attackers on the ground as belonging to "pro-government militias."
Here again, thousands of civilians were newly displaced.

Even more disturbing and significant, however, is a subsequent attack
on the follow-up investigation, an unusually robust UNAMID patrol
comprising 16 vehicles in all.  On October 17, 2012 a very heavily
armed militia group—which had carefully anticipated the route of the
UNAMID convoy traveling to Hashaba—fired from elevated ground down
upon the highly vulnerable UNAMID forces.  UNAMID returned fire, but
faced very intimidating weaponry and overwhelming tactical
disadvantage; with the killing of one UNAMID soldier and the wounding
of three others (one critically), the force retreated back to Kutum.
The South African soldier killed was the 43rd to die in a mission that
has been consistently poorly led and betrayed by the political
unwillingness of UNAMID leaders to confront Khartoum over its actions,
and those of its proxies.

The character of the weapons used in the attack on UNAMID forces was
reported in uncharacteristic detail (Agence France-Presse [Khartoum],
October 22, 2012):

"'[The attackers] used arsenals of high-calibre weapons that were
never used before,' UNAMID spokeswoman Aicha Elbasri said in a written
reply to AFP questions. ‘This includes mortars, medium machine-guns,
rocket-propelled grenades, AK-47 rifles, and anti-tank guns.'"

Edmond Mulet, deputy head of UN peacekeeping operations, would later
declare in an October 24 briefing of the UN Security Council that the
attacking force used "heavy machine guns," a fearsomely destructive
weapon when fired with the advantage of significantly higher ground
position.

This was no ordinary militia assault: it is clear that the UNAMID
convoy was attacked, on the basis of advance intelligence, so as to
prevent the investigation of atrocity crimes and egregious violations
of IHRL reported from Hashaba.

UNAMID's invoking of IHL on the occasion of its medevac operation for
SAF soldiers could hardly be more specious with this as context.  As
UNAMID knows full well, Khartoum has blocked humanitarian and medical
access to civilians in desperate, even emergency need on countless
occasions; often these are civilians who have been wounded or raped
during actions by Khartoum's forces and militias, further conspicuous
violations of IHRL.  At such moments, so relentlessly persistent over
the five years of UNAMID presence in Darfur, we hear nothing or
virtually nothing from UNAMID's Cycmanick about either IHL or IHRL.

IHL and Khartoum's military operations elsewhere in greater Sudan

If we look further afield, there are a great many more questions that
provide context for UNAMID's deplorable decision to medevac SAF
soldiers, using scarce aerial resources that have not been deployed on
those occasions when civilians were clearly at risk or had been
reliably reported as wounded:

• Is UNAMID not aware that on August 2, 2011 the SAF refused to allow
for the urgent medevac of three mortally wounded UN peacekeepers in
Abyei (the UN Interim Security Force for Abyei, UNISFA)?  Despite
repeated attempts to secure permission from the SAF in Kadugli (South
Kordofan) for helicopter evacuation, the UN was rebuffed on each
occasion until it had become too late. One of the mortally wounded
soldiers would have likely survived if he had reached Kadugli in
timely fashion. Alain Le Roy, then head of UN peacekeeping, declared
bluntly that, "We didn't get the clearance for the Medevac helicopter
to take off immediately. They [Khartoum's SAF] prevented us to take
off by threatening to shoot at the helicopter."

• Is UNAMID unaware that in June 2011 UN human rights observers in
Kadugli observed the SAF and its proxies kill a great number of
civilians because of their Nuba ethnicity?  Is UNAMID leadership
unaware that some 7,000 civilians were removed from UN protective
custody in Kadugli by Khartoum's Military Intelligence and have never
subsequently been accounted for?  Is UNAMID unaware of assaults by SAF
forces on UN employees in Kadugli, detailed in a leaked UN human
rights report?

