Dear Frank, I have only just got around to reading your account of the Margaret Stanier Memorial Dial which I downloaded a couple of weeks ago so I hope you will treat this response as better late than never.
Congratulations on implementing a novel dialling concept in such a beautiful dial. Your account of the evolution and manufacture of the dial was a delight to read and I am surprised that it has not resulted in more widespread acclaim from this list. I must assume that your readers are dumbfounded. My only comment is that your omission of the sunrise/sunset hours should be regarded as of no practical disadvantage since the timings of these phenomena are evident to the observer without the need for a dial. You asked to be alerted to typos and I think that you might have transposed the standard deviation values for R1 and R2 in the last sentence of the penultimate paragraph on page 30. Thank you for providing us with such a comprehensive and thought-provoking account of your creation. Best Wishes, Geoff -----Original Message----- From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Frank King Sent: 26 September 2010 17:18 To: sundial Subject: Another Sundial with VI at Midday... Dear All, The beer-glass sundial spotted by Mike Cowham brought on a panic attack. More strictly, it was his comment that caused alarm... > The glass acts as the gnomon but the real horror ... > midday was at VI. Maybe every reader should pour a glass of beer (or something stronger) before reading any further. I have just inaugurated my latest creation and, guess what, midday is at VI. Should I spend my declining years designing sundials for garden centres? Make sure you have a first-aider to hand and take a look at: http://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/users/fhk1/Newnham/FHK+Dial.jpg I hope, by the way, that you like my outfit. I chose to wear British Sundial Society-approved colour-coordinated yellow for the occasion. This sundial is a memorial tribute, by Newnham College, Cambridge, to Margaret Stanier, lately Editor of the BSS Bulletin. About 10 years ago, Margaret told me how important mass dials were so I thought I would come up with a design which is (ever so loosely) based on a 24-line mass dial. My goal was impossible but I am not easily put off... I wanted an unequal-hours sundial where the time is indicated by the direction of the shadow of a rod gnomon. [I didn't want to use a nodus and its point-indicating shadow.] Is there a "best" approximation? Newnham College asked for a account written for technically-minded academics who know nothing about sundials. You can see this, and numerous photographs, at: http://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/users/fhk1/Newnham/write-up.pdf You will even see that this dial incorporates a few dialling jokes :-) Here I proffer some acknowledgements to: Margaret Stanier for the inspiration. Frans Maes and many others for making me think about the Braunschweig dials. Geoff Thurston for making me think about just what is meant by "best-fit" when making compromises. Gianni Ferrari for explaining that the hour-lines on this design "don't have great gnomonic meaning". Not many unequal-hours sundials get made these days so, if you think it is a sundial at all, make the most of this one :-) Please let me know of all the typos that you spot. I haven't handed the account to the College yet! Now what was that beer that Mike was telling us about? Frank H. King Cambridge, U.K. --------------------------------------------------- https://lists.uni-koeln.de/mailman/listinfo/sundial --------------------------------------------------- https://lists.uni-koeln.de/mailman/listinfo/sundial
