2014-02-17 12:58 GMT+00:00 nounours77 <kuessemondtaegl...@gmail.com>: > Dear Clifford, dear Pierren, > > thanks for your thoughts. Here some answers > > >> What/Who defines what is an Architectural Monument? When I think it is more >> along the lines of what Wikipedia [1] defines as a monument. > > No, I'm not (specifically) talking about specific monuments created for > commemoration purpose. > >> What I think >> of as a building designed by famous architects, it is more along the lines >> of a Frank Gehry building. i.e. The Guggenheim >> Museum > > Yes, this I have in mind, and even "less important". > >> Can you clarify your proposal to help me better understand. (Pics would be >> great.) > > Find 2 examples from the Basel-list under [1] and [2] > >> Also, do you mean an actual import? If so, please make sure the list is >> licensed appropriately for OSM and you discuss on the import mailing list. > > Yes, I'm talking about a specific import. It's part of the import of the > geodata of the State of Basel. Yes, we have explicit right to do so in > written from the government authority [3]. No, I did not intend to discuss it > on the import mailing list, since it's a very local import, I discussed it on > the swiss-talk only.
I'm not going to jump on this but you will very likely be frowned upon for not mentioning it to the imports list. > Pieren: > >> More seriously, is it not something very subjective ? is OSM the right >> place for such list ? At least, "heritage" [1] is based on something >> "verifiable" [2]. > > Yes, it is subjectively what is relevant enough to be tagged in OSM. > The current list is a bit less subjective, since it's the official government > list of the state of Basel which enumerates 36 buildings as being of > architectural interest. Is this verifiable enough? Ah! This official listing sounds much better, to me. You could perhaps use "listed_status" as we do in the UK, if that is appropriate: http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:listed_status > Thinking of it, a solution might be to just create Wikipediapages for all of > the 36 buildings (most are probably already there), and then set the > wikipedia tag to the building? But would that no remove information, since > there are so many wikipedia-tags, how can I get a map of all architectural > monuments in a city? You would need to combine the two datasets. One way of doing this is via linked-data: dbpedia (which gives you data from wikipedia about-boxes, and linkedgeodata which gives you OSM. http://dbpedia.org/ http://linkedgeodata.org/ Dan _______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
