Harald,

> But you don't "enable or disable BEEP". You enable or disable
> syslog; syslog happens to use BEEP for its messaging
> protocol. Ditto anything else that uses BEEP; you're still
> enabling the individual protocol.

Are there multiple TCP ports involved? I haven't found this mentioned
anywhere (maybe I overlooked the obvious). As long as it is one port, I
can do it. Even with an IANA assigend syslog-reliable port, I can not
totally guarantee that only syslog is spoken there...

>
> > When a crypting tuning profile is used, the firewall
> > can not even look at the application layer into the
> exchange of BEEP
> > packages. So effectively BEEP will open up a hole in the
> firewall (as
> > does SOAP for HTTP).
>
> HTTP opens a security hole in a firewall, even with a proxy
> server. I have successfully run IP tunnels over HTTP through
> a proxy using off-the-shelf software. This is a red herring, IMO.

This is exactly my concern! And I don't see it is addressed in the
syslog RFC series...

Rainer


Reply via email to