This excellent article actually made it into The Ithaca Journal yesterday, Wed 
June 13th.

I highly recommend the book mentioned below, Hell And High Water by physicist 
and former energy department official Joseph Romm. I do disagree with him on 
two major points however. He thinks we need more nuclear power though, like Tim 
Flannery, he does not put a major emphasis on it, and he supports cap and trade 
rather than the carbon tax. Romm does an especially good job in discussing why 
thoughtful, responsible scientists are up against it when competing with 
delayer/denyer rhetoric.

Like me, he thinks the word sceptic is too good for most of them. Skeptic 
emplies rational, reasoned debate and dissent;--not manipulating, obfuscating 
and outright lying.

Sorry for any duplicated cross-posting.

Jeanne 


http://www.theithacajournal.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=2007706130320&template=printart


. 

Blame It On Coal


Texas, Wyoming, Alaska among U.S.'s leading polluters

Article published Jun 13, 2007
By Seth Borenstein The Associated Press 

WASHINGTON — America may spew more greenhouse gases than any other country, but 
some states are astonishingly more prolific polluters than others — and it's 
not always the ones you might expect. 

The Associated Press analyzed state-by-state emissions of carbon dioxide from 
2003, the latest U.S. Energy Department numbers available. The review shows 
startling differences in states' contribution to climate change. 

The biggest reason? The burning of high-carbon coal to produce cheap 
electricity. 

* Wyoming's coal-fired power plants produce more carbon dioxide in just eight 
hours than the power generators of more populous Vermont do in a year. 

* Texas, the leader in emitting this greenhouse gas, cranks out more than the 
next two biggest producers combined, California and Pennsylvania, which 
together have twice Texas' population. 

* In sparsely populated Alaska, the carbon dioxide produced per person by all 
the flying and driving is six times the per capita amount generated by 
travelers in New York State. 

“There's no question that some states have made choices to be greener than 
others,” said former top Energy Department official Joseph Romm, author of the 
new book “Hell and High Water” and executive director of a nonprofit energy 
conservation group. 

The disparity in carbon dioxide emissions is one of the reasons there is no 
strong national effort to reduce global warming gases, some experts say. 
National emissions dipped ever so slightly last year, but that was mostly 
because of mild weather, according to the Energy Department. 

“Some states are benefiting from both cheap electricity while polluting the 
planet and make all the rest of us suffer the consequences of global warming,” 
said Frank O'Donnell, director of the Washington environmental group Clean Air 
Watch. “I don't think that's fair at all.” 

He noted that the states putting out the most carbon dioxide are doing the 
least to control it, except for California. 

Several federal and state officials say it's unfair and nonsensical to examine 
individual states' contribution to what is a global problem. 

“If the atmosphere could talk it wouldn't say, ‘Kudos to California, not so 
good to Wyoming',” said assistant energy secretary Alexander “Andy” Karsner. 
“It would say, ‘Stop sending me emissions.”' 

Some coal-burning states note that they are providing electricity to customers 
beyond their borders, including Californians. Wyoming is the largest exporter 
of energy to other states, Gov. Dave Freudenthal told The Associated Press. 

He said two-thirds of the state's carbon footprint “is a consequence of energy 
that is developed to feed the rest of the national economy. That doesn't mean 
that somehow then it's good carbon, I'm just saying that's why those numbers 
come out the way are,” Freudenthal said. 

And the massive carbon dioxide-spewing and power-gobbling refineries of Texas 
and Louisiana fuel an oil-hungry nation, whose residents whine when gasoline 
prices rise. 

However, some of the disparities are stunning. 

On a per-person basis, Wyoming spews more carbon dioxide than any other state 
or any other country: 276,000 pounds of it per capita a year, thanks to burning 
coal, which provides nearly all of the state's electrical power. 

Yet, just next door to the west, Idaho emits the least carbon dioxide per 
person, less than 23,000 pounds a year. Idaho forbids coal power plants. It 
relies mostly on non-polluting hydroelectric power from its rivers. 

Texas, where coal barely edges out cleaner natural gas as the top power source, 
belches almost 1 1/2 trillion pounds of carbon dioxide yearly. That's more than 
every nation in the world except six: the United States, China, Russia, Japan, 
India and Germany. 

