Sven, Thank you for your comments, I appreciate having your involvement in this proposal.
>> 2) Deprecate bbq=* (use barbecue_grill=* instead). > > Well, in practice according to taginfo there are zero campsites featuring an > additional bbq or barbecue_grill tag. Mainly this is used for picnic sites. It's not a common tag; barbecue_grill=* is about equally used but also still rare. But it might be useful for specifying all the features at a tourism=camp_pitch, in addition to picnic sites and the like. The reason for choosing barbecue_grill=* instead of bbq=* is that bbq could imply permission to user your own grill, rather than the presence of a grill which is permanently installed at the feature. > Well if you are about additional tags I would strongly recomend adding > another one which is already supported in http://opencampingmap.org > In Germany there are a lot of campsites which rent pitches on a seasonal or > even yearly base. People often use them as a kind of weekend home. > We call them "Dauercamper" which is likely called "permanent campers" in > english. > As this is quite common here and there are even sites for permanent > residents _only_ I invented a tag called permanent_camping=yes/no/only That's an interesting idea. I don't know much about this concept myself, so it would be better if this were kept separate. Is it like renting a summer cabin, or more like having a permanent spot in a mobile home park (eg for fixed caravans)? I see it's already been used 50 times. Maybe you can make a proposal or a wiki page to document it? https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/w/index.php?title=Key:permanent_camping&action=edit Thank you for your help, -Joseph Eisenberg _______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
