On 16-Jan-17 11:56 PM, Janko Mihelić wrote:
There was a similar topic about memorials and artworks a while ago,
and I mentioned my idea of a tag like sculpture_shape. It would have
values like bust, person_standing, person_sitting, person_on_horse,
abstract and so on. Then there's already a well established tag
subject:wikidata=Qxxx. With those two tags we have the way it looks
(if it's a sculpture), and who/what it's dedicated to.
If a memorial is about a specific battle, data consumers would still
like to know that it is a war_memorial. So subject:wikidata=* (or
subject=*) should point to the specific battle, but some other tag
should explain the broader subject. Maybe topic=* or theme=* with
values like battle, mass_killing, war_hero, notable_person_death,
notable_person_home, notable_event, archeological_finding ...
memorial=stolperstein is fine by me because it describes the shape and
the topic in one tag.
Also memorial:type=plaque, plate, stele, obelisk seem ok to me.
Janko
pon, 16. sij 2017. u 10:06 Martin Koppenhoefer <dieterdre...@gmail.com
<mailto:dieterdre...@gmail.com>> napisao je:
What is the "type" or "kind" of a memorial?
There are currently different ideas crammed together in the
subkeys, some referring to the physical appearance, others
referring to the topic or scope/reason.
E.g. the suggested/documented tags:
memorial:type/memorial=plaque
memorial:type/memorial=plate
memorial:type/memorial=statue
memorial=bust
memorial:type/memorial=stele
memorial=stone
memorial:type/memorial=obelisk
all refer to the physical aspect of the memorial.
The suggested tag:
memorial=war_memorial refers to the topic of the memorial
the suggested tags
memorial:type/memorial=stolperstein
memorial=blue_plaque
because they are very specific, refer to both, the physical aspect
and the topic/scope.
IMHO we should have distinct tags for these properties, because
they occur indepently/are different properties.
Cheers,
Martin
+1
I too would rather see separate tags for the 'use', the construction,
the appearance.
Not being local to any stolperstein that has no meaning to me, I have to
look it up.
A war memorial could be a plaque, an obelisk, a statue, a plate.
A plaque could be for a war, a person, a group of people, a machine, or
an event. Without using another source the information in OSM for this
tag is not very descriptive.
_______________________________________________
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
