FYI Governor Mark Sanford said legislation that offers tax credits for businesses to install sprinkler systems is too expensive and smacks of too much government interference.
His comments, and the looming threat of a veto, have sparked a litany of criticism from lawmakers and firefighters, who say this is all about the politics of money and the price of human life. The legislation, filed in response to the June 18 Sofa Super Store fire that killed nine Charleston firefighters, would give businesses a tax credit for 80 percent of the cost of installing sprinklers in their buildings. It is considered one of the safest bets to pass the General Assembly this year. Sanford said the size of the proposed tax credit makes this a government entitlement, not encouragement, and erodes the free market and home rule. His office suggested that a lower percentage on the tax credit would be more appropriate, and palatable, to the governor. House Speaker Bobby Harrell, who vows to override any veto of the sprinkler legislation, told the governor in a letter that "you miss the point entirely." "This bill is about saving lives," said Harrell, R-Charleston. This difference of opinion and philosophy threatens to politicize one of the most high-profile pieces of state legislation this year. Some Statehouse insiders say that, quietly, lobbyists have been complaining to lawmakers about the high cost of adding sprinklers to existing businesses. Mike Parrotta, president of the South Carolina Professional Firefighters, has spent time in Columbia in support of the sprinkler bill, and has been shocked by the opposition. "Sprinkler systems save lives and property, there is no argument," Parrotta said. "What's more important than that?" Sanford wrote to Harrell, and members of the House Ways and Means Committee, about the bill on Feb. 6. He said that while he applauded lawmakers' attempt to "bring good out of the horror that has come to South Carolina," he said emotions "can swing to the point of creating policy that would cause damage to society at large in different ways." "There seems to be too much government interference, regulation and subsidy," Sanford wrote earlier this month. The governor said that adding more sales tax exemptions for sprinkler bills, basically subsidizing sprinklers, could be a burden to taxpayers. Sanford spokesman Joel Sawyer couldn't say what the governor will do if the Legislature passes the sprinkler legislation, which has wide support in the House and Senate. "If the bill comes to the governor's desk, he'll look at it carefully, but he does have concerns with the bill in its current form," Sawyer said. Harrell said the sprinkler bill is much the same as the coastal insurance legislation passed last year at the governor's urging, which offers tax credits to owners of homes and businesses that are retrofitted to make them safer from storms. The cost of the coastal insurance tax credits is about $30 million over five years, and he estimated the cost of the sprinkler legislation at about $36 million over the same period. "I really don't understand the opposition to fire sprinklers when the support was there for coastal insurance reform," Harrell said. Sanford said the difference is that the coastal insurance legislation provides only a 25 percent tax credit capped at $1,000, but the sprinkler legislation is a 20 percent private match to get 80 percent public funding. The sprinkler legislation enjoys wide support in the firefighting community. Jeffery Thompson, deputy chief with Pine Ridge Fire Department, lost his brother, Brandon, in the Sofa Super Store fire. He said the bottom line is that sprinklers save lives. "I definitely feel the outcome of the Sofa Super Store fire would have been different if they had had sprinklers," Thompson said. House and Senate members said they can likely round up the two-thirds majority needed to override a Sanford veto, but fire groups hope that it doesn't get that far. Roger L. Yow, president of IAFF Local 61, the Charleston Firefighters Association, said this isn't about philosophy, and there is no gray area. "They are putting money above lives," Yow said. "If he vetoes it, apparently he doesn't support fire safety." Reach Brian Hicks at 937-5561 or [EMAIL PROTECTED] Reach Yvonne Wenger at [EMAIL PROTECTED] or 803-799-9051. _______________________________________________ Sprinklerforum mailing list [email protected] http://lists.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum To Unsubscribe, send an email to:[EMAIL PROTECTED] (Put the word unsubscribe in the subject field)