Of course, Texas is a very populous state. North Dakota isn't, but its power 
plants crank out 68 percent more carbon dioxide than New Jersey, which has 13 
times North Dakota's residents. 

And while Californians have cut their per-person carbon dioxide emissions by 11 
percent from 1990 to 2003, Nebraskans have increased their per capita emissions 
by 16 percent over the same time frame. 

Officials in Wyoming, North Dakota and Alaska say numbers in their states are 
skewed because of their small populations. But Vermont, Rhode Island and the 
District of Columbia are similar in size and have one-12th the per-capita 
emissions of Wyoming. 

A lot of it comes down to King Coal. 

Burning coal accounts for half of America's electricity. And coal produces more 
carbon dioxide than any other commonly used U.S. fuel source. The states that 
rely the most on coal — Wyoming, North Dakota, West Virginia, Indiana — 
generally produce the most carbon dioxide pollution per person, but also have 
the cheapest electric rates. 

States that shun coal — Vermont, Idaho, California, Rhode Island — and turn to 
nuclear, hydroelectric and natural gas, produce the least carbon dioxide but 
often at higher costs for consumers. 

It's unfair to pin all the blame on the coal-using states, said Washington 
lawyer Jeffrey Holmstead, who as an attorney at Bracewell Giuliani represents 
coal-intensive utilities and refineries. Holmstead is the former Bush 
administration air pollution regulator who ruled that carbon dioxide was not a 
pollutant, a decision that was overturned recently by the U.S. Supreme Court. 

“Coal-fired generation is the most economical, least expensive way to produce 
power almost anywhere in the world,” he said. He argued that outlawing such 
plants would have little overall impact globally; however, the U.S. has long 
been the leading global source of carbon emissions. 

Instead of trying to wean themselves from coal, Texas government officials went 
out of their way to encourage the state's biggest utility, TXU Corp., to plan 
for 11 new coal-burning power plants that would have produced even more carbon 
dioxide. The strategy collapsed when an investor group buying TXU cut a deal 
with environmentalists to drop plans to build most of the coal plants. 

The Texas state agency charged with monitoring the environment declined to 
comment on carbon dioxide emissions. Spokeswoman Andrea Morrow said the gas “is 
not a regulated pollutant.” Frank Maisano, a lobbyist and spokesman for 
Bracewell Giuliani, which also has offices in Texas, defended the state saying, 
“these net exporters of energy are always going to produce more carbon 
dioxide.” 

Emissions from generating electricity account for the largest chunk of U.S. 
greenhouse gases, nearly 40 percent. Transportation emissions are close behind, 
contributing about one-third of U.S. production of carbon dioxide. States with 
mass transit and cities, such as New York, come out cleaner than those with 
wide expanses that rely solely on cars, trucks and airplanes, like Alaska. 

Alaska, which stands out for its carbon dioxide production, also stands out as 
one of the early victims of climate change. Its glaciers are melting, its 
permafrost thawing, and coastal and island villages will soon be swallowed by 
the sea. Alaska ranked No. 1 in per-person emissions for transportation, which 
includes driving, flying, shipping and rail traffic. 

That's not the state's fault, says Tom Chapple, director of the state Division 
of Air Quality. Its sheer expanse requires a lot of air travel. And Anchorage 
ranked No. 2 nationally in air cargo traffic. 

For people who want to reduce their household emissions, or their “carbon 
footprint,” the state where they live really does matter. 

After seeing Al Gore's documentary, “An Inconvenient Truth,” Gregg Cawley used 
one of the many calculators available online to determine his “carbon 
footprint.” The University of Wyoming professor lives in a small one-bedroom 
apartment and drives a moderately efficient Subaru, so he figured he 
contributes less to global warming than the average American. 

But the calculations showed otherwise. They suggested Cawley produces more 
carbon dioxide than most Americans. Even if he reduced his energy consumption, 
the numbers would hardly budge. “My God,” he thought, “what do I have to do to 
my lifestyle to change this?” 

Then he changed his home state in the equation. He took out Wyoming and plugged 
in Washington state. 

