Nothing new here, but great to see this all summed up in a newspaper
of general circulation.

Jon

==================================================================

Corn Can't Solve Our Problem
By David Tilman and Jason Hill
Sunday, March 25, 2007; B01
washingtonpost.com

The world has come full circle. A century ago our first
transportation biofuels -- the hay and oats fed to our horses --
were replaced by gasoline. Today, ethanol from corn and biodiesel
from soybeans have begun edging out gasoline and diesel.

This has been hailed as an overwhelmingly positive development
that will help us reduce the threat of climate change and ease our
dependence on foreign oil. In political circles, ethanol is the
flavor of the day, and presidential candidates have been cycling
through Iowa extolling its benefits. Lost in the ethanol-induced
euphoria, however, is the fact that three of our most fundamental
needs -- food, energy, and a livable and sustainable environment
-- are now in direct conflict. Moreover, our recent analyses of
the full costs and benefits of various biofuels, performed at the
University of Minnesota, present a markedly different and more
nuanced picture than has been heard on the campaign trail.

Some biofuels, if properly produced, do have the potential to
provide climate-friendly energy, but where and how can we grow
them? Our most fertile lands are already dedicated to food
production. As demand for both food and energy increases,
competition for fertile lands could raise food prices enough to
drive the poorer third of the globe into malnourishment. The
destruction of rainforests and other ecosystems to make new
farmland would threaten the continued existence of countless
animal and plant species and would increase the amount of
climate-changing carbon dioxide in the atmosphere.

Finding and implementing solutions to the food, fuel and
environment conflict is one of the greatest challenges facing
humanity. But solutions will be neither adopted nor sought until
we understand the interlinked problems we face.

Fossil fuel use has pushed atmospheric carbon dioxide higher than
at any time during the past half-million years. The global
population has increased threefold in the past century and will
increase by half again, to 9 billion people, by 2050. Global food
and fossil energy consumption are on trajectories to double by
2050.

Biofuels, such as ethanol made from corn, have the potential to
provide us with cleaner energy. But because of how corn ethanol
currently is made, only about 20 percent of each gallon is "new"
energy. That is because it takes a lot of "old" fossil energy to
make it: diesel to run tractors, natural gas to make fertilizer
and, of course, fuel to run the refineries that convert corn to
ethanol.

If every one of the 70 million acres on which corn was grown in
2006 was used for ethanol, the amount produced would displace only
12 percent of the U.S. gasoline market. Moreover, the "new"
(non-fossil) energy gained would be very small -- just 2.4 percent
of the market. Car tune-ups and proper tire air pressure would
save more energy.

There is another problem with relying on a food-based biofuel,
such as corn ethanol, as the poor of Mexico can attest. In recent
months, soaring corn prices, sparked by demand from ethanol
plants, have doubled the price of tortillas, a staple food. Tens
of thousands of Mexico City's poor recently protested this
"ethanol tax" in the streets.

In the United States, the protests have also begun -- in
Congress. Representatives of the dairy, poultry and livestock
industries, which rely on corn as a principal animal feed, are
seeking an end to subsidies for corn ethanol in the hope of
stabilizing corn prices. (It takes about three pounds of corn to
produce a pound of chicken, and seven or eight pounds to grow a
pound of beef.) Profit margins are being squeezed, and meat prices
are rising.

U.S. soybeans, which are used to make biodiesel, may be about to
follow corn's trajectory, escalating the food vs. fuel
conflict. The National Biodiesel Board recently reported that 77
biodiesel production plants are under construction and that eight
established plants are expanding capacity.

In terms of environmental impact, all biofuels are not created
equal. Ethanol is the same chemical product no matter what its
source. But ethanol made from prairie grasses, from corn grown in
Illinois and from sugar cane grown on newly cleared land in Brazil
have radically different impacts on greenhouse gases.

Corn, like all plants, is a natural part of the global carbon
cycle. The growing crop absorbs carbon dioxide from the
atmosphere, so burning corn ethanol does not directly create any
additional carbon. But that is only part of the story. All of the
fossil fuels used to grow corn and change it into ethanol release
new carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases. The net effect is
that ethanol from corn grown in the Corn Belt does increase
atmospheric greenhouse gases, and this increase is only about 15
percent less than the increase caused by an equivalent amount of
gasoline. Soybean biodiesel does better, causing a greenhouse gas
increase that is about 40 percent less than that from petroleum
diesel.

In Brazil, ethanol made from sugar cane produces about twice as
much ethanol per acre as corn. Brazilian ethanol refineries get
much of their power from burning cane residue, in effect recycling
carbon from the atmosphere. The environmental benefit is
large. Sugar-cane ethanol grown on established soils releases 80
percent less greenhouse gases than gasoline.

But that isn't the case for sugar-cane ethanol or soybean
biodiesel from Brazil's newly cleared lands, including tropical
forests and savannas. Clearing land releases immense amounts of
greenhouse gases into the air, because much of the material in the
plants and soil is broken down into carbon dioxide.

