вс, 23 окт. 2022 г., 22:56 Tomas Straupis <tomasstrau...@gmail.com>:
> > As there have been incidents where widespread and basic tags have > been known and widely understood and still some inexperienced people > after several months of "practice" in OSM managed to push changes to > those with devastating effects still visible today it is still a very > good idea to clearly state such "standard" tags and "freeze" them. > > I strongly believe that freezing "main" tags for main landuse, > roads, waterways, buildings, places, MAIN amenities (classes used in > 99% of map/gis products) would allow data consumers to spend less time > on running after changes, reading thousands of letters to identify > possible changes to important tags etc. Very few people care how > colour of a bench is tagged but all care how a lake is tagged. > I suggest alternative solution: some machine readable spec, which defines mapping between stable identifier and tags. For example (XML): <list> <item id="healthcare.hospital" k="amenity" v="hospital" /> <item id="healthcare.hospital" k="healthcare" v="hospital" /> <item id="shop.supermarket" k="shop" v="supermarket" /> <item id="landform.peak" k="natural" v="peak" /> </list> In this example, "healthcare.hospital", "shop.supermarket" and "landform.peak" is stable identifiers. If tag has been replaced, config must be updated. Config may be applied on conversion stage. Regards, Illia.
_______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
