I believe that Brad had it right in terms of the "philosophical" intent of the question poser. But we must plunge ahead into the actual mechanical outcome.
Dave, I believe you have approximately the right shape path for a walker with an apparent sun path that crosses his meridian south of his zenith. Continuing with that setup and the walker being on the equator to begin his walk at sunrise, I question whether the walker ever makes it back to the same line of longitude from whence he started. By walking away from the sun he has ended up extending the time from 6 hours between sunrise and solar noon to 6 hours plus. After solar noon, he is retreating from the sun and shortening the time to sunset to less than 6 hours. Hence, he winds up at a location north of his starting point, but longitudinally west of his starting longitude. In John's first setup with the walker on the equator on the equinox, the sun passes through the zenith so the walker would only be treading on the equator, but using the same argument above, heading west until solar noon would take 6 plus hours and the time spent heading back east would be under 6 hours so a constant speed walker would fall short of returning to his starting point. Larry Bohlayer From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Dave Bell Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2011 9:43 PM To: 'John Carmichael'; 'Sundial List' Subject: RE: Walking Shadow Riddle Interesting question!! I couldn't get my head around it, either, so tried plotting it in Excel. Grabbing a table of Solar Azimuth for Tucson on today's date, I estimated a 5 mph rate. Since the Sun rises just barely South of East, the path starts out heading North and mostly West. By noon, our trekker has reached 25 miles West and 12 miles North of his starting point. By sunset, he has walked back East to a point 25 miles North of his start. The path looks like half of an ellipse with an East-West major axis of roughly 50 miles, and a North-South minor axis of slightly over 25 miles. December 21st looks a lot different, and I'm having trouble buying it! Dave _____ From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of John Carmichael Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2011 11:08 AM To: 'Sundial List' Subject: Walking Shadow Riddle A Riddle: I was watching a dumb movie last weekend and there was a bit of dialogue that caught my attention. I'm sure this relates to sundials and mapping, but the answer eludes me. One of the characters was told by the wise man to: "walk towards your shadow all day, starting at sunrise and stopping at sunset" at which point the walker would discover the location of a treasure. So I asked myself, what would the path of the trek look like on a map? But I can't figure it out. This is as far as I get in my thinking: I started considering an example with these conditions.- The walk begins at dawn on the equinox, and the man is on the equator. And the walk ends at sunset. So we know that the walk will last twelve hours. If the average speed of a walking man is 5 km/hr. , it is 12 hours from sunrise to sunset; then we know that he will walk 60 km. He'll start walking towards the west at dawn and his path will turn towards the north in the morning as the sun heads south. After Solar Noon, his path will turn towards the east he'll end up facing due east at sunset. And we know that the path will be a curve since his shadow will always be changing direction. But what would the curve look like on a map? Would it be a hyperbola? How would the curve change if he walks on the summer solstice instead? What if he's at the North Pole? John C.
--------------------------------------------------- https://lists.uni-koeln.de/mailman/listinfo/sundial
