Alexander is right, Junipers are fine backbone routers and have many
avantages over Cisco.  The M7i is "officially" positioned as a Cisco
7200 replacement, so it must be somewhere in the same price range.
The look&feel is somewhat different, but practically everybody I talk
to likes the Juniper software much better than Cisco's.  (Compared to
IOS, JUNOS seems to have a higher rate of new features coupled with a
lower rate of new bugs :-)

A minimal box from Cisco to fill your requirements would probably be a
7204VXR with the NPE-G1 processor board.  The NPE-G1 has three onboard
GigE ports, each of which can be equipped with a GBIC (otherwise you
can directly plug a Cat5 cable into each 10/100/1000 port).

Packet forwarding performance will probably not be as good as the
Junipers, because the Junipers do forwarding in ASICs (both IPv4 and
IPv6!), while on these Cisco boxes this is done by the same (but
decently fast) general-purpose CPU that processes all the updates to
your Glorious Full Routing Table.  But you should be fine as long as
you're not running your GigE links at capacity and there are no
high-packet-rate (D)DoS attacks.

If you don't need a full table, the Catalyst 3750 might be an
interesting alternative - this one DOES forwarding in hardware, but
has a small FIB.

If you don't care so much about price and want a really fast small box
(with 10GbE upgrade path), look at the Cisco 7603 OSR.

Please don't misinterpret this as a recommendation for Cisco against
Juniper - as I said Juniper makes fine boxes - but since you asked
about Cisco and I'm more familiar with them...
-- 
Simon.
----------------------------------------------
[EMAIL PROTECTED] Maillist-Archive:
http://www.mail-archive.com/swinog%40swinog.ch/

Reply via email to