"The attacks on [UN Mission in Sudan, Kadugli], its staff and assets
are so egregious that condemnation is insufficient. The conduct of the
SAF, the PDF, the Central Reserve Police Force, and the Government
Police, singularly and collectively, has frustrated and weakened the
capacity of the UNMIS to implement in Southern Kordofan a mandate
given to it by the UN Security Council. The conduct has also resulted
in loss of life and injury of UN staff." (§74)

The UN report specifically invokes both IHL and IHRL in expressing its
outrage at the acts committed by Khartoum's SAF and its proxies; the
report also demands a UN investigation and strongly suggests that
there be a referral to the International Criminal Court:

"The international community must hold the Government of Sudan
accountable for this conduct and insist that those responsible be
arrested and brought to justice. [This] report further recommends that
an independent and comprehensive investigation be conducted, into
violations of human rights and international humanitarian laws in
Southern Kordofan with the view to bringing those who bear the
greatest responsibility to justice, including referral as appropriate
to the Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court (ICC)."
(Executive Summary)

There has of course been no such investigation—merely lip-service
support for such an investigation from the likes of present U.S.
special envoy Princeton Lyman and UN High Commissioner for Human
Rights Navi Pillay.

• Is UNAMID unaware that, in outrageous violation of IHL, Khartoum
continues to deny humanitarian access to the Nuba Mountains (South
Kordofan) and Blue Nile more than 17 months after hostilities were
initiated by the regime?  A million people face slow starvation and
pressure to flee their homes and lands because of this deliberately
destructive violation of IHL.

• Is UNAMID unaware that there are numerous, redundantly corroborated
reports of the systematic destruction of food supplies in the Nuba?
Many of these extraordinary violations of IHL and IHRL have been
conducted by the infamous "Match Brigade," such as the complete
destruction of Um Bartumbu village in March 2012 (www.NubaReports.org
has posted a "screen grab" from this action, reportedly found on the
body of a Popular Defense Forces militia member in the Jebel Toma area
later the same month).  I have received reports from the Nuba of an
increased use of incendiary bombs by Khartoum in an effort to inflict
greater damage on the harvest still underway; the seasonal rains no
longer prevent wildfires among what little there is in the way of
mature crops, especially sorghum.

•  Is UNAMID unaware that Khartoum deliberately bombed refugee camps
in both Upper Nile and Unity states in South Sudan on November 8 and
10, 2011?  This entailed multiple egregious violations of IHL, IHRL,
and other key tenets of international law.

• Is UNAMID unaware that Khartoum has again been repeatedly and highly
credibly accused of using military aircraft painted "UN white," both
for reconnaissance purposes along the North/South border and in
delivering supplies to renegade militia leader David Yau Yau, the man
presently most responsible for terrible civilian destruction in
Jonglei State and a widespread inflaming of ethnic tensions—a campaign
he may soon bring to Upper Nile State?

• Is UNAMID unaware of how many times Khartoum denied humanitarian
access to South Sudan during the civil war, leaving millions of people
at greatly increased risk?  How many times Khartoum's military
aircraft deliberately attacked hospitals, feeding facilities, even
humanitarian relief sites clearly marked as belong to the
International Committee of the Red Cross?

The question of UNAMID awareness or ignorance of the larger context
for their decision to medevac SAF soldiers is essential here; but
UNAMID spokesman Cycmanick seems oblivious and the interim head of
UNAMID, Aichatou Mindaoudou, seems content to issue anodyne statements
about Darfur on the occasion of her first, highly controlled visit to
the region.  She has said nothing publicly about the UNAMID decision
to medevac SAF troops, or indeed anything of consequence about
UNAMID's mandate: "continued fighting is a dead end that only harms
the people of Darfur."  Concerning IHL and IHRL she indulges a
familiar "moral equivalence" that betrays the people of Darfur and
contributes to what virtually all Darfuris see as a continuing climate
of impunity, deliberately maintained by Khartoum:

"'Ms. Mindaoudou urges all sides to cease hostilities immediately,
respect international human rights and humanitarian law, and engage
fully in the peaceful settlement of Darfur conflict,' UNAMID added in
a news release." (UN News Centre, November 12, 2012)

In connection with the very recent murder and displacement of many
civilians in the Sigili area of North Darfur, Ms. Mindaoudou places no
blame but only generally deplores "all forms of violence in Darfur":