“I came in way low. I said, ‘That's the problem. I live in the wrong damn 
state.”' 

That simple hypothetical change of address cut his personal emissions by nearly 
three tons of carbon dioxide a year.

 




Blame It On Coal


Texas, Wyoming, Alaska among U.S.'s leading polluters

Article published Jun 13, 2007
By Seth Borenstein The Associated Press 

WASHINGTON — America may spew more greenhouse gases than any other country, but 
some states are astonishingly more prolific polluters than others — and it's 
not always the ones you might expect. 

The Associated Press analyzed state-by-state emissions of carbon dioxide from 
2003, the latest U.S. Energy Department numbers available. The review shows 
startling differences in states' contribution to climate change. 

The biggest reason? The burning of high-carbon coal to produce cheap 
electricity. 

* Wyoming's coal-fired power plants produce more carbon dioxide in just eight 
hours than the power generators of more populous Vermont do in a year. 

* Texas, the leader in emitting this greenhouse gas, cranks out more than the 
next two biggest producers combined, California and Pennsylvania, which 
together have twice Texas' population. 

* In sparsely populated Alaska, the carbon dioxide produced per person by all 
the flying and driving is six times the per capita amount generated by 
travelers in New York State. 

“There's no question that some states have made choices to be greener than 
others,” said former top Energy Department official Joseph Romm, author of the 
new book “Hell and High Water” and executive director of a nonprofit energy 
conservation group. 

The disparity in carbon dioxide emissions is one of the reasons there is no 
strong national effort to reduce global warming gases, some experts say. 
National emissions dipped ever so slightly last year, but that was mostly 
because of mild weather, according to the Energy Department. 

“Some states are benefiting from both cheap electricity while polluting the 
planet and make all the rest of us suffer the consequences of global warming,” 
said Frank O'Donnell, director of the Washington environmental group Clean Air 
Watch. “I don't think that's fair at all.” 

He noted that the states putting out the most carbon dioxide are doing the 
least to control it, except for California. 

Several federal and state officials say it's unfair and nonsensical to examine 
individual states' contribution to what is a global problem. 

“If the atmosphere could talk it wouldn't say, ‘Kudos to California, not so 
good to Wyoming',” said assistant energy secretary Alexander “Andy” Karsner. 
“It would say, ‘Stop sending me emissions.”' 

Some coal-burning states note that they are providing electricity to customers 
beyond their borders, including Californians. Wyoming is the largest exporter 
of energy to other states, Gov. Dave Freudenthal told The Associated Press. 

He said two-thirds of the state's carbon footprint “is a consequence of energy 
that is developed to feed the rest of the national economy. That doesn't mean 
that somehow then it's good carbon, I'm just saying that's why those numbers 
come out the way are,” Freudenthal said. 

And the massive carbon dioxide-spewing and power-gobbling refineries of Texas 
and Louisiana fuel an oil-hungry nation, whose residents whine when gasoline 
prices rise. 

However, some of the disparities are stunning. 

On a per-person basis, Wyoming spews more carbon dioxide than any other state 
or any other country: 276,000 pounds of it per capita a year, thanks to burning 
coal, which provides nearly all of the state's electrical power. 

Yet, just next door to the west, Idaho emits the least carbon dioxide per 
person, less than 23,000 pounds a year. Idaho forbids coal power plants. It 
relies mostly on non-polluting hydroelectric power from its rivers. 

Texas, where coal barely edges out cleaner natural gas as the top power source, 
belches almost 1 1/2 trillion pounds of carbon dioxide yearly. That's more than 
every nation in the world except six: the United States, China, Russia, Japan, 
India and Germany. 

Of course, Texas is a very populous state. North Dakota isn't, but its power 
plants crank out 68 percent more carbon dioxide than New Jersey, which has 13 
times North Dakota's residents. 

And while Californians have cut their per-person carbon dioxide emissions by 11 
percent from 1990 to 2003, Nebraskans have increased their per capita emissions 
by 16 percent over the same time frame. 

