Does the U.S. deserve its new seat on the Human Rights Council?

Posted By Colum LynchMonday, November 12, 2012 - 6:11 PM Share



The election of the United States to the U.N. Human Rights Council by
the General Assembly this morning drew sighs of relief from human
rights advocates who feared that a U.S. defeat would undercut American
support for the U.N.'s principal rights body.

The United States garnered the highest number of votes in a five-way
race for three seats reserved for Western governments, besting Germany
and Ireland, who also secured seats on the council, and leaving Greece
and Sweden in defeat.

The vote represented a victory for Susan Rice, the U.S. ambassador to
the United Nations, and Eileen Donahoe, the U.S. ambassador to the
Human Rights Council, who ran the risk of possible defeat in an effort
to promote open elections at the United Nations.

Rice said the United States is "proud" to have been elected in a "very
spirited campaign" to a second three-year term.

But did the U.S. really win on its merits?

Does the United States -- with its death penalty, its controversial
detention and shoot-to-kill drone policies -- really have a better
human rights record than Sweden?

"No," tweeted Jamil Dakwar, director of the ACLU's Human Rights
Program. But the United States, he added, "has more political power to
secure" U.N. General Assembly votes denouncing rights abuses. Dakwar
said that the United States falls short of its European competitors
for the seat, due to its excesses in the war on terrorism,
discriminatory criminal justice system, and immigration policy. And
yet, said Dakwar, "On balance, the United States deserves to be on the
Human Rights Council because of its overall record on human rights
issues over the years and its commitment to strengthening human
rights."

Dakwar's remarks reflect a widely held view among human rights
proponents, and European governments, that despite the Obama
administration's failings, Washington's leadership remains vital to
promoting broad human rights protections at the United Nations. It's
probably better to have Washington than Sweden on your side when
you're facing off with an emboldened new generation of Islamic leaders
who are committed to adopting resolutions outlawing criticism of
religions.

"It is not just about one's human rights record it's also about their
ability to make an effective contribution to advancing the Human
Rights Council," said Peggy Hicks, an expert at Human Rights Watch.
"In that sense, the U.S. carries far more political weight."

Suzanne Nossel, executive director of Amnesty International USA, said
that America's election provides Washington with an opportunity not
only to promote human rights values abroad, but to live up to them at
home. "The most important contribution the United Nations can now make
to the cause of human rights is a determined effort to regain its own
credibility," Nossel said. "The continued indefinite detention without
criminal charges of 166 men at the Guantanamo Bay naval base, the
ongoing military commission proceedings that fail to meet fair trial
standards, a drone program shrouded in secrecy, and the lack of
accountability for torture and disappearances in the so-called ‘war on
terror' undermine human rights and undercut the legitimacy of the
U.S.'s voice at the council."

The U.N. 47-nation Human Rights Council was established in 2006. But
the George W. Bush administration refused to join it, saying
membership would lend legitimacy to a body that included many
governments with appalling rights records. Obama reversed course,
arguing that it would be better to improve the body from within than
lecturing from the outside.

In recent years, the Obama administration has used its influence to
prevent countries with poor rights records from joining the body,
running campaigns to block countries like Belarus, Iran, and Syria
from getting on the council. But today's vote -- which also resulted
in election victories for Venezuela and Pakistan -- shows that it
remains a struggle to ensure that members of the council are actually
committed to promoting human rights. Critics of the Geneva-based
council argued that the fact that countries like Pakistan and
Venezuela won a greater number of votes than the United States
highlights the council's moral bankruptcy.

The real culprit in this unfolding spectacle is the U.N. system of
regional voting blocs, which generally pre-select a list of candidates
based on which country is next in line. The practice ensures that
everyone gets their chance -- whether they deserve it or not -- and
there are no messy elections.

It is hard to offer a precise measurement of a country's human rights
record because the major human rights advocatcy groups, such as
Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch, don't rank nations by
their record. The Freedom House Freedom Index, though, includes all
five Western candidates in the ranks of the "free." Reporters Without
Borders's Press Freedom Index ranks Sweden higher, at 12, than any of
the 18 countries voted on the Human Rights Council, including the
United States, which ranked 47.

But Sweden is by no means perfect, according to rights advocates.

Amnesty International has criticized Sweden for detaining and
surrendering two Egyptian asylum seekers, Ahmed Agiza and Mohammed
al-Zari, via a CIA-leased plane to Egypt, where they allegedly were
subject to torture. And Sweden also failed to meet international
standards in considering asylum applications from Roma that fled
Serbia.

But the Swedish candidacy had two liabilities.

For one, according to rights advocates, it had taken a tougher stance
-- alongside the United States -- against the traditional practice of
trading votes on other elections in order to win. And a loss for
Sweden posed no threat to the U.N. rights institution itself. "There
was a concern that if the United States was defeated it would give
fodder to those who are skeptical about U.S. engagement at the council
in the first place," said Peggy Hicks.

Follow me on Twitter @columlynch






EXPLORE:HUMAN RIGHTS, UNITED NATIONS

-- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected].
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/groups/opt_out.


Reply via email to