For the last couple of weeks I have been replacing the portions of the BC coastline which were PGS or CT-dirty imports with the latest CanVec/GeoBase data. I elected to use GeoBase since it's coastlines require less manual processing to get into workable form. This process is now finished, with the exception of the basins that are in the US and have data in GeoBase and the 08OA000 and 08OB000 basins (Haida Gwaii) which are in progress.
Before replacing any coast, I compared it with the GeoBase data for accuracy. For most of BC's 25000 km of coastline the data was PGS data and easily replaced. The only places where there was substantial coastline retained were in Greater Vancouver, Victoria, Nanaimo and Sidney. The quality of the OSM coastline data exceeds that of GeoBase/CanVec in these areas. All the data was run through JOSM's simplify function with a max-error of 1.5m. On later runs, short ways were combined into larger ones after simplification. The search expression "(parent child selected | parent selected) nodes:-1000" was used in doing this. In the process I identified many unmapped rivers where I needed to join two sections of coastline together. Where bing imagery showed a river, I added a brief tracing. Most of the bing imagery was low-resolution Landsat or higher-resolution imagery from the BC government, the same as is found on their openmaps WMS server. In the process, I ran JOSM's validator tool over most of the coastline and fixed other unrelated errors. Statistics: The .osm files were 232 MB on disk before simplification The total number of objects uploaded is approximately 1.5 million Surprisingly, no errors were found by coastcheck in the coastline, indicating my procedures worked There are 47 NHN basins with coastline, varying in complexity and size from 5k nodes before simplification to 150k nodes before simplification _______________________________________________ Talk-ca mailing list Talk-ca@openstreetmap.org http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-ca