"'I am dismayed by these deaths, and very concerned over the repeated
incidents that have led to the killing, injury of the local
population, as well as their displacement," said UNAMID's Acting Joint
Special Representative and Joint Chief Mediator Aichatou Mindaoudou.
'I reiterate my strong condemnation of all forms of violence in
Darfur, especially the attacks against civilians, which constitute
serious crimes,' she added in a news release.' [ ] 'I urge all the
parties to avoid violence and choose the path of peace and negotiated
settlement,' Ms. Mindaoudou stated." (UN News Centre, November 3,
2012)

Khartoum certainly feels that it has prevailed if it confronts only
such incontrovertible assessments, and "urgings" that have no
political support; moreover, Mindaoudou fails to assign responsibility
for the violence, despite a great deal of evidence about who carried
it out.  Much more usefully, Radio Dabanga reports—on the basis of
eyewitness accounts—that Khartoum-allied militia forces were
responsible for the violence at Sigili (southeast of el-Fasher):

"About 1,000 people, or 140 families, from Sigili in Shawa area, North
Darfur, have reportedly fled their village following the militia
attack that left 13 people dead last Friday, 2 November, locals told
Radio Dabanga.  According to sources, virtually all inhabitants left
the Shawa area and are moving to El-Fasher and to Zam Zam camp, they
explained to Radio Dabanga on Thursday, 8 November. In addition,
reports concerning a new imminent attack in Sigili by a militia based
in Kalimandou, have also influenced the large displacement of
residents, according to witnesses. [ ] Witnesses and activists
appealed to UNAMID and to the international community to protect the
civilians stranded with their livestock and who are threatened to be
attacked once more by government militias." (November 10, 2012)

Claims that the medevac of SAF soldiers is a "core responsibility" of
UNAMID because of IHL obligations ring hollow when such reports of
civilian endangerment and casualties are essentially ignored.

Why would UNAMID decide to conduct the medevac?

UNAMID's poorly timed and even more poorly justified decision to
medevac Khartoum's combatants raises serious questions about
consequences as well as about motives.  Certainly the action will
further alienate both Darfuri civil society—already contemptuous of
UNAMID—and the Darfur rebel groups, which have long felt, with good
reason and considerable evidence, that UNAMID was not impartial and
had taken sides with the regime in Khartoum.  Increased Darfuri
hostility towards its mission and personnel is the last thing UNAMID
needs as it scales back the size of the force, claiming as
justification improved security on the ground.  But the real issue is
why UNAMID would decide as it did.  In fact, it is highly
likely—although UNAMID will never admit as much—that SAF commanding
officers demanded that their soldiers be medevac'd, threatening UNAMID
with grave consequences if it did not comply.

Such threats of reprisal cannot be taken lightly.  Here we should also
recall the history of SAF hostility to and obstruction of UNAMID, as
well as many explicit threats of violence against this UN-authorized
force.  A report by the Secretary General from November 16, 2010
notes:

"In the context of this ongoing violence, freedom of movement
continues to be a serious concern for UNAMID and many of the agencies
in Darfur. Since January 2009, there have been at least 42 incidents
in which a UNAMID patrol was denied passage by a Government official,
including incidents in which Government officials specifically
threatened the safety of UNAMID staff and equipment." (page 3)

One example cited in the report is particularly telling:

"On 29 September 2009, an SAF representative in Shaeria locality
informed UNAMID that the failure to provide authorities with prior
notification of a patrol would result in the patrol being attacked."
(page 4)

In its report of January 28, 2011 on Darfur, Human Rights Watch noted
that, "The Government of] Sudan has continued to restrict UN and
humanitarian agencies from accessing conflict-affected areas,
including Tabit, the site of the January 25 [2011] clash."  This
restriction occurred during what represents perhaps the most egregious
violation of IHL in Khartoum's response to UNAMID's efforts to fulfill
its true mandate:

"UNAMID spokesman Kemal Saiki confirmed the bombing was by 'the
Sudanese Armed Forces (SAF) air force.' Later on Wednesday [January
26, 2011], a group of 200 Sudanese government soldiers in 40 vehicles
arrived at UNAMID's camp in the nearby settlement of Shangil Tobay,
UNAMID said. '(The soldiers) surrounded the team site's exit as well
as the adjacent makeshift camp, where thousands of civilians recently
displaced by the December 2010 clashes have settled,' read the
statement. The Sudanese army detained four displaced people at the
camp, said UNAMID. 'The SAF commander at the scene ... then threatened
to burn down the makeshift camp and UNAMID team site, if the
peacekeepers continued to interfere.'"  (Reuters [Khartoum], January
27, 2011)

Reuters had reported two days earlier (January 25, 2011) the UN had
confirmed "Sudanese soldiers fired warning shots when they saw a
UNAMID patrol on Saturday [January 22, 2011] near the north Darfur
settlement of Dar el-Salam and stopped it from entering the area, a UN
source said."

