---------- Forwarded message ----------
Date: Fri, 8 Jun 2007 14:15:33 -0700
From: "Bialic, Trudy" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: "Garrett, Steven M." <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>,
     Acting Food Policy Council of Seattle and King County
     <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Cc: Network Member ListServ <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Subject: RE: [wsffnet] Focus on 'food miles' is too narrow, say researchers

Steven,

You're right of course that the research from the U of Wales is not a
peer-reviewed report in Nature or Science, but as you inherently
suggest, there's very little research on the actual ecological impact of
food. This research cited by the Guardian probably is some of the first,
spurred on by the "local" movement, which certainly has ignored HOW food
is produced and how some methods (especially fossil fuel based
pesticides and fertilizers) may pose even greater impacts on the
environment, not to mention public health.

If you wish to know more about the study from Wales, you might contact
Dr. Ruth Fairchild and her colleague Andrea Collins at the University of
Wales Institute in Cardiff.  It took me only one keystroke on Google to
find the University of Wales Institute, and one more to get the address
to send an email to general inquiries for their contact info
http://www2.uwic.ac.uk/UWIC/contact/
<http://www2.uwic.ac.uk/UWIC/contact/> . Also readily available at that
site is Sarah Narusberg, Communications Officer (Tel: 029 2041 6221_ or
[EMAIL PROTECTED] <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]> .  Let Sarah what
it is you'd like to see and I bet that Dr. Fairchild would be glad to
provide it.

I don't believe anyone would argue that purchasing locally grown,
organically grown foods are the best choice for sustainability. The
point remains, however, that assuming anything local is more sustainable
than anything brought from further away won't hold up.

Two examples I recently learned about from a U. of Oregon Ph. D.
candidate (also with Resource Innovations at the university), that you
may not be familiar with: 1) that buying rice from Thailand is more eco-
and energy efficient than buying rice from California. Why? Because
growing rice in arid California requires substantial amounts of energy
and fossil fuels to make piping for irrigation, to warehouse, ship and
build the pipes, then run pumps to run water through the pipes. In
Thailand, the fields are watered by monsoon rains.  2) it's more
eco-efficient for the British to eat lamb from New Zealand than lamb
from England, becuase the lamb in England is raised on
petroleum-intensive corn.

I'm hoping more research will be done on the ecological impact of
various food production systems. We clearly don't have enough. Local is
part of the sustainability equation and it may be significant, all other
things being equal, but it's clearly not always the deciding factor.

Trudy


________________________________

From: Garrett, Steven M. [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: Thursday, June 07, 2007 1:11 PM
To: Bialic, Trudy; Acting Food Policy Council of Seattle and King County
Cc: Network Member ListServ
Subject: RE: [wsffnet] Focus on 'food miles' is too narrow, say
researchers



Trudy,

I think most reasonable folks would agree with your statement. However,
no one should rush to any judgment just yet on the actual ecological
impact of localization. This is just one study and the journal of
"Sustainable Food Consumption" is not exactly Nature or Science. Try
finding it on the web. I couldn't.



Also, it is not available in the Cascade Inter-Library loan system
(comprising nearly all public and private university and college
libraries in the PNW). I even went to the researchers' own websites. Not
there either.



If you can't find it, read it, critique it, and cite it, it might as
well not even exist. All we have is a University of Cardiff press
release. So until this report, and others like it, surface and
effectively contradict common sense and existing research (e.g., Pretty
et al), I will carry on promoting localization as a significant part of
an ecologically sound diet.

