In my original post, I had a typo with Iona as an auto and not Dartmouth. I ran the analysis with Dartmouth though, so all of the analysis is still correct.
Here are the men's qualifiers (by my math) Autos - Stan, Port, Colo, NAU, Minn, Ok St, ND, Mich, Nova, Gtown, Prov, Dart, NC St, W&M, Bama, Tenn, Ark, Tex First round (schools and wins over) Ore - Gtown, W&M, Minn, Bama, Tenn, Dart ASU - Gtown, W&M, Minn, Texas BYU - Gtown, W&M, Minn, Bama, Tenn, Dart CSU - Mich, Gtown, W&M, Minn, Bama, Dart, Tenn Neb - Gtown, W&M, Minn, Tenn, Dart Iowa - Wake - Mich, Gtown, W&M, Minn, Texas Duke - Mich, Gtown, W&M, Minn, Texas Tulane - Baylor - Texas, Tenn Prin - (Whoever is 4th - doesn't matter - results aren't up yet, but it doesn't matter) FSU - Texas, Tenn GA Tech - MSU - Gtown, W&M, Minn, Bama, Tenn, Dart Wisc - Port, Prov, Mich, Gtown, W&M, Minn CSU has most wins, they push in BYU BYU #1 at large, CSU #2 Slot #3 Ore - Gtown, W&M, Minn, Bama, Tenn, Dart, CSU ASU - Gtown, W&M, Minn, Texas AFA - Minn, Nova, Texas, CSU Neb - Gtown, W&M, Minn, Tenn, Dart Iowa - Wake - Mich, Gtown, W&M, Minn, Texas, BYU Duke - Mich, Gtown, W&M, Minn, Texas, BYU Tulane - Baylor - Texas, Tenn Prin - FSU - Texas, Tenn Ga Tech - MSU - Gtown, W&M, Minn, Bama, Tenn, Dart, CSU Wisc - Port, Prov, Mich, Gtown, W&M, Minn, CSU, BYU Wisc has most wins, they push in MSU MSU #3, Wisc #4 Slot #5 Ore - Gtown, W&M, Minn, Bama, Tenn, Dart, CSU, MSU ASU - Gtown, W&M, Minn, Texas AFA - Minn, Nova, Texas, CSU Neb - Gtown, W&M, Minn, Tenn, Dart Iowa - Wake - Mich, Gtown, W&M, Minn, Texas, BYU Duke - Mich, Gtown, W&M, Minn, Texas, BYU Tulane - Baylor - Texas, Tenn Prin - FSU - Texas, Tenn GA Tech - Butler - Gtown, Bama, Dart, Minn, Tenn Oregon has most wins - gets #5 Slot #6 ASU - Gtown, W&M, Minn, Texas, Ore AFA - Minn, Nova, Texas, CSU Neb - Gtown, W&M, Minn, Tenn, Dart Iowa - Wake - Mich, Gtown, W&M, Minn, Texas, BYU, Ore Duke - Mich, Gtown, W&M, Minn, Texas, BYU, Ore Tulane - Baylor - Texas, Tenn Prin - FSU - Texas, Tenn Ga Tech - Butler - Gtown, Bama, Dart, Minn, Tenn Wake and Duke are tied on wins, and also tied head to head - I've worked all the scenarios, and it doesn't matter. If Duke wins the tie break, they push in Wake. If Wake wins, Duke is next at #7 no matter what, based on number of wins Wake gets #6, Duke gets #7 Slot #8 ASU - Gtown, W&M, Minn, Texas, Ore, Wake AFA - Minn, Nova, Texas, CSU, Wake Neb - Gtown, W&M, Minn, Tenn, Dart Iowa - VA - Tulane - Baylor - Texas, Tenn Prin - FSU - Texas, Tenn GA tech Butler - Gtown, Bama, Dart, Minn, Tenn ASU and AFA are tied with # of wins. Next criteria is head to head. ASU beat AFA at Griak, AFA beat ASU at Pre-Nats. Next criteria is common opponents. There are 11 common opponents where they have differing records. ASU has a better record against MSU, BYU, Ore, Neb, Gtown, and W&M (total of 6). AFA has a better record against UCSB, ARIZ, EMU, Nova, and Duke (total of 5). With all other common opponents, they have the same record. Either way, AFA is going to get the next slot. ASU gets slot #8 Slot #9 UCSB - Nova, Duke, ASU, Wake, Texas AFA - Minn, Nova, Texas, CSU, Wake, Duke, ASU Neb - Gtown, W&M, Minn, Tenn, Dart Iowa - Vir - Tulane - Baylor - Texas, Tenn Prin - FSU - Texas, Tenn GA Tech Butler - Gtown, Bama, Dart, Minn, Tenn AFA gets #9 Slot #10 UCSB - Nova, Duke, ASU, Wake, Texas Utah - CSU Neb - Gtown, W&M, Minn, Tenn, Dart, AFA Iowa - Vir - Tulane - Baylor - Texas, Tenn Prin - FSU - Texas, Tenn Ga Tech - Butler - Gtown, Bama, Dart, Minn, Tenn Take Neb #10 Slot #11 UCSB - Nova, Duke, ASU, Wake, Texas Utah - CSU Iowa - Vir - Tulane - Baylor - Texas, Tenn Prin - FSU - Texas, Tenn GaTech - Butler - Gtown, Bama, Dart, Minn, Tenn, Neb Take Butler #11 Slot #12 UCSB - Nova, Duke, ASU, Wake, Texas Utah - CSU Iowa - Vir - Tulane - Baylor - Texas, Tenn Prin - FSU - Texas, Tenn GA Tech - EMU - Nova, Duke, ASU, Wake, Tex UCSB and EMU are tied with wins, UCSB beat EMU head to head. Take UCSB #12 Slot #13 Ariz - Mich, Minn, Nova, Duke, ASU, Wake, Texas Utah - CSU Iowa - Vir - Tulane - Baylor - Texas, Tenn Prin - FSU - Texas, Tenn GA Tech - EMU - Nova, Duke, ASU, Wake, Tex Take AZ #13 - last spot First teams out (in order) are Wash (7 wins), EMU (5 wins), Indiana (3 wins)
