Le 17.06.19 à 03:53, Joseph Eisenberg a écrit : > we don't label Paris as the geographic center of Ile-de-France.
You confuse the two the Paris label is actually not based on the geography of Ile de France since these are 2 unrelated things except that one is admin_center of the other > Instead, we place the node near the center of the main > business district and historic centre of the city of Paris, this way of doing things is common, but I find it inconsistent. one cannot both say that the label role is arbitrary and replace it with a node whose placement follows a conflict between several unwritten and subjective rules. it would be much more objectifiable to create nodes for the different criteria (historical/economic/administrative/tourism/geodesic centre), possible member of their relation, and each datause could choose its main criterion when these locations are not the same > since this is where everyone can agree is in Paris. Paris maybe, but you are talking about Ile-de-France. where the single node representing "ile de france" should be located ? look at the history of the node, you will see that there is no unanimous opinion, it ends up being positioned where it is most attractive, it is totally arbitrary _______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