Steven



________________________________

From: Bialic, Trudy [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: Thursday, June 07, 2007 12:26 PM
To: Acting Food Policy Council of Seattle and King County
Cc: Network Member ListServ
Subject: [wsffnet] Focus on 'food miles' is too narrow, say researchers



fyi, as mentioned before, the focus on "local" is way too simplistic
when the goal is reducing environmental impact

Trudy



________________________________

From: Natasha Spoden [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: Thursday, June 07, 2007 10:21 AM
To: Bialic, Trudy
Cc: David Lively; Natalie Reitman-White
Subject: Focus on 'food miles' is too narrow, say researchers





Focus on 'food miles' is too narrow, say researchers
'Only 2%' of impact due to transport from farm to shop

The Guardian
June 4, 2007

Consumers need more information about the environmental impact of the
food in their shopping basket if they are to make eco-friendly choices,
according to researchers who have carried out a detailed analysis of the
ecological costs associated with food.

They argue that the focus on "food miles" is missing the bigger picture
and may be counter-productive.

Food stores such as Tesco and Marks & Spencer have said that they will
label products that have been transported by air. But according to the
researchers, only around 2 percent of the environmental impact of food
comes from transporting it from farm to shop.

The vast majority of its ecological footprint comes from food
processing, storage, packaging and growing conditions.

So food grown locally could have a considerably bigger footprint than
food flown halfway around the world, and consumers who make their
choices on air miles alone may be doing more environmental harm,
according to the scientists.

"I'm a bit worried about the food miles [debate] because it is educating
the consumer in the wrong way. It is such an insignificant point," said
Ruth Fairchild at the University of Wales Institute in Cardiff. "Those
[foods] could have been produced using pesticides that have traveled all
the way around the world. If you just take food miles, it is the tiny
bit on the end."

A better system, she argues, would be one that considers all
environmental impacts from farm to dinner plate.

One option is ecological footprint analysis, which takes into account
the amount of land needed to provide the resources to produce food, both
directly on the farm and indirectly from the energy that goes into
growing, harvesting, processing, packaging and transporting it.

A food's impact is measured in "global hectares", the notional land area
needed to produce it. But she thinks that consumers are not yet ready
for ecological footprint labeling and the science behind it is not yet
watertight.

To help confused consumers, Dr Fairchild and colleague Andrea Collins at
Cardiff University have used the ecological footprint concept to develop
a set of eco-diets designed to minimize the impact of food consumption
on the planet.

Sticking to the diets does not mean eating lentils all day, but the most
eco-friendly diet excludes wine, spirits, chocolate, ice cream and most
meat. The study is published in the journal Sustainable Food
Consumption.

The diets are based on an analysis of the ecological footprint
associated with the food consumed by the average Cardiff resident in a
week.

The three diets are progressively more austere in their ecological
footprint, with the most ascetic allowing only foods with a footprint of
less than 0.002 global hectares per kilogram. This meant replacing
around one in six food items with less eco-profligate fare, which had a
similar nutritional makeup. This diet has a 40 percent lower ecological
footprint than the typical Cardiff diet.

Most meat is pushed out of the super-eco-diet because feeding livestock
is energy intensive. Cheese is also out because of the large amounts of
energy that go into processing it and refrigerating it in storage.

The footprint for wine is just too high, while sprits and chocolate have
a per kilogram footprint which is around double the cut-off point.
Bread, vegetables, cakes, biscuits, eggs, pork, ham, bacon and milk are
all acceptable.




<blocked::http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/science/jan-june07/foodfears_06
-01.html>



Natasha
Organically Grown Company

Tellie:  541-461-6466   Fax:  541-689-8768

"Eaters must understand that eating takes place inescapably in the
world, that it is inescapably an agricultural act, and that how we eat
determines, to a considerable extent, how the world is used."  Wendell
Berry








_______________________________________________
Geactivists mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://geaction.org/mailman/listinfo/geactivists_geaction.org


-- 
"Eaters must understand that eating takes place inescapably in the
world, that it is inescapably an agricultural act, and that how we eat
determines, to a considerable extent, how the world is used."
Wendell Berry
_______________________________________________
RSS, archives, subscription & listserv information for:
[email protected]
http://lists.mutualaid.org/mailman/listinfo/sustainabletompkins
free hosting by http://www.mutualaid.org

Reply via email to