Officials in Wyoming, North Dakota and Alaska say numbers in their states are 
skewed because of their small populations. But Vermont, Rhode Island and the 
District of Columbia are similar in size and have one-12th the per-capita 
emissions of Wyoming. 

A lot of it comes down to King Coal. 

Burning coal accounts for half of America's electricity. And coal produces more 
carbon dioxide than any other commonly used U.S. fuel source. The states that 
rely the most on coal — Wyoming, North Dakota, West Virginia, Indiana — 
generally produce the most carbon dioxide pollution per person, but also have 
the cheapest electric rates. 

States that shun coal — Vermont, Idaho, California, Rhode Island — and turn to 
nuclear, hydroelectric and natural gas, produce the least carbon dioxide but 
often at higher costs for consumers. 

It's unfair to pin all the blame on the coal-using states, said Washington 
lawyer Jeffrey Holmstead, who as an attorney at Bracewell Giuliani represents 
coal-intensive utilities and refineries. Holmstead is the former Bush 
administration air pollution regulator who ruled that carbon dioxide was not a 
pollutant, a decision that was overturned recently by the U.S. Supreme Court. 

“Coal-fired generation is the most economical, least expensive way to produce 
power almost anywhere in the world,” he said. He argued that outlawing such 
plants would have little overall impact globally; however, the U.S. has long 
been the leading global source of carbon emissions. 

Instead of trying to wean themselves from coal, Texas government officials went 
out of their way to encourage the state's biggest utility, TXU Corp., to plan 
for 11 new coal-burning power plants that would have produced even more carbon 
dioxide. The strategy collapsed when an investor group buying TXU cut a deal 
with environmentalists to drop plans to build most of the coal plants. 

The Texas state agency charged with monitoring the environment declined to 
comment on carbon dioxide emissions. Spokeswoman Andrea Morrow said the gas “is 
not a regulated pollutant.” Frank Maisano, a lobbyist and spokesman for 
Bracewell Giuliani, which also has offices in Texas, defended the state saying, 
“these net exporters of energy are always going to produce more carbon 
dioxide.” 

Emissions from generating electricity account for the largest chunk of U.S. 
greenhouse gases, nearly 40 percent. Transportation emissions are close behind, 
contributing about one-third of U.S. production of carbon dioxide. States with 
mass transit and cities, such as New York, come out cleaner than those with 
wide expanses that rely solely on cars, trucks and airplanes, like Alaska. 

Alaska, which stands out for its carbon dioxide production, also stands out as 
one of the early victims of climate change. Its glaciers are melting, its 
permafrost thawing, and coastal and island villages will soon be swallowed by 
the sea. Alaska ranked No. 1 in per-person emissions for transportation, which 
includes driving, flying, shipping and rail traffic. 

That's not the state's fault, says Tom Chapple, director of the state Division 
of Air Quality. Its sheer expanse requires a lot of air travel. And Anchorage 
ranked No. 2 nationally in air cargo traffic. 

For people who want to reduce their household emissions, or their “carbon 
footprint,” the state where they live really does matter. 

After seeing Al Gore's documentary, “An Inconvenient Truth,” Gregg Cawley used 
one of the many calculators available online to determine his “carbon 
footprint.” The University of Wyoming professor lives in a small one-bedroom 
apartment and drives a moderately efficient Subaru, so he figured he 
contributes less to global warming than the average American. 

But the calculations showed otherwise. They suggested Cawley produces more 
carbon dioxide than most Americans. Even if he reduced his energy consumption, 
the numbers would hardly budge. “My God,” he thought, “what do I have to do to 
my lifestyle to change this?” 

Then he changed his home state in the equation. He took out Wyoming and plugged 
in Washington state. 

“I came in way low. I said, ‘That's the problem. I live in the wrong damn 
state.”' 

That simple hypothetical change of address cut his personal emissions by nearly 
three tons of carbon dioxide a year.

 





________________________________________________________________________
AOL now offers free email to everyone.  Find out more about what's free from 
AOL at AOL.com.
_______________________________________________
RSS, archives, subscription & listserv information for:
[email protected]
http://lists.mutualaid.org/mailman/listinfo/sustainabletompkins
free hosting by http://www.mutualaid.org

Reply via email to