Plants and soil contain three times more carbon than the
atmosphere. The trees and soil of an acre of rainforest -- which,
once cleared, is suitable for growing soybeans -- contain about
120 tons of organic carbon. An acre of tropical woodland or
savanna, suitable for sugar cane, contains about half this
amount. About a fourth of the carbon in an ecosystem is released
to the atmosphere as carbon dioxide when trees are clear-cut,
brush and branches are burned or rot, and roots decay. Even more
is lost during the first 20 to 50 years of farming, as soil carbon
decomposes into carbon dioxide and as wood products are burned or
decay.

This means that when tropical woodland is cleared to produce sugar
cane for ethanol, the greenhouse gas released is about 50 percent
greater than what occurs from the production and use of the same
amount of gasoline. And that statistic holds for at least two
decades.

Simply being "renewable" does not automatically make a fuel better
for the atmosphere than the fossil fuel it replaces, nor guarantee
that society gains any new energy by its production. The European
Union was recently shocked to learn that some of its imported
biodiesel, derived from palm trees planted on rain-forest lands,
was more than twice as bad for climate warming as petroleum
diesel. So much for the "benefits" of that form of biodiesel.

Although current Brazilian ethanol is environmentally friendly,
the long-term environmental implications of buying more ethanol
and biodiesel from Brazil, a possibility raised recently during
President Bush's trip to that country, are cloudy. It could be
harmful to both the climate and the preservation of tropical plant
and animal species if it involved, directly or indirectly,
additional clearing of native ecosystems.

Concerns about the environmental effects of ethanol production are
starting to be felt in the United States as well. It appears that
American farmers may add 10 million acres of corn this year to
meet booming demand for ethanol. Some of this land could come from
millions of acres now set aside nationwide for conservation under
a government-subsidized program. Those uncultivated acres absorb
atmospheric carbon, so farming them and converting the corn into
ethanol could release more carbon dioxide into the air than would
burning gasoline.

There are biofuel crops that can be grown with much less energy
and chemicals than the food crops we currently use for
biofuels. And they can be grown on our less fertile land,
especially land that has been degraded by farming. This would
decrease competition between food and biofuel. The United States
has about 60 million acres of such land -- in the Conservation
Reserve Program, road edge rights-of-way and abandoned farmlands.

In a 10-year experiment reported in Science magazine in December,
we explored how much bioenergy could be produced by 18 different
native prairie plant species grown on highly degraded and
infertile soil. We planted 172 plots in central Minnesota with
various combinations of these species, randomly chosen. We found,
on this highly degraded land, that the plots planted with mixtures
of many native prairie perennial species yielded 238 percent more
bioenergy than those planted with single species. High plant
diversity led to high productivity, and little fertilizer or
chemical weed or pest killers was required.

The prairie "hay" harvested from these plots can be used to create
high-value energy sources. For instance, it can be mixed with coal
and burned for electricity generation. It can be "gasified," then
chemically combined to make ethanol or synthetic gasoline. Or it
can be burned in a turbine engine to make electricity. A technique
that is undergoing rapid development involves bioengineering
enzymes that digest parts of plants (the cellulose) into sugars
that are then fermented into ethanol.

Whether converted into electricity, ethanol or synthetic gasoline,
the high-diversity hay from infertile land produced as much or
more new usable energy per acre as corn for ethanol on fertile
land. And it could be harvested year after year.

Even more surprising were the greenhouse gas benefits. When
high-diversity mixtures of native plants are grown on degraded
soils, they remove carbon dioxide from the air. Much of this
carbon ends up stored in the soil. In essence, mixtures of native
plants gradually restore the carbon levels that degraded soils had
before being cleared and farmed. This benefit lasts for about a
century.

Across the full process of growing high-diversity prairie hay,
converting it into an energy source and using that energy, we
found a net removal and storage of about a ton and a half of
atmospheric carbon dioxide per acre. The net effect is that
ethanol or synthetic gasoline produced from this grass on degraded
land can provide energy that actually reduces atmospheric levels
of carbon dioxide.

When one of these carbon-negative biofuels is mixed with gasoline,
the resulting blend releases less carbon dioxide than traditional
gasoline.

Biofuels, if used properly, can help us balance our need for food,
energy and a habitable and sustainable environment. To help this
happen, though, we need a national biofuels policy that favors our
best options. We must determine the carbon impacts of each method
of making these fuels, then mandate fuel blending that achieves a
prescribed greenhouse gas reduction. We have the knowledge and
technology to start solving these problems.

[EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]

David Tilman is an ecologist at the University of Minnesota and a
member of the National Academy of Sciences. Jason Hill is a
research associate in the Department of Applied Economics at the
University of Minnesota.


_______________________________________________
RSS, archives, subscription & listserv information for:
[email protected]
http://lists.mutualaid.org/mailman/listinfo/sustainabletompkins
free hosting by http://www.mutualaid.org

Reply via email to