Hi!
Es wird empfohlen, bei Multipolygon-Relationen bevorzugt Tags an der Relation zu setzen und nicht an den einzelnen Ways. Da die meisten Tools sowas noch nicht auswerten können, werden häufig auch zusätzlich die Tags direkt an den Ways gesetzt. Daß man bei solchen Konstrukten schnell die Übersicht verliert, zeigt eine Auswertung, die ich mal in den Lauf von Composer nebenbei eingebaut habe. Sie zeigt die Inkonsistenzen auf, die dabei in kurzer Zeit bereits entstanden sind. Die Liste beinhaltet die Ways nach folgenden Kritierien: - Multipolygon-Relationen in D/A/CH - Es sind Tags an der Relation gesetzt - Es gibt dieselben Tags auch direkt am Objekt - Der Inhalt der Tags an Relation und Way stimmt nicht überein Damit ist nicht mehr klar, was eigentlich gemeint ist bzw. welches Tag ein Tool letztendlich auswertet. bye Nop Conflicting relation tag CLC:code for way 42376705 Conflicting relation tag CLC:code for way 42463894 Conflicting relation tag CLC:code for way 43903898 Conflicting relation tag CLC:id for way 42376705 Conflicting relation tag CLC:id for way 42463894 Conflicting relation tag amenity for way 39685961 Conflicting relation tag amenity for way 39685962 Conflicting relation tag building for way 24595410 Conflicting relation tag building for way 33188113 Conflicting relation tag denomination for way 39671759 Conflicting relation tag landuse for way 25776616 Conflicting relation tag landuse for way 26519445 Conflicting relation tag landuse for way 27606108 Conflicting relation tag landuse for way 27774699 Conflicting relation tag landuse for way 28197648 Conflicting relation tag landuse for way 28462598 Conflicting relation tag landuse for way 30737036 Conflicting relation tag landuse for way 32977366 Conflicting relation tag landuse for way 35089567 Conflicting relation tag landuse for way 35089572 Conflicting relation tag landuse for way 35421524 Conflicting relation tag landuse for way 35797769 Conflicting relation tag landuse for way 39301364 Conflicting relation tag landuse for way 39301371 Conflicting relation tag landuse for way 42317300 Conflicting relation tag name for way 10054545 Conflicting relation tag name for way 13007353 Conflicting relation tag name for way 13207715 Conflicting relation tag name for way 13858691 Conflicting relation tag name for way 15241539 Conflicting relation tag name for way 15587527 Conflicting relation tag name for way 15805019 Conflicting relation tag name for way 15975049 Conflicting relation tag name for way 15976893 Conflicting relation tag name for way 17704533 Conflicting relation tag name for way 18650301 Conflicting relation tag name for way 18825494 Conflicting relation tag name for way 19428440 Conflicting relation tag name for way 21155836 Conflicting relation tag name for way 22737653 Conflicting relation tag name for way 22754798 Conflicting relation tag name for way 23065583 Conflicting relation tag name for way 23118578 Conflicting relation tag name for way 23213319 Conflicting relation tag name for way 23288215 Conflicting relation tag name for way 23321484 Conflicting relation tag name for way 23444432 Conflicting relation tag name for way 23450045 Conflicting relation tag name for way 23837585 Conflicting relation tag name for way 24013646 Conflicting relation tag name for way 24238761 Conflicting relation tag name for way 24262321 Conflicting relation tag name for way 24378138 Conflicting relation tag name for way 24591269 Conflicting relation tag name for way 24694668 Conflicting relation tag name for way 24795974 Conflicting relation tag name for way 24938759 Conflicting relation tag name for way 25196339 Conflicting relation tag name for way 25533205 Conflicting relation tag name for way 25645566 Conflicting relation tag name for way 25791579 Conflicting relation tag name for way 25823946 Conflicting relation tag name for way 26419086 Conflicting relation tag name for way 26443912 Conflicting relation tag name for way 26519445 Conflicting relation tag name for way 26658759 Conflicting relation tag name for way 27066777 Conflicting relation tag name for way 27107749 Conflicting relation tag name for way 27145914 Conflicting relation tag name for way 27633228 Conflicting relation tag name for way 27633269 Conflicting relation tag name for way 27774699 Conflicting relation tag name for way 27774699 Conflicting relation tag name for way 27917646 Conflicting relation tag name for way 27917816 Conflicting relation tag name for way 28005571 Conflicting relation tag name for way 28197648 Conflicting relation tag name for way 28197648 Conflicting relation tag name for way 28359908 Conflicting relation tag name for way 28383739 Conflicting relation tag name for way 28465351 Conflicting relation tag name for way 28475228 Conflicting relation tag name for way 28520237 Conflicting relation tag name for way 28659446 Conflicting relation tag name for way 28692974 Conflicting relation tag name for way 28801457 Conflicting relation tag name for way 28891895 Conflicting relation tag name for way 29255306 Conflicting relation tag name for way 29305519 Conflicting relation tag name for way 29984519 Conflicting relation tag name for way 30070242 Conflicting relation tag name for way 30250840 Conflicting relation tag name for way 30250927 Conflicting relation tag name for way 30265139 Conflicting relation tag name for way 30429839 Conflicting relation tag name for way 30458593 Conflicting relation tag name for way 30472358 Conflicting relation tag name for way 30490491 Conflicting relation tag name for way 30525494 Conflicting relation tag name for way 30563075 Conflicting relation tag name for way 30600820 Conflicting relation tag name for way 30610687 Conflicting relation tag name for way 30610698 Conflicting relation tag name for way 30610699 Conflicting relation tag name for way 30625138 Conflicting relation tag name for way 30737036 Conflicting relation tag name for way 30737036 Conflicting relation tag name for way 30752911 Conflicting relation tag name for way 30837332 Conflicting relation tag name for way 31099976 Conflicting relation tag name for way 31728218 Conflicting relation tag name for way 31777710 Conflicting relation tag name for way 32430389 Conflicting relation tag name for way 32481995 Conflicting relation tag name for way 32764590 Conflicting relation tag name for way 32808408 Conflicting relation tag name for way 32808621 Conflicting relation tag name for way 32860957 Conflicting relation tag name for way 32977366 Conflicting relation tag name for way 32977366 Conflicting relation tag name for way 32992874 Conflicting relation tag name for way 33183376 Conflicting relation tag name for way 33371839 Conflicting relation tag name for way 33771566 Conflicting relation tag name for way 33994412 Conflicting relation tag name for way 3401795 Conflicting relation tag name for way 34477443 Conflicting relation tag name for way 35004264 Conflicting relation tag name for way 35042877 Conflicting relation tag name for way 35081522 Conflicting relation tag name for way 35136377 Conflicting relation tag name for way 35154742 Conflicting relation tag name for way 35383689 Conflicting relation tag name for way 35390807 Conflicting relation tag name for way 35391786 Conflicting relation tag name for way 35417857 Conflicting relation tag name for way 35417858 Conflicting relation tag name for way 35417859 Conflicting relation tag name for way 35442759 Conflicting relation tag name for way 35444199 Conflicting relation tag name for way 35717906 Conflicting relation tag name for way 35717907 Conflicting relation tag name for way 35740790 Conflicting relation tag name for way 35742026 Conflicting relation tag name for way 35776998 Conflicting relation tag name for way 35777001 Conflicting relation tag name for way 35777003 Conflicting relation tag name for way 35777092 Conflicting relation tag name for way 35777412 Conflicting relation tag name for way 35777415 Conflicting relation tag name for way 35777938 Conflicting relation tag name for way 35963169 Conflicting relation tag name for way 35963172 Conflicting relation tag name for way 35998426 Conflicting relation tag name for way 36743984 Conflicting relation tag name for way 36768965 Conflicting relation tag name for way 36785599 Conflicting relation tag name for way 36788096 Conflicting relation tag name for way 36817838 Conflicting relation tag name for way 36817838 Conflicting relation tag name for way 36830781 Conflicting relation tag name for way 36857694 Conflicting relation tag name for way 36857695 Conflicting relation tag name for way 36857699 Conflicting relation tag name for way 36857700 Conflicting relation tag name for way 37135187 Conflicting relation tag name for way 37346389 Conflicting relation tag name for way 37350035 Conflicting relation tag name for way 37350040 Conflicting relation tag name for way 37616185 Conflicting relation tag name for way 37647036 Conflicting relation tag name for way 37677704 Conflicting relation tag name for way 37677704 Conflicting relation tag name for way 37812403 Conflicting relation tag name for way 37826179 Conflicting relation tag name for way 37826180 Conflicting relation tag name for way 37826180 Conflicting relation tag name for way 37826185 Conflicting relation tag name for way 37826189 Conflicting relation tag name for way 37826190 Conflicting relation tag name for way 37826192 Conflicting relation tag name for way 37826193 Conflicting relation tag name for way 37826195 Conflicting relation tag name for way 37826197 Conflicting relation tag name for way 37828464 Conflicting relation tag name for way 37829336 Conflicting relation tag name for way 37829340 Conflicting relation tag name for way 37871622 Conflicting relation tag name for way 38346972 Conflicting relation tag name for way 38346984 Conflicting relation tag name for way 38681129 Conflicting relation tag name for way 38681133 Conflicting relation tag name for way 38771377 Conflicting relation tag name for way 38772490 Conflicting relation tag name for way 38842507 Conflicting relation tag name for way 38882626 Conflicting relation tag name for way 38915632 Conflicting relation tag name for way 38966264 Conflicting relation tag name for way 39028440 Conflicting relation tag name for way 39131710 Conflicting relation tag name for way 39301364 Conflicting relation tag name for way 39301364 Conflicting relation tag name for way 39301371 Conflicting relation tag name for way 39301371 Conflicting relation tag name for way 39322575 Conflicting relation tag name for way 39539949 Conflicting relation tag name for way 39576418 Conflicting relation tag name for way 39590308 Conflicting relation tag name for way 39636647 Conflicting relation tag name for way 40680768 Conflicting relation tag name for way 41863584 Conflicting relation tag name for way 41865674 Conflicting relation tag name for way 42114542 Conflicting relation tag name for way 42114550 Conflicting relation tag name for way 4221342 Conflicting relation tag name for way 42375308 Conflicting relation tag name for way 42467415 Conflicting relation tag name for way 42467416 Conflicting relation tag name for way 42467417 Conflicting relation tag name for way 42467418 Conflicting relation tag name for way 42685064 Conflicting relation tag name for way 42685065 Conflicting relation tag name for way 42761898 Conflicting relation tag name for way 42762837 Conflicting relation tag name for way 42762840 Conflicting relation tag name for way 4305186 Conflicting relation tag name for way 43117799 Conflicting relation tag name for way 43133998 Conflicting relation tag name for way 43315505 Conflicting relation tag name for way 43315510 Conflicting relation tag name for way 43675720 Conflicting relation tag name for way 43937695 Conflicting relation tag name for way 43937696 Conflicting relation tag name for way 43937697 Conflicting relation tag name for way 44468720 Conflicting relation tag name for way 4476995 Conflicting relation tag name for way 4675070 Conflicting relation tag name for way 4743208 Conflicting relation tag name for way 4743246 Conflicting relation tag name for way 4782431 Conflicting relation tag name for way 4901449 Conflicting relation tag name for way 5008858 Conflicting relation tag name for way 5785819 Conflicting relation tag name for way 6244349 Conflicting relation tag name for way 7646336 Conflicting relation tag name for way 7974755 Conflicting relation tag name for way 8031419 Conflicting relation tag name for way 8031453 Conflicting relation tag name for way 8056155 Conflicting relation tag name for way 8077485 Conflicting relation tag name for way 8106950 Conflicting relation tag name for way 8152268 Conflicting relation tag name for way 8457006 Conflicting relation tag name for way 9874123 Conflicting relation tag natural for way 35098890 Conflicting relation tag natural for way 37811858 Conflicting relation tag natural for way 37811859 Conflicting relation tag natural for way 37811861 Conflicting relation tag natural for way 42327199 Conflicting relation tag natural for way 42327210 Conflicting relation tag natural for way 42327214 Conflicting relation tag natural for way 42327216 Conflicting relation tag natural for way 42443881 Conflicting relation tag natural for way 42454466 Conflicting relation tag natural for way 42463917 Conflicting relation tag natural for way 42463925 Conflicting relation tag natural for way 42463930 Conflicting relation tag natural for way 42463932 Conflicting relation tag natural for way 42464911 Conflicting relation tag natural for way 42726179 Conflicting relation tag natural for way 42727499 Conflicting relation tag natural for way 5021351 Conflicting relation tag place for way 10100485 _______________________________________________ Talk-de mailing list Talk-de@openstreetmap.org http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-de