June 10, 2007

The Sunday Times

Top scientist says biofuels are scam
Jonathan Leake and Steven Swinford

http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/uk/article1909827.ece

THE government's policy of promoting biofuels for transport will come under
harsh attack this week from one of its senior science advisers.

Roland Clift will tell a seminar of the Royal Academy of Engineering that
the
plan to promote bioethanol and biodiesel produced from plants is a "scam".

Clift, professor of environmental technology at Surrey University, sits on
the
scientific advisory council of Defra, David Miliband's environment
department.

He will tell the seminar that promoting the use of biofuels is likely to
increase greenhouse gas emissions.

Clift's comments will amount to a direct challenge to Miliband, who has
published a strategy promoting biofuels. It coincides with a surge of anger
among environmentalists over the weak pledges on climate change that emerged
from last week's G8 summit.

The audience on Thursday will also include Howard Dalton, Miliband's chief
scientist at Defra, who is expected to speak in defence of biofuels.

Clift said: "Biodiesel is a complete scam because in the tropics the growing
demand is causing forests to be burnt to make way for palm oil and similar
crops.

"We calculate that the land will need to grow biodiesel crops for 70-300
years to compensate for the CO2 emitted in forest destruction."

Clift will also condemn plans to produce British biodiesel from rapeseed,
pointing to research showing the crop generates copious amounts of nitrous
oxide – an even more powerful global warming gas than CO2 The attack comes
as
the government increases its support for biofuels. Next year it will
introduce
a requirement for 3% of all fuel sold on UK forecourts to come from a
renewable
source.

Across the EU the renewable transport fuels obligation will increase this to
5%
by 2010, with the British government pushing for a target of 10%.

Miliband wants British farming to diversify into biofuels. "It is an
important part of our vision for a diversified farming sector," he said in a
recent speech.

The UK Biomass Strategy published last month is, however, also critical of
turning crops into transport fuels, pointing out that this is the least
efficient way of using them. It says that it is most efficient simply to
burn
them.

Clift is not the only government science adviser calling for a rethink on
biofuels. Roger Kemp, who advises the Department for Transport on energy use
in
transport, told a conference last week that using biofuels in transport
would
have no impact on cutting emissions.

In his submission to the Institute of Engineering and Technology's climate
change committee he warned that Britain produced 200m tonnes of CO2 a year
in
transport emissions.

On current trends that will double by 2045 – whereas the government has
pledged to reduce transport emissions to around 90m tonnes by that date.

"We would need to plant a land area twice the size of Britain to get enough
biofuel crops to halve our emissions," said Kemp, professor of engineering
at
Lancaster University. "The numbers simply do not add up."

Kemp and Clift point out that the surging global interest in biofuels
derives
from a "false belief" among politicians that there must be a technical
solution to climate change.

Kemp said: "Underlying all this is the assumption that we have to preserve
the mobility and freedom to travel that we now enjoy at all costs.

"However, when you look at the science of climate change it is clear there
are no such simple solutions. Humanity has to accept that."

A similar message was this weekend emerging from environmentalists as they
denounced the G8 industrialised nations for failing to take action on
climate
change at last week's summit.

Tony Juniper, director of Friends of the Earth, accused the G8 of being
little
more than a "talking shop". He said: "The G8 has a record of putting the
short term interests of rich countries before those of the environment and
developing countries and this year was no exception."

FACTS OF 'GREEN' FUEL

What are biofuels?

Biofuels come from plants: bioethanol from sugars and starches, biodiesel
mainly from rapeseed and palm oil. They are blended with normal fuels,
making
up about 5% of the product.

What are the benefits?

The carbon in biofuels comes from the atmosphere so when they burn that
carbon
is simply rereleased and there is no increase.

What are the concerns?

Biofuel crops take land from growing food and create pressure for
deforestation. Burning forests generates vast amounts of CO2.


-- 
"Eaters must understand that eating takes place inescapably in the
world, that it is inescapably an agricultural act, and that how we eat
determines, to a considerable extent, how the world is used."
Wendell Berry
_______________________________________________
RSS, archives, subscription & listserv information for:
[email protected]
http://lists.mutualaid.org/mailman/listinfo/sustainabletompkins
free hosting by http://www.mutualaid.org

Reply via email to