In 1977 I had just gotten my drivers license,
but that date rings true to when Bud Nelson conceived of,
and together with Shibe, wrote up an equivalency
system (FSES or Fire Safety Equivalency System)
that became an Annex to the Life Safety Code.  The
publish date for the FSES was 1978, so the concept
must have been implemented months, if not years before
that.  I recall Nelson first applied this method to a federally funded
hospital in Boston.  He was motivated to create this
performance-based system because "badge heavy"
fire inspectors would not budge on prescriptive Codes
(or could not see the forest for the trees).

I know I am going to make some enemies with these
statements, but the Codes are a guideline for our
ultimate common sense.  The Codes work in the
vast, vast majority of instances;  but not in all instances.
And in those instances where the Codes do not apply (or
fit) too well, that is where an Engineering Judgment comes
in.  Most high school students can do what we do, except when it
comes to exercising expert judgment on a situation that
lands "outside" the Codes.  For me, that is when the job
get REAL fun.  Somewhere it was said, rules are for people
that don´t want to think.  We don´t have time to think about
every decision.  But we need the flexibility to pass judgments
when we *must* think about decisions.

Nelson´s FSES provided a systematic method for
trading-off one fire protection strategy for another.  Strategies
included walls, smoke detection, sprinklers, exiting, etc.  The
weighting of the different systems was decided upon by industry experts
(via a Delphi group).  I know Nelson´s system saved millions of dollars
on that Boston hospital alone.  There were many hospitals that followed
this cost saving approach.  Sprinklers were given lots of trade offs.
The FSES grew from application to hospitals to application in other
occupancies.

scot deal
excelsior fire engineering




On 11/29/07, Chris Cahill <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
>
> Well I have the report or to say an article from Hospitals Feb 1, 1977
> published by the American Hospital Association - No the date is not a
> typo.
>
> So the date is the first things that jumps out so pricing needs to be
> dated.
>
>
> It's written by Patton and the Director of the Division of Architectural
> Services for the State of Kansas.
>
> It describes a very large hospital not unlike we'd think today.
>
> The article is scarce on detail we could "learn" from.  To that end here
> are
> some interesting items.
>
> I paraphrase "Most industries face double inflation...labor and materials
> are expected....for the past 10 years new safety regs have been added...So
> a
> smoke detector costs more and more of them are required...double
> inflation."
>
> Or perhaps those setting the budget didn't keep up with the times, sound
> familiar today?
>
> I paraphrase again "After being 10 mill over budget on a $50 mill project
> (in 1977 dollars) the State Arch investigated other facilities for
> ideas....hired FPE (Patton)...substituted new sprinklers for conventional
> sprinkler systems...smaller pipe saved money...also provided composite
> safety plan."
>
> I was riding BMX bikes and playing Little League in 1977 anyone have an
> idea
> on what new vs. conventional means.  EC I don't think existed.  I don't
> think old style vs spray style was the issue.  Could mean pipe schedule
> vs.
> calcs to trim pipe size?  Any ideas?  But see below sounds hard to believe
> the cost of smaller pipe saved that much when at least today labor is the
> expensive part.
>
> Continuing "sprinkler primary safety tool...eliminated excessive fire
> protection...fire proofing...alarms....others were modified.."
>
> "Basement only standard sprinkles in original bid...$403,000, 140,000 sq.
> ft. (in 1977 dollars)....new sprinklers throughout $431,136, 850,000 sq.ft
> .
> (I don't know if that includes the bsmt or not) plus saving on all other
> fire items....$5 mill total savings to project."
>
> Even back then sounds like someone really screwed up in the specifying the
> first time around.  Overall I'd say it's very pro sprinkler, especially
> for
> the time.  Further considering the time it's perhaps an early example of
> performance based design, alternate methods which really saved the big
> portion of the money.  Although, I still have doubts about the sprinkler
> costs above.
>
> Chris Cahill, P.E.
> Fire Protection Engineer
> Sentry Fire Protection, Inc.
>
> 763-658-4483
> 763-658-4921 fax
>
> Email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
>
> Mail: P.O. Box 69
>        Waverly, MN 55390
>
> Location: 4439 Hwy 12 SW
>              Waverly, MN 55390
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Chris Cahill [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> Sent: Wednesday, November 21, 2007 1:40 PM
> To: '[email protected]'
> Subject: RE: Wow
>
> I have one coming as well.  Note he said it was DESIGNED for $0.35.  I'm
> sure he meant designed and installed but on face value that's not what was
> written.  Of course it doesn't say what year either.  Maybe in 1950's
> dollars when you really needed 4 heads in a 16'x16'room because the EC
> technology wasn't around.
>
> We'll see.
>
> Chris Cahill, P.E.
> Fire Protection Engineer
> Sentry Fire Protection, Inc.
>
> 763-658-4483
> 763-658-4921 fax
>
> Email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
>
> Mail: P.O. Box 69
>        Waverly, MN 55390
>
> Location: 4439 Hwy 12 SW
>              Waverly, MN 55390
>
> _______________________________________________
> Sprinklerforum mailing list
> [email protected]
> http://lists.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum
>
> To Unsubscribe, send an email to:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> (Put the word unsubscribe in the subject field)
>
_______________________________________________
Sprinklerforum mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum

To Unsubscribe, send an email to:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
(Put the word unsubscribe in the subject field)

Reply via email to