Dismayingly, access issues were made into a political football by the
Obama administration's special envoy for Sudan, Scott Gration, who
declared shortly before he ended his disastrous tenure: "'The
Government of Sudan has taken great steps to lift restrictions on
UNAMID,' he said. 'We’ve seen great improvement of access for UNAMID
and for the international NGOs'" (Reuters, February 11, 2011).
Gration—who predicted peace would come to Darfur by the end of 2009
and that the 2010 national Sudanese elections would be "as free and
fair as possible"—bears major responsibility for the collective
decision to acquiesce before Khartoum's intransigence and its ruthless
evisceration of UNAMID capacity.

UNAMID's real mandate

The language of the UNAMID mandate is included in its entirety below,
but the mission's key terms of reference begin with these four
charges:

[1]  "protect its personnel, facilities, installations and equipment,
and to ensure the security and freedom of movement of its own
personnel and humanitarian workers;

[2]  "support early and effective implementation of the Darfur Peace
Agreement, prevent the disruption of its implementation and armed
attacks, and protect civilians, without prejudice to the
responsibility of the Government of Sudan.

[NB: the mandate was emended per UN Security Council Resolution 2003
to refer instead to the "Doha Document for Peace in Darfur," an
agreement as untenable as the DPA and almost universally rejected by
Darfuri civil society, political leadership, and the rebel groups—ER]

[3]  "To contribute to the restoration of necessary security
conditions for the safe provision of humanitarian assistance and to
facilitate full humanitarian access throughout Darfur;

[4]  "To contribute to the protection of civilian populations under
imminent threat of physical violence and prevent attacks against
civilians, within its capability and areas of deployment, without
prejudice to the responsibility of the Government of the Sudan."

UNAMID's failure in all these tasks has been abject.  It has been no
more successful in taking on other parts of the stipulated mandate:

[5] "To monitor, observe compliance with and verify the implementation
of various ceasefire agreements signed since 2004, as well as assist
with the implementation of the Darfur Peace Agreement and any
subsequent agreements."

Monitoring has consistently been limited by a lack of resources, a
lack of leadership and commitment, and because Khartoum has engineered
a climate so threatening that UNAMID is now largely paralyzed.  Its
weak efforts to monitor "compliance" with the "various ceasefire
agreements signed since 2004" have had no chance for success, given
the regime's relentless denial of access to places where the
"ceasefires" have been violated.

UNAMID is to "assist in the promotion of the rule of law in Darfur,
including through support for strengthening an independent judiciary
and the prison system."  Again, there has been no progress whatsoever
during the five years of UNAMID's deployment.  Incarceration, however
arbitrary, is the prerogative of Khartoum's Military Intelligence, as
it has been since conflict began.

UNAMID is also to "contribute to a secure environment for economic
reconstruction and development, as well as the sustainable return of
internally displaced persons and refugees to their homes."  But a
great many more civilians have been newly displaced since UNAMID took
up its mandate (well over 1 million people) than have fully returned
to their homes (fewer than 100,000, even if one accepts the UN's
dubious reckoning of this figure).

"Means" for implementing the mandate

It becomes painfully clear in reading the language of the mandate that
it is almost circular: goals and means are articulated in the very
same terms.  Even so, the emphasis continues to fall decisively on
civilian protection:

The mandate demands that UNAMID "contribute to the promotion of
respect for and protection of human rights and fundamental freedoms in
Darfur."  This demand stands as an appallingly grim joke in Darfur.

