I can think of three ways to incorporate the Equation of Time into a
twisted band dial:

(1) A correction can be made in the hardware by simply turning the
band around its axis. Since it is hung up on a polar support, this is
easier to accomplish than with some other designs like horizontal
plates. The drawback, of course, in addition to mechanical complexity,
is that somebody has to constantly readjust the dial.

(2) When the sun is at different declinations, the line of the shadow
will be at an angle across the strip. Multiple lines can be put on the
strip and you only have to read from the one with the angle matching
the shadow. The drawback is the inherently bivalent nature of the
analemma, i.e., for most dates there will be two lines that match and
you still have to figure out which one to read. Furthermore, the
accuracy is not great near the equinoxes because the EoT is changing
but the declination is not.

(3) The shadow is a line, but only a point is needed to tell the
time. This opens up the possibility of adding date lines down the
length of the strip and making the time lines the same wiggly shape as
the Equation of Time graph (plus, ideally, an additional correction
for the changing slope of the shadow mentioned above). To use the
dial, you find the intersection of the shadow with the line for the
current date and read the corrected time from the wiggly line passing
through that point. I like this solution. It is easy to manufacture
because all the time curves have the same shape and the same
separation, and it is easy and accurate to use.

Regards,

Art Carlson

Reply via email to