On 27/12/18 16:42, Ewen Hill wrote:
Dion,
   Thanks for your hard work to date and good luck with your trek. I am happy to help you off-line and this is open to conjecture however I would ...
1. Create a single master relation and attach all elements to this
2. Where the track may split into two (e.g into the town/skirting around it) perhaps create alternative more localised relationships
See the existing relation - that has at least 2 alternatives .. one is closed due to the rile range... and not likely to open any time soon. Another is to get around the expensive private ferry from Brooklyn to Pantonga - 2 possiblities.

OSM routes for bushwalking, MTBs, cycling, horse riding, skiing can all be found on that site https://hiking.waymarkedtrails.org/ if they are tagged as routes in OSM.

3. I would attach all benches, seats, potable water points etc. to the master. This will allow users to easily download everything they need. This is probably frowned on however in planning the Munda Biddi Trail attack, I have found this invaluable ... and critical to the planning for water points. Others will disagree.

Yep. Does not go well with a 'route' definition.
If you want this it could be better as a 'site relation' - containing the water, camp, shops etc .. and possibly the route relation too as a member?

4. I would suggest using mapillary to upload some sections of the track where it is complex. You can then upload these images and rework the route accordingly and have the appropriate sign posts. 5. Have fun and enjoy - don't get bogged down in mapping whilst enjoying the trip.

Most, if not all, of the route mapping is done. It is the 'extras' that are missing. Yes there may be some sign posts missing.. but of more importance are water, toilets ... I think camp sites re done.. as are the remote shops.
Remote transport (e.g. Somersby) is not done.

P.S. I'd rather have somewhat cooler regards at this time of year. :)


Ewen

On Thu, 27 Dec 2018 at 15:47, Dion Moult <d...@thinkmoult.com <mailto:d...@thinkmoult.com>> wrote:

    G'day all!

    I've started walking the Great North Walk and was miffed that I
    couldn't
    immediately find a good online map showing the full route from
    Sydney to
    Newcastle. Instead I found incredibly difficult to navigate
    websites, paywalled
    online maps, and maps split up into many smaller pages.

    I decided to walk it myself and create a map for it here:

    https://thinkmoult.com/map-of-the-great-north-walk-sydney-to-newcastle.html

    Out of curiosity, I was wondering what things I can help map while
    I'm on this
    route? I am not currently aware of a single "route" / multi-line
    in the OSM
    database that describes the Great North Walk.

    I considered mapping the sign posts, but they are quite plenty and
    probably of
    little benefit.

    Any ideas?

-- Dion Moult


    _______________________________________________
    Talk-au mailing list
    Talk-au@openstreetmap.org <mailto:Talk-au@openstreetmap.org>
    https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-au



--
Warm Regards

Ewen Hill
Internet Development Australia


_______________________________________________
Talk-au mailing list
Talk-au@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-au

Reply via email to