Other "means" for UNAMID to fulfill its mandate:

 "To promote the re-establishment of confidence, deter violence and
assist in monitoring and verifying the implementation of the
redeployment and disengagement provisions of the Darfur Peace
Agreement, including by actively providing security and robust
patrolling of redeployment and buffer zones, by monitoring the
withdrawal of long-range weapons, and by deploying hybrid police,
including formed police units, in areas where internally displaced
persons are concentrated, in the demilitarized and buffer zones [there
are no such "zones" in Darfur—ER], along key routes of migration and
in other vital areas, including as provided for in the Darfur Peace
Agreement."

No "long-range weapons" have been withdrawn from Darfur; on the
contrary, weapons and ammunition of primarily Chinese manufacture
continue to pour into Darfur, as the UN Panel of Experts on
Darfur—charged with monitoring the UN-imposed arms embargo—made
painfully clear during the first five years of its existence.  As
noted above, the Panel has since degenerated into a meaningless and
utterly uninspired fig-leaf put in place for political reasons by the
UN Secretariat.  "Robust patrolling" has never been a significant part
of UNMID's activities, and such patrols are now increasingly rare.
Formed Police Units (FPU) are present in only a few camps, and these
are some of the first elements of UNAMID to be deployed out.

UNAMID also has as part of its mandate "To monitor, verify and promote
efforts to disarm the Janjaweed and other militias."  The UN Security
Council first "demanded" that Khartoum "disarm" the Janjaweed and
bring its leaders to justice in July 2004 (Resolution 1556).  There
has been absolutely no progress on this front over more than eight
years.  Some former Janjaweed have been recycled into other
paramilitary guises (e.g., the Border Intelligence Police and Abu
Tira, or Central Reserve Police).  In turn, the Abu Tira in particular
are implicated in a tremendous amount of the continuing violence
against civilians.

UNAMID is also to:

"…contribute to the creation of the necessary security conditions for
the provision of humanitarian assistance and to facilitate the
voluntary and sustainable return of refugees and internally displaced
persons to their homes;

"…to ensure the security and freedom of movement of United
Nations-African Union personnel, humanitarian workers and Assessment
and Evaluation Commission personnel, to prevent disruption of the
implementation of the Darfur Peace Agreement by armed groups and,
without prejudice to the responsibility of the Government of the
Sudan, to protect civilians under imminent threat of physical violence
and prevent attacks and threats against civilians;

"…to assist in harnessing the capacity of women to participate in the
peace process, including through political representation, economic
empowerment and protection from gender-based violence."

As noted above, UNAMID no longer even reports on the avalanche of
sexual violence—and fear of such violence—that continues to sweep
across Darfur and dominate the lives of many hundreds of thousands of
Darfuri women and girls, overwhelmingly from the non-Arab or African
tribal groups.

And critically, UNAMID has been charged "…to monitor through proactive
patrolling the parties' policing activities in camps for internally
displaced persons, demilitarized and buffer zones and areas of
control." In this last task, UNAMID has disgracefully, abjectly
failed. As the report from the Saraf Omra camps in North Darfur (see
above) makes clear, along with countless similar reports, violence is
pervasive and uncontrolled in the camp areas, where living conditions
continue to deteriorate.

UNAMID is at once the most expensive UN peacekeeping operation in the
world and the least effective.  Given the urgent needs for
peacekeeping resources elsewhere, the UN Department of Peacekeeping
Operations has decided that it will draw down the force substantially.
 Although Hervé Ladsous, head of UN peacekeeping, has declared that
the force reduction has been dictated by changed "realities on the
ground" (i.e., improved security), this claim is nothing more than a
cynical bit of face-saving mendacity.  The tremendously challenging
operation in Darfur was the first undertaken by the then relatively
newly formed African Union Peace and Security Council.  The initial
failure of the African Union Mission in Sudan (AMIS), though widely
acknowledged, seemed not to faze the AUPSC leadership; instead,
earlier failure led in the end not to an effective UN protective force
(per the terms of UN Security Council Resolution 1706, August 2006),
but a force acceptable to Khartoum—a "hybrid" UN and African Union
force that was to be "predominantly African" in makeup.  No matter
that this ensured the force would comprise a great many poorly trained
and ill-equipped personnel from many different countries that had not
previously worked together; no matter, in short, that such
capitulation before Khartoum's demands ensured the disaster to which
we have been witness.  The regime's obduracy has prevailed, and
neither the African Union nor the UN will challenge the regime. The
have much company.

