Steve, It is good to see you are thinking outside the box some, but I'm somewhat glad your performance-based approach to standpipe design was voted down. The comments that Chris makes regarding FD's have quite a bit of truth to them. You can design for what the SDFD or what any FD wants today, however, as Chris points out, that can change with a new fire chief or fire service changes in strategy/tactics or just pure fads. That building and standpipe however is going to be there for many decades. Over those many decades, how many different performance-based designs are there going to be in just one city? And those are on top of the 100 psi and 65 psi designs and even earlier crtieria.
Did your performance-based proposal also allow modifying the flow per outlet as well? Unless an FD is using 2 1/2" or maybe 2", they are not going to flow 250 gpm at a reasonable outlet pressure. If they are going to use 1 1/2 or 1 3/4" hose, the max gpm is probably only in the 175 gpm range. If we are going to force owners to pay for the extra pressure, why make them pay for gpm the FD will not use? There are a number of options out there to make good use of the current 100 psi outlet pressure. Every dept still has the option of 2 1/2" and many use it. For those that don't want to lug the bigger hose, a 2" line is well-sized for standpipe use. 2" line with a smooth-bore could deliver in the 225 gpm range and isn't much more difficult to handle than an 1 3/4". You portray somewhat the best case scenario with FDs that know how they want the standpipe to perform, Unfortunately, many small and mid-size cities, and probably even some bigger ones, aren't in that position and there is a lot to be said for standardization and where over time there is knowledge building on the fire service side and where neighboring (or not so neighboring in the internet world) can learn from each other how to properly utilize a "standard" design standpipe. I think this is an area where industry can assist FDs in understanding the design and how to match equipment to it vs. throwing key design criteria over the fence to the FD and asking "tell us what you want." Interesting discussion. Rich Richard Malek [EMAIL PROTECTED] -----Original Message----- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Behalf Of Steve Leyton Sent: Wednesday, December 06, 2006 12:17 PM To: [email protected] Subject: RE: pump capacity/standpipe Chris: I'm don't agree with the, "... requirements for gpm and pressure are broke beyond repair ..." smack, but I'm with you on, "... FD's haven't a clue what they want or need ..." I made a proposal in committee that we add a provision for hydraulic analysis of the actual hose nozzle set-up used by the serving fire department in determining the required outlet pressure, to essentially performance-engineer Class 1 standpipes, but it was voted down as too cumbersome. Here's the challenge: As Chris says, it's foreseeable that certain hose nozzle set-ups can require much higher outlet pressure to deliver the required residual at the tip. If the standard rig is a 2-1/2" gated wye with two 1-1/2" x 100' hoses the required outlet pressure to deliver 100 at the tips is almost 150 PSI. But not all nozzles are rated for 100 PSI - that just happened to be the first performance point at which a couple of manufacturers tested and received listings for their nozzles. Using Task Force Tips as an example, they now offer nozzles that are designed for as low as 45 PSI up to 100 PSI; I think they have 45, 75 and 100 PSI model families. The 45's and 75's work great with lower residuals at the tip and bring the required outlet pressure to or near 100. (Let's keep in mind that the nozzles are functional at lower pressures than their ratings, but may not meet the patterns and performance of their listings.) But it's really up to the serving FD to tell the designer what they need, based on the equipment their firefighters carry into buildings, and that should drive the design criteria. Here in San Diego, the FD specified a new high-rise pack with a 75 PSI nozzle - they're updating all of their trucks. New policy in this city, based purely on performance criteria, is 115-120 PSI at discharge; regardless of the specifics of nozzle performance or actual residual at the tip, this is what the FD wants based on full flow exercises they ran at their training facility. That's the way it should be - and that's how we can continue to shape NFPA 14 to "fix" it in this regard. But any chain of events is only as strong as its weakest link, and in this case it's the interaction between industry and fire service to query the serving departments about how they want standpipe systems to perform. Be proactive about asking and make them tell you ... Steve Leyton Protection Design & Consulting The foregoing is the opinion of the writer alone, and does not necessarily represent the intent of the NFPA 14 Technical Committee, nor constitute a formal or informal interpretation of the standard. -----Original Message----- From: Chris Cahill [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Wednesday, December 06, 2006 8:44 AM To: [email protected] Subject: RE: pump capacity/standpipe If you review what the FD actually uses you will probably find it's much higher than 100psi. A popular set up is 100 psi nozzles with 1-3/4" hose 200' which is 132 psi at the outlet at 100 gpm. Then there is no guessing what they will be using 5 years from now. Through the 80's and 90's required average pressures went up as a general trend. They seem to be going down IMHO in the '00's. Trends are irrelevant though when speaking of a particular job in a particular city. NFPA 14 requirements for gpm and pressure are broke beyond repair and FD's haven't a clue what they want or need, thus why NFPA 14 is broke. If I knew how to fix it I would send in a proposal, but I don't. Chris Cahill, P.E. Fire Protection Engineer Sentry Fire Protection, Inc. 763-658-4483 763-658-4921 fax Email: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Mail: P.O. Box 69 Waverly, MN 55390 Location: 4439 Hwy 12 SW Waverly, MN 55390 -----Original Message----- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Thom McMahon Sent: Wednesday, December 06, 2006 10:14 AM To: [email protected] Subject: Re: pump capacity/standpipe I don't want to beat this horse to death like a "Big Ass Fan", but it would be prudent if you reviewed the changes to 14 for 2007, and reviewed the equipment used by the AHJ, to meet the hose and Nozzle friction loss calc's. (They may actually be lower than the 100 Psi at the outlet depending on the nozzle.) Thom McMahon Firetech, Inc. 2560 Copper Ridge Dr Steamboat Springs, CO 80488-2136 Tel: 970-879-7952 Fax: 970-879-7926 ----- Original Message ----- From: "Joe Hankins" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: <[email protected]> Sent: Wednesday, December 06, 2006 8:49 AM Subject: Re: pump capacity _______________________________________________ Sprinklerforum mailing list [email protected] http://lists.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum _______________________________________________ Sprinklerforum mailing list [email protected] http://lists.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum _______________________________________________ Sprinklerforum mailing list [email protected] http://lists.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum _______________________________________________ Sprinklerforum mailing list [email protected] http://lists.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum
