On 12/6/06, rod <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

Can anyone explain to me what seems to be a contradiction
between table 7.5.2.2 and figure 7.5.2.5(c), NFPA 2002 and
2007. My problem is that in table 7.5.2.2 it clearly shows
that at 40% water (60%glycerin) at 60F the specific gravity
is 1.171 and the freeze point is - 47.3.  Then it goes on to
show that with the same conditions and 30% water (70%
glycerin) the specific gravity is 1.197 and the freeze point
is -22.2F. We have always mixed our glycerin at a 60/40
ratio because of this chart. The problem as I see it is that
when you look at figure7.5.2.5( c ) the graph seems to show
that with 70% glycerine a lower freeze point can be
achieved. It also seems to show that pure 100% glycerine has
a freeze point of 62.6F so I assume that I am reading this
chart wrong but I can't seem to get my finger on it. As
always your help is appreciated.



this is the nature of chemistry, Rod.
pure Glycerine freezes at 62.6° F.
pure water freezes at 32 ° F.

Between these endpoints, most binary and
 terrtiary chemical systems are highly NON-linear.
 If you email me, I will be happy to send you
 the graph.  meanwhile, at

 http://www.dow.com/glycerine/resources/table8.htm

 you can get another perspective on the freezing points
 of the glycerine-water binary system at various weight
 percents.  Incidentally Figure 7.5.2.5(c) appears to be WRONG
 at freezing points for glycerine of 60 and 70 % by weight
 in both 2002 and 2007 versions.  The accuracy of
 Table 7.5.2.2 appears specious, too, when compared
 against the DOW data.  Maybe it is the GM derived
 DOW glycerine? :- )

what does that mean in the field?  From the quick graph I
  drew up for freezing points, it appears you get the best
  protection against cold using glycerine at about 70% by weight
  (freeze point approximately -38° F).  This trend should
  be fairly consistent among different "brands" of glycerine
  with at least 95% purity.



Scot Deal
Excelsior Fire Engineering
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum

Reply via email to