This unwillingness to challenge the regime has steadily emboldened the
ruthless men in Khartoum, and their military representatives in
Darfur.  When the SAF demanded that UNAMID medevac its wounded
soldiers—as it almost certainly did—there was again no resistance.
Instead, we heard only the deplorably disingenuous invoking of
"International Humanitarian Law" by spokesman Cycmanick.

UNAMID is on the verge of collapse; certainly its ability and capacity
to take on the primary responsibilities specified in its mandate have
all but vanished.  As a consequence, we may expect what is already
massive violence against civilians to continue to increase in the
coming months.

[ Eric Reeves is author of Compromising with Evil: An archival history
of greater Sudan, 2007 – 2012, at www.CompromisingWithEvil.org ]

Appendix A: Full text of UNAMID mandate:

UNAMID Mandate

Acting under Chapter VII of the Charter of the United Nations, the
Security Council, by its resolution 1769 of 31 July 2007 decided that
UNAMID is authorized to take the necessary action, in the areas of
deployment of its forces and as it deems within its capabilities in
order to:

   •protect its personnel, facilities, installations and equipment,
and to ensure the security and freedom of movement of its own
personnel and humanitarian workers;

   •support early and effective implementation of the Darfur Peace
Agreement, prevent the disruption of its implementation and armed
attacks, and protect civilians, without prejudice to the
responsibility of the Government of Sudan.

   •The Council also decided that the mandate of UNAMID shall be as
set out in paragraphs 54 and 55 of the report of the Secretary-General
and the Chairperson of the African Union Commission [S/2007/307/Rev.1
of 5 June 2007, namely as follows:

   •To contribute to the restoration of necessary security conditions
for the safe provision of humanitarian assistance and to facilitate
full humanitarian access throughout Darfur;

   •To contribute to the protection of civilian populations under
imminent threat of physical violence and prevent attacks against
civilians, within its capability and areas of deployment, without
prejudice to the responsibility of the Government of the Sudan;


   •To monitor, observe compliance with and verify the implementation
of various ceasefire agreements signed since 2004, as well as assist
with the implementation of the Darfur Peace Agreement and any
subsequent agreements;


   •To assist the political process in order to ensure that it is
inclusive, and to support the African Union-United Nations joint
mediation in its efforts to broaden and deepen commitment to the peace
process;


   •To contribute to a secure environment for economic reconstruction
and development, as well as the sustainable return of internally
displaced persons and refugees to their homes;


   •To contribute to the promotion of respect for and protection of
human rights and fundamental freedoms in Darfur;


   •To assist in the promotion of the rule of law in Darfur, including
through support for strengthening an independent judiciary and the
prison system, and assistance in the development and consolidation of
the legal framework, in consultation with relevant Sudanese
authorities;


   •To monitor and report on the security situation at the Sudan’s
borders with Chad and the Central African Republic.


In order to achieve these broad goals, the operation’s tasks would
include the following:

Support for the peace process and good offices:

   •To support the good offices of the African Union/United Nations
Joint Special Representative for Darfur and the mediation efforts of
the Special Envoys of the African Union and the United Nations;


   •To support and monitor the implementation of the Darfur Peace
Agreement and subsequent agreements;


   •To participate in and support the major bodies established by the
Darfur Peace Agreement and any subsequent agreements in the
implementation of their mandate, including through the provision of
technical assistance and logistical support to those bodies;


   •To facilitate the preparation and conduct of the Darfur-Darfur
Dialogue and Consultation, as stipulated in the Darfur Peace
Agreement;


   •To assist in the preparations for the conduct of the referendums
provided for in the Darfur Peace Agreement;


   •To ensure the complementary implementation of all peace agreements
in the Sudan, particularly with regard to the national provisions of
those agreements, and compliance with the Interim National
Constitution;


   •To liaise with UNMIS, the African Union Liaison Office for the
implementation of the Comprehensive Peace Agreement and other
stakeholders to ensure complementary implementation of the mandates of
UNMIS, the African Union Liaison Office for the implementation of the
Comprehensive Peace Agreement and the hybrid operation in Darfur;


