Dear Developers, I've been lurking on the developers list for a while and submitted the questions/problems below to the struts-user list. Unfortunately I haven't gotten a reply, and I was recommended to try the developers list. I hope, that posting this list to the developer list, is not to big a breech of protocol.
Best regards /Maya Retzlaff ps. Due to time differences I might be a bit slow in replying ds. > -----Original Message----- > From: Maya Retzlaff [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Sent: den 28 juli 2003 21:19 > To: 'Struts Users Mailing List' > Subject: RE: Memory consumption 1.1 b3 vs. 1.1 final > > > Hi, > > Unfortunate no one replied. But I'll try again with more information. > > After a bit more debugging, when using the debugger see screen shot. > http://maya.retzlaff.se/debugScreenShot.png, sorry couldn't > export to text. > Its a bit censored. > > This means that the whole struts-config.xml (a HashMap with > 127 elements) is > saved in the session for every user when <action > scope="session"> is set in > struts-config.xml. For us with the memory restrictions we > face, the 50k that > the strutsconfig takes in memory is very severe. > If this is a conscious design description, it would be very > good to hear the > reasons. > If not could we in anyway work with someone to help debug it > so we could > submit a patch? > > Now when comparing the source files for the different > releases we can't find > anything significantly different in any of these classes. And > finding where > moduleconfig gets set into the FormBeanConfig is untraceable. > Is it done in > apache.commons? > > A search in bugzilla either hasn't yielded anything either, > regrettably > > We are on a schedule and need to have this solved on Weds, > otherwise we need > to go back to the 1.1 b3 release. Obviously we would prefer to use the > stable 1.1 release. > > Help would be very much appreciated. > > > /Maya > > > -----Original Message----- > > From: Maya Retzlaff [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > > Sent: den 25 juli 2003 19:57 > > To: 'Struts Users Mailing List' > > Subject: Memory consumption 1.1 b3 vs. 1.1 final > > > > > > Hi, > > > > Me and my colleagues are developing a web application in an > > environment of > > very strict memory limitations, for instance the session size > > per user is > > limited to 15k. > > If we go over the limit the application fails. Its out of > our control > > unfortunately. > > > > We are subclassing the DynaActionForm for use in our own > > forms, when this > > form is saved to the session, which we do in rare cases, it > > uses quite a lot > > of memory. > > > > We were previously running on jakarta-struts-1.1-b3 from > > October release > > which caused no problem. Below is a comparison of the memory > > consumption > > with 1.1 Final on the _same_ form > > > > Running on the same version of tomcat: > > > > 1.1 b3 2344 k > > 1.1 Final 76624 k > > > > When debugging (serializing and back) we found that the > > DynaAction uses > > FormBeanConfig which in turns refer to ModuleConfigImp which keeps a > > reference to the complete struts config file. This in our > > case, where we > > don't use modules but have all the config info in one class, > > takes quite a > > lot of memory. > > > > In comparing directories, and source from the two different > > releases nothing > > obvious appears. > > > > The memory problem still appears on our wml interface site where we > > ourselves implemented the "front end" bits of struts instead > > of struts-html, > > we can rule out a fair chunk of the struts classes. > > > > Has anyone else come across the problem? Any suggestions on > > how we could > > reduce the size. > > > > We'd be very grateful for help as the release date for the > > project we are > > working is starting to get uncomfortably close. > > > > Best Regards > > /Maya > > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
