On Dec 22, 2007 2:46 AM, Andy Robinson (blackadder) <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Karl Newman [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote > >Sent: 22 December 2007 6:02 AM > >To: Andy Robinson > >Cc: David James; [email protected] > >Subject: Re: [OSM-talk] Featured images for christmas week > > > >On Dec 21, 2007 6:43 PM, Andy Robinson <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > >wrote: > >> > >> We thrashed out ideas on th wiki the other day and decided upon the > >following: > >> > >> The buiding areas are tagged with building=residential (or > >> building=whatever if its something else) > >> > >> The nodes are also tagged with buidling=residential and have an > >> additional ref=# on them for the house number. > >> > >> Will document this in Map Features if it looks to work out ok once > >rendered. > >> > >> Cheers > >> > >> Andy > >> -- > >> Andy Robinson > >> > > > >Okay, that will work for numbering buildings and showing the number on > >a map. The argument I'm having on the Wiki is more for house numbering > >which can be used for address interpolation along a street. GPS > >devices use this sort of numbering (which is my intended application). > > > > Yes, its something I've noted that the house numbers are often too close to > more than one street to be sure which street they belong to on a proximity > basis. If the nodes are always within a building area then that area in the > majority of cases can be linked to its street through proximity. There are > however some exceptions, especially buildings which bound more than one > road. So it would be necessary to add specific information to either the > building or the node to identify the street in these cases but it should be > possible to get to the majority of locations without adding a pile of extra > tags. Beyond that it should be possible to use a proximity basis for all > other data (town, region etc). > > There is also the issue of whether every property number is required. I find > that when using off-the-shelf navigation products they can generally take me > to the end of the correct drive. But I find I'm driving so slowly by that > point I could have worked it out anyway. So do we really need every unique > address? Probably not. For the vast majority of cases an interpolation > between the start and end number on a continuous run of property (whether > odd, even or mixed) should be enough to work out the intermediate properties > with sufficient accuracy for routing. Oddball properties or properties with > names alone will be in the database individually anyway. > > Of course if the unique postal_code is added to a node or area that gives an > extra method for location resolution potential. > > Cheers > > Andy > >
You might want to take a look at my proposal here: http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/index.php/Proposed_features/House_numbers#Third_Suggestion_.28Using_relations.29 Without a topologically-associated solution such as I've proposed, it will be very difficult to get the numbers associated with the streets at the correct points for use in navigational devices (and that's a big reason we're entering street numbers, right?). Karl (SiliconFiend) _______________________________________________ talk mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/talk