[ UNMIS no longer exists, and UNAMID does not liaise with UNMISS, the
successor force—ER ]


Security:

  •To promote the re-establishment of confidence, deter violence and
assist in monitoring and verifying the implementation of the
redeployment and disengagement provisions of the Darfur Peace
Agreement, including by actively providing security and robust
patrolling of redeployment and buffer zones, by monitoring the
withdrawal of long-range weapons, and by deploying hybrid police,
including formed police units, in areas where internally displaced
persons are concentrated, in the demilitarized and buffer zones, along
key routes of migration and in other vital areas, including as
provided for in the Darfur Peace Agreement;


   •To monitor, investigate, report and assist the parties in
resolving violations of the Darfur Peace Agreement and subsequent
complementary agreements through the Ceasefire Commission and the
Joint Commission;


   •To monitor, verify and promote efforts to disarm the Janjaweed and
other militias;


   •To coordinate non-combat logistical support for the movements;


   •To assist in the establishment of the disarmament, demobilization
and
reintegration programme called for in the Darfur Peace Agreement;


   •To contribute to the creation of the necessary security conditions
for the provision of humanitarian assistance and to facilitate the
voluntary and sustainable return of refugees and internally displaced
persons to their homes;


   •In the areas of deployment of its forces and within its
capabilities, to protect the hybrid operation’s personnel, facilities,
installations and equipment, to ensure the security and freedom of
movement of United Nations-African Union personnel, humanitarian
workers and Assessment and Evaluation Commission personnel, to prevent
disruption of the implementation of the Darfur Peace Agreement by
armed groups and, without prejudice to the responsibility of the
Government of the Sudan, to protect civilians under imminent threat of
physical violence and prevent attacks and threats against civilians;


   •To monitor through proactive patrolling the parties’ policing
activities in camps for internally displaced persons, demilitarized
and buffer zones and areas of control;


   •To support, in coordination with the parties, as outlined in the
Darfur Peace Agreement, the establishment and training of community
police in camps for internally displaced persons, to support
capacity-building of the Government of the Sudan police in Darfur, in
accordance with international standards of human rights and
accountability, and to support the institutional development of the
police of the movements;


   •To support the efforts of the Government of the Sudan and of the
police of the movements to maintain public order and build the
capacity of Sudanese law enforcement in this regard through
specialized training and joint operations;


   •To provide technical mine-action advice and coordination and
demining capacity to support the Darfur Peace Agreement;


Rule of law, governance, and human rights:


   •To assist in the implementation of the provisions of the Darfur
Peace Agreement and any subsequent agreements relating to human rights
and the rule of law and to contribute to the creation of an
environment conducive to respect for human rights and the rule of law,
in which all are ensured effective protection;


   •To assist all stakeholders and local government authorities, in
particular in their efforts to transfer resources in an equitable
manner from the federal Government to the Darfur states, and to
implement reconstruction plans and existing and subsequent agreements
on land use and compensation issues;


   •To support the parties to the Darfur Peace Agreement in
restructuring and building the capacity of the police service in
Darfur, including through monitoring, training, mentoring, co-location
and joint patrols;


   •To assist in promoting the rule of law, including through
institution-building, and strengthening local capacities to combat
impunity;


   •To ensure an adequate human rights and gender presence capacity,
and expertise in Darfur in order to contribute to efforts to protect
and promote human rights in Darfur, with particular attention to
vulnerable groups;


   •To assist in harnessing the capacity of women to participate in
the peace process, including through political representation,
economic empowerment and protection from gender-based violence;


   •To support the implementation of provisions included in the Darfur
Peace Agreement and any subsequent agreements relating to upholding
the rights of children;


Humanitarian assistance:

   •To facilitate the effective provision of humanitarian assistance
and full access to people in need.


   •In its most recent resolution 2003 of 29 July 2011, the Security
Council underlined the need for UNAMID to make full use of its
capabilities and prioritize the protection of civilians; safe, timely
and unhindered humanitarian access; and to complement efforts to
promote the peace as well as the political process negotiated in Doha,
Qatar. It demanded that all parties to the conflict, including all
armed movements, immediately end the violence and make every effort to
reach a permanent ceasefire and a comprehensive settlement under the
Doha Document.



