Hi Leif, You made me do it! :-) I sort of stole your proposal and started creating a new one. It differs in rather important ways from your proposal, so I preferred not modifying your wiki page. I also think it's important to decouple the (voting for a) full timetable solution from the solution where tags are added to indicate interval during 'opening_hours' or a route, which is a lot more likely to be accepted.
So here goes: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/Public_transport_timetables Please let me know what you think. What I still haven't figured out yet is how to differ weekdays that fall in school holiday periods from "normal" weekdays. So work in progress. Polyglot Op za 3 nov. 2018 om 16:25 schreef Leif Rasmussen <354...@gmail.com>: > Polyglot: > I think that having a timetable relation for each stop is less complicated > than having one per route. There are several advantages to this: > 1) People can easily add a single relation at a time, rather than having > to do the entire line at one time. This could make it much easier to, for > example, have a StreetComplete quest asking "What are the arrival times of > bus X at this bus stop?" iD could also have a field at bus stops with > "arrivals for each parent bus route" that would allow people to seamlessly > create timetable relations. It also makes more features possible in the > future, such as additional tags to each timetable. > 2) The system is easier for newbies to learn to use. > > The disadvantage is that there are now a ton of relations per bus / train > / subway route. Creating these could made easier by a new JOSM plugin. > Also, if someone wanted to delete all timetable relations that are part of > a route, they could simply use this overpass query to download the data > into JOSM and then delete all of the timetable relations: > https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/Dlf > > If people really prefer a single timetable relation for each route, then I > will go with that. > > Julien: > Why not have a "delay"="<amount of time between arrival and departure at > this platform>" tag instead of separate arrivals/departures tags? > > Thanks, > Leif Rasmussen > _______________________________________________ > Tagging mailing list > Tagging@openstreetmap.org > https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging >
_______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging