Hi Edward,

Thanks for the patch. I'm interested in integrating it into Sup
mainline. A couple comments:

1. Can you rename it to custom-search? I think that's a better
   description.

2. I would rather have the hook return a value. So this:
> -    subs = s.gsub(/\b(to|from):(\S+)\b/) do
> +    subs = String.new s
> +    HookManager.run("before-search", :subs => subs)
  I would rather see as:
    subs = HookManager.run("before-search", :subs => s) || s

3. It's not really an issue of mutation vs no mutation. The problem is
   that the parameter names in hooks are method calls, not variables. So
   while "subs = subs.gsub(...)" causes a 'subs' local variable to be
   created and initialized to nil, both "x = subs.gsub(...)" and "subs =
   self.subs.gsub(...)" work fine.

   This is probably less of an issue when the hook is returning a
   values, but if you could change the comments to be a warning about
   shadowing method calls instead that would be better.

Thanks!
-- 
William <[email protected]>
_______________________________________________
sup-talk mailing list
[email protected]
http://rubyforge.org/mailman/listinfo/sup-talk

Reply via email to