Appendix B: Reuters account of the Tabarat massacre of September 2010

On September 2, 2010 in the market area of the village of Tabarat,
some 20 kilometers west of Tawila (which is south of Kutum and site of
a UNAMID base), more than 50 ethnically African men and boys were
killed, most by gunshots at point-blank range. Despite desperately
urgent reports carried by survivors to the UNAMID force stationed at
nearby Tawila that evening, UNAMID refused either to intervene or to
evacuate the scores of wounded, many of whom subsequently died of
their wounds. Reuters reported (Khartoum, 17 September 2010) various
eyewitness accounts from Tabarat, which give us some sense of what
likely occurred in Hashaba.  Khartoum’s security forces prevented
UNAMID from investigating events in Tabarat for over a week, and it is
still the case that what we know comes primarily from a series of
Reuters interviews with survivors of the massacre:

“Darfuri men were shot dead at point blank range during a surprise
Arab militia raid on a busy market this month in which at least 39
people were killed and almost 50 injured, eyewitnesses said on Friday.
The attack on civilians was reminiscent of the early years of the
counter-insurgency operation in Sudan’s west, which took up arms
against the government in 2003, complaining that the region had been
neglected by Khartoum. The International Criminal Court in The Hague
has since issued an arrest warrant for Sudanese President Omar Hassan
al-Bashir for genocide and war crimes in Darfur, charges he denies.

“Details of the September 2 attack on the market in the village of
Tabarat have not previously come to light. The government prevented
peacekeepers from visiting the site until days later. But five
survivors of the attack told Reuters that heavily armed Arab militia
had targeted male victims and shot many at point blank range. One
diplomat said the militia were likely from among those armed and
mobilized by the government to quell the rebels. Those militia, known
as Janjaweed, were responsible for mass rape, murder and looting. Many
of the tribal militia still support the government but Khartoum has
lost control over some.

“In Tabarat, men were rounded up by militia wearing military uniforms
who rode into the market on horses and camels pretending to be buying
goods before spraying the shops with gunfire. Then vehicles mounted
with machine guns and carrying militia fighters appeared and rounded
up some of the men, survivors said.

“‘They laid them down and they came up close and shot them in their
heads,’ Abakr Abdelkarim, 45, told Reuters by telephone from the town
of Tawilla, where many of the victims had sought refuge and medical
help. ‘(Those killed) were all men and one woman—some men were tied
with rope behind the cars and dragged until they died.’”

RUN FOR HIS LIFE

“Adam Saleh said he had run for his life and hidden in nearby fields
to watch from afar. ‘They were targeting men—all of them were shot in
the head and chest, only those who were running away got shot in their
legs and arms.’ Nour Abdallah, 45, said the attackers let most of the
women run away. She could not escape and so lay face down in the dirt.
‘They told me not to lift my head up or I would be shot too.’

“Saleh and others said after the attack they had gone to the joint
U.N.-African Union (UNAMID) peacekeeping base in Tawilla to ask
peacekeepers to come to Tabarat but they had refused. ‘They also
refused to come and help us recover the bodies,’ Saleh added. UNAMID
has said both rebels and the government prevented it getting access to
the area.

“A UNAMID spokesman said he could not comment on the witness reports
but an internal document seen by Reuters showed UNAMID had received
similar witness reports of men being executed. The only aid agency
working in Tawilla, Médecins Sans Frontières, said it could confirm 39
people died and it had treated 46 injured, many with ‘serious gunshot
wounds.’ ‘We saw only men,’ said MSF head of mission Alessandro Tuzza.
He said he could not comment on how the victims were shot but that MSF
was still negotiating with the government to get access to the area in
North Darfur province.

“The witnesses said they had buried 41 bodies in common graves but
more were still in the bushes around the market. Sudan’s army denied
involvement in the attack and said the local government was
investigating. ‘The North Darfur government have formed a security
committee to investigate this.’ Presidential adviser Ghazi Salaheddin
visited the area on Friday on a fact-finding mission.” (Opheera McDoom
for Reuters [Khartoum], September 17, 2010)

-- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected].
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/groups/opt_out.


Reply via email to