Just to emphasise the points David has made here...

The Definitive Map that each council produces is typically made by
drawing routes over an Ordnance Survey basemap, and therefore contains
IP claimed by OS as well as the council that produced it. OS has
stated that they're happy for councils to release any such derived GIS
data under the OGL, but this doesn't automatically allow us to use the
Definitive Map data in OSM. To use the data, three conditions need to
be met:

1/ The council has to make the GIS data available as a separate map
layer, or display it on top of a suitably licensed (for OSM) basemap.
We can't use the data if it's displayed on top of an OS basemap on the
Council's website, as you'd be referring to OS features to identify
the routes of the paths. (OS has been clear on this point I believe.)

2/ The council needs to formally licence the data under the OGL.
Ideally they would do so in a public statement on their website, or in
a public FOI/EIR/RoPSIR request on WhatDoTheyKnow, so that it's
verifiable. A private communication with an individual OSM Mapper is
less good, but possibly acceptable if the mapper can provide the
evidence somewhere. Whether we should rely on a statement on the
third-party website rowmaps.com is debatable. Personally I don't think
we should unless there's some additional evidence, e.g. a copy of a
letter from the council.

3/ The required attribution statement under the OGL needs to be added
to the Contributors page on the OSM wiki:
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Contributors . (There are already
a number of councils listed there under the "Public Rights of Way Data
from local councils" heading.) The OSM editor adding it to the page
should be satisfied on point 2, as they're effectively warranting to
others that they've checked that the data is ok to use.

For Flintshire, 1 is done, since rowmaps has the data. It's not clear
whether we should be happy with point 2 if the only evidence is a
statement by rowmaps.com. But it would be simple for someone to
contact the council (e.g. through WDTK) to check. In any case, point 3
hasn't been satisfied, so we certainly can't use their GIS data yet.

Best wishes,

Robert.


On Sat, 17 May 2025 at 19:45, David Woolley <[email protected]> wrote:
>
> On 17/05/2025 18:11, Mark Goodge wrote:
> > The basemap is OS. But the overlay is from Flintshire's GIS, and if you
> > click on the overlay line then you get a popup with this data:
> >
> > Code: 401/40A/10
> > Community: Brynford
> > Status: BOAT
> > Length: 654m
>
> I don't see any reference to a licence for the GIS data on the web site
> <https://rightsofway.flintshire.gov.uk/standardmap.aspx>, and the route
> would be a derived work of the OS map, if it has been traced from it.
> Parts of it, on the Flintshire site, seem to very accurately follow a
> dashed line that is on the base map.
>
> <https://osm.mathmos.net/prow/open-data/> appears to show the licence
> state for Flintshire's GIS data as unknown.  Flintshire is NOT listed as
> a contributor, on the OSM contributors page, but would be for their OGL
> data to be used.  The rowmaps reference is hearsay.  However see below.
>
> The interpretation in
> <https://osm.mathmos.net/prow/open-data/use-in-osm.html> does suggest
> that OS will waive the fact that council provided data is actually a
> derived work, but OSM still requires that the council have explicitly
> released it, under an acceptable licence, and is included in the list of
> contributors.

--
Robert Whittaker
https://www.openstreetmap.org/user/Robert%20Whittaker
https://osm.mathmos.net/

_______________________________________________
Talk-GB mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-gb